Roe v. Wade
Roe v. Wade
Legal decision
By: U.S. Supreme Court
Date: January 22, 1973
Source: Roe v. Wade 410 U.S. 113 (1973). Available at: ?http://supreme.justia.com/us/410/113/case.html? (accessed April 12, 2006).
About the Author: At the time of the Roe v. Wade decision, the U.S. Supreme Court was composed of Justices Warren Burger (Chief), William Douglas, William Brennan, Potter Stewart, Byron White, Thurgood Marshall, Harry Blackmun, Lewis F. Powell, and William Rehnquist. Justice Harry Blackmun, a Republican, served on the court from 1970–1994. Appointed to the court by President Richard Nixon, Blackmun's most famous written opinion for the court is Roe v. Wade. Blackmun continued to support abortion rights until his death in 1999.
INTRODUCTION
Abortion was legal in the United States from the country's founding until the 1820s, when some states began to pass legislation limiting the procedure. English common law, which provided the basis for many laws in the United States, had treated abortion before "quickening" or the feeling of fetal movement, as a misdemeanor, but post-quickening abortion was considered a felony or a capital offense. An 1803 English law, The Miscarriage of Women Act, made pre-quickening abortion a felony and post-quickening abortion a capital crime. American states began to follow England in codifying abortion law by the 1820s.
In 1861, England passed the Offenses Against the Person Act, declaring all abortions felonies, and, in 1869, Pope Pius IX, leader of the Roman Catholic Church, declared all abortion, regardless of circumstance or timing, to be grounds for excommunication. In addition, the Pope stated that any person involved in the act—including medical personnel and husbands—had also separated themselves from the Catholic Church by virtue of their choice.
By the early 1900s, abortion was illegal throughout most of the United States. Illegal abortions were commonly performed by midwives, some doctors, or any person who chose to perform the procedure; the practice was unregulated. Because abortion was criminalized, there were few incentives to report corrupt, "back alley" abortion providers or to name them should a complication arise. Many such abortion providers charged large sums of money, performed the procedure with unsterilized equipment, and provided no follow-up care to check for infection, retained tissue, or other complications.
In the 1920s and 1930s, economic crises in the United States, coupled with the difficulty of accessing affordable birth control, led many women to seek abortions. Although abortion was illegal, many states had a clause permitting a physician to perform the procedure if the mother's life was in jeopardy. The American Medical Association had lobbied for criminalization of abortion in the late 1800s and early 1900s with a dual purpose of driving non-medical abortion providers out of business and making the procedure safer by forcing it to be performed by physicians only.
In 1935, Iceland became the first western country to permit abortions under certain specific medical circumstances; other countries, such as Britain, Canada, and Australia, followed throughout the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s. In the United States, California and Colorado both made abortion legal in 1967, and New York decriminalized abortion in 1970.
Anti-choice advocates argued that life begins at conception, and ending that life is equivalent to murder. The Roman Catholic Church held this position as well. By 1970, when the Roe v. Wade case was filed, thirty-one states permitted abortion when the mother's life was in danger, and women seeking abortions often traveled across state lines or into Canada to seek elective abortions.
Norma McCorvey, the "Jane Roe" in Roe v. Wade, filed a lawsuit in Texas on the grounds that Texas law criminalizing abortion violated her rights under the First, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth, and Fourteenth Amendments. Abortion rights proponents had been searching for a case to take through the courts that would stand through repeated court battles; attorneys Sarah Weddington and Linda Coffee believed Norma McCorvey's case was the right choice. McCorvey claimed that her pregnancy was the result of a rape, a condition that some states would have accepted as justification for the abortion. Weddington did not make that fact public during the court case.
The case made its way to the U.S. Supreme Court in December 1971, but after initial arguments the court decided to have it reargued, to give new justices William Rehnquist and Lewis Powell the opportunity to hear the case. In October 1972, the U.S. Supreme Court heard the case again, and in January handed down its ruling, declaring the Texas state law banning abortion unconstitutional.
