Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Type of Government
The government of Russia operates under a super-presidential system that grants broad powers to the elected head of state, the president. The president appoints and shares executive powers with the prime minister, who is the head of the government. The legislative branch includes a bicameral assembly, the upper chamber of which comprises a Federation Council made up of representatives from