PRIMARY SOURCE
VIII
….This right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment's concept of personal liberty and restrictions upon state action, as we feel it is, or, as the District Court determined, in the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass a woman's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy. The detriment that the State would impose upon the pregnant woman by denying this choice altogether is apparent. Specific and direct harm medically diagnosable even in early pregnancy may be involved. Maternity, or additional offspring, may force upon the woman a distressful life and future. Psychological harm may be imminent. Mental and physical health may be taxed by child care. There is also the distress, for all concerned, associated with the unwanted child, and there is the problem of bringing a child into a family already unable, psychologically and otherwise, to care for it. In other cases, as in this one, the additional difficulties and continuing stigma of unwed motherhood may be involved. All these are factors the woman and her responsible physician necessarily will consider in consultation.
On the basis of elements such as these, appellant and some amici argue that the woman's right is absolute and that she is entitled to terminate her pregnancy at whatever time, in whatever way, and for whatever reason she alone chooses. With this we do not agree. Appellant's arguments that Texas either has no valid interest at all in regulating the abortion decision, or no interest strong enough to support any limitation upon the woman's sole determination, are unpersuasive. The [410 U.S. 113, 154] Court's decisions recognizing a right of privacy also acknowledge that some state regulation in areas protected by that right is appropriate. As noted above, a State may properly assert important interests in safeguarding health, in maintaining medical standards, and in protecting potential life. At some point in pregnancy, these respective interests become sufficiently compelling to sustain regulation of the factors that govern the abortion decision. The privacy right involved, therefore, cannot be said to be absolute. In fact, it is not clear to us that the claim asserted by some amici that one has an unlimited right to do with one's body as one pleases bears a close relationship to the right of privacy previously articulated in the Court's decisions. The Court has refused to recognize an unlimited right of this kind in the past. Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905) (vaccination); Buck v. Bell, 274 U.S. 200 (1927) (sterilization).
We, therefore, conclude that the right of personal privacy includes the abortion decision, but that this right is not unqualified and must be considered against important state interests in regulation.
….Although the results are divided, most of these courts have agreed that the right of privacy, however based, is broad enough to cover the abortion decision; that the right, nonetheless, is not absolute and is subject to some limitations; and that at some point the state interests as to protection of health, medical standards, and prenatal life, become dominant. We agree with this approach.
….In the recent abortion cases, cited above, courts have recognized these principles. Those striking down state laws have generally scrutinized the State's interests in protecting health and potential life, and have concluded that neither interest justified broad limitations on the reasons for which a physician and his pregnant patient might decide that she should have an abortion in the early stages of pregnancy. Courts sustaining state laws have held that the State's determinations to protect health or prenatal life are dominant and constitutionally justifiable.
IX
The District Court held that the appellee failed to meet his burden of demonstrating that the Texas statute's infringement upon Roe's rights was necessary to support a compelling state interest, and that, although the appellee presented "several compelling justifications for state presence in the area of abortions," the statutes outstripped these justifications and swept "far beyond any areas of compelling state interest." 314 F. Supp., at 1222-1223. Appellant and appellee both contest that holding. Appellant, as has been indicated, claims an absolute right that bars any state imposition of criminal penalties in the area. Appellee argues that the State's determination to recognize and protect prenatal life from and after conception constitutes a compelling state interest. As noted above, we do not agree fully with either formulation.
A. The appellee and certain amici argue that the fetus is a "person" within the language and meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. In support of this, they outline at length and in detail the well-known facts of fetal development. If this suggestion of personhood is established, the appellant's case, of course, collapses, [410 U.S. 113, 157] for the fetus' right to life would then be guaranteed specifically by the Amendment. The appellant conceded as much on reargument. On the other hand, the appellee conceded on reargument that no case could be cited that holds that a fetus is a person within the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment….
B. The pregnant woman cannot be isolated in her privacy. She carries an embryo and, later, a fetus, if one accepts the medical definitions of the developing young in the human uterus. See Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary 478-479, 547 (24th ed. 1965). The situation therefore is inherently different from marital intimacy, or bedroom possession of obscene material, or marriage, or procreation, or education, with which Eisenstadt and Griswold, Stanley, Loving, Skinner, and Pierce and Meyer were respectively concerned. As we have intimated above, it is reasonable and appropriate for a State to decide that at some point in time another interest, that of health of the mother or that of potential human life, becomes significantly involved. The woman's privacy is no longer sole and any right of privacy she possesses must be measured accordingly.
Texas urges that, apart from the Fourteenth Amendment, life begins at conception and is present throughout pregnancy, and that, therefore, the State has a compelling interest in protecting that life from and after conception. We need not resolve the difficult question of when life begins. When those trained in the respective disciplines of medicine, philosophy, and theology are unable to arrive at any consensus, the judiciary, at this point in the development of man's knowledge, is not in a position to speculate as to the answer. [410 U.S. 113, 160].
It should be sufficient to note briefly the wide divergence of thinking on this most sensitive and difficult question. There has always been strong support for the view that life does not begin until live birth. This was the belief of the Stoics. It appears to be the predominant, though not the unanimous, attitude of the Jewish faith. It may be taken to represent also the position of a large segment of the Protestant community, insofar as that can be ascertained; organized groups that have taken a formal position on the abortion issue have generally regarded abortion as a matter for the conscience of the individual and her family. As we have noted, the common law found greater significance in quickening. Physicians and their scientific colleagues have regarded that event with less interest and have tended to focus either upon conception, upon live birth, or upon the interim point at which the fetus becomes "viable," that is, potentially able to live outside the mother's womb, albeit with artificial aid. Viability is usually placed at about seven months (28 weeks) but may occur earlier, even at 24 weeks. The Aristotelian theory of "mediate animation," that held sway throughout the Middle Ages and the Renaissance in Europe, continued to be official Roman Catholic dogma until the 19th century, despite opposition to this "ensoulment" theory from those in the Church who would recognize the existence of life from [410 U.S. 113, 161] the moment of conception. The latter is now, of course, the official belief of the Catholic Church. As one brief amicus discloses, this is a view strongly held by many non-Catholics as well, and by many physicians. Substantial problems for precise definition of this view are posed, however, by new embryological data that purport to indicate that conception is a "process" over time, rather than an event, and by new medical techniques such as menstrual extraction, the "morning-after" pill, implantation of embryos, artificial insemination, and even artificial wombs.
In areas other than criminal abortion, the law has been reluctant to endorse any theory that life, as we recognize it, begins before live birth or to accord legal rights to the unborn except in narrowly defined situations and except when the rights are contingent upon live birth. For example, the traditional rule of tort law denied recovery for prenatal injuries even though the child was born alive. That rule has been changed in almost every jurisdiction. In most States, recovery is said to be permitted only if the fetus was viable, or at least quick, when the injuries were sustained, though few [410 U.S. 113, 162] courts have squarely so held. In a recent development, generally opposed by the commentators, some States permit the parents of a stillborn child to maintain an action for wrongful death because of prenatal injuries. Such an action, however, would appear to be one to vindicate the parents' interest and is thus consistent with the view that the fetus, at most, represents only the potentiality of life. Similarly, unborn children have been recognized as acquiring rights or interests by way of inheritance or other devolution of property, and have been represented by guardians ad litem. Perfection of the interests involved, again, has generally been contingent upon live birth. In short, the unborn have never been recognized in the law as persons in the whole sense.
X
In view of all this, we do not agree that, by adopting one theory of life, Texas may override the rights of the pregnant woman that are at stake. We repeat, however, that the State does have an important and legitimate interest in preserving and protecting the health of the pregnant woman, whether she be a resident of the State or a nonresident who seeks medical consultation and treatment there, and that it has still another important and legitimate interest in protecting the potentiality of human life. These interests are separate and distinct. Each grows in substantiality as the woman approaches [410 U.S. 113, 163] term and, at a point during pregnancy, each becomes "compelling."
With respect to the State's important and legitimate interest in the health of the mother, the "compelling" point, in the light of present medical knowledge, is at approximately the end of the first trimester. This is so because of the now-established medical fact, referred to above at 149, that until the end of the first trimester mortality in abortion may be less than mortality in normal childbirth. It follows that, from and after this point, a State may regulate the abortion procedure to the extent that the regulation reasonably relates to the preservation and protection of maternal health. Examples of permissible state regulation in this area are requirements as to the qualifications of the person who is to perform the abortion; as to the licensure of that person; as to the facility in which the procedure is to be performed, that is, whether it must be a hospital or may be a clinic or some other place of less-than-hospital status; as to the licensing of the facility; and the like.
This means, on the other hand, that, for the period of pregnancy prior to this "compelling" point, the attending physician, in consultation with his patient, is free to determine, without regulation by the State, that, in his medical judgment, the patient's pregnancy should be terminated. If that decision is reached, the judgment may be effectuated by an abortion free of interference by the State.
With respect to the State's important and legitimate interest in potential life, the "compelling" point is at viability. This is so because the fetus then presumably has the capability of meaningful life outside the mother's womb. State regulation protective of fetal life after viability thus has both logical and biological justifications. If the State is interested in protecting fetal life after viability, it may go so far as to proscribe abortion [410 U.S. 113, 164] during that period, except when it is necessary to preserve the life or health of the mother.
Measured against these standards, Art. 1196 of the Texas Penal Code, in restricting legal abortions to those "procured or attempted by medical advice for the purpose of saving the life of the mother," sweeps too broadly. The statute makes no distinction between abortions performed early in pregnancy and those performed later, and it limits to a single reason, "saving" the mother's life, the legal justification for the procedure. The statute, therefore, cannot survive the constitutional attack made upon it here.
SIGNIFICANCE
The court interpreted the right to obtain an abortion as an issue of personal privacy, grounded in the Fourteenth Amendment. In addition, Blackmun's written decision rejected the Texas law's claim that life begins at conception; the court ruled that viability, or the fetus's ability to live outside the womb, was the better benchmark for state involvement in regulating abortion.
Roe v. Wade set clear guidelines on the state's ability to set limits on abortion based on the viability of the fetus. (In 1973, a fetus was considered to be viable at approximately twenty-eight weeks of gestation.) Until the age of viability had passed, women could legally obtain abortions on demand. Once the fetus was viable, the state could place restrictions on abortion.
Within seven years, European countries such as France, Italy, West Germany, and the Netherlands legalized abortion. In the United States, individual states responded to the Roe v. Wade decision by passing laws that required parental notification, informed consent, "cooling off" periods of twenty-four or more hours between the first consultation with an abortion provider and the actual procedure, and specific counseling information requirements.
The 1992 case Planned Parenthood v. Casey revisited Roe and provided a new court that included appointees from conservative presidents Ronald Reagan and George H. W. Bush with the opportunity to overturn Roe. Many legal scholars had argued that the U.S. Supreme Court had created a privacy right in the Fourteenth Amendment, arguing strenuously with the court's use of that justification for Roe. In Planned Parenthood v. Casey the court struck down portions of Pennsylvania's abortion restrictions, such as spousal notification laws, but upheld parental consent and "cooling off" periods. Anti-choice and pro-choice advocates alike had expected the court to overturn Roe; the court, however, did not do so.
Technological advances, such as RU-486, an abortion pill protocol, and neonatal care for premature infants have blurred the lines set by Roe in 1973. Viability comes at earlier stages more than thirty years after the Roe v. Wade decision was published; ten to forty percent of all babies born at twenty-three weeks survive, and survival rates increase to fifty to eighty percent for babies born at twenty-five weeks.
In February 2006, South Dakota passed a state law banning all abortions, with the only exception being to save the life of the mother. In April 2006, legislators in Ohio crafted a law making abortion illegal and criminalizing those who cross state lines for the purpose of obtaining an abortion. While Roe v. Wade struck down such laws in 1973, more than thirty years later the debate continues.
FURTHER RESOURCES
Books
Hull, N. E. H., and Peter Charles Hoffer. Roe V. Wade: The Abortion Rights Controversy in American History. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2001.
Solinger, Rickie. Abortion Wars: A Half Century of Struggle, 1950–2000. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998.
Weddington, Sarah. A Question of Choice. New York: Penguin, 1993.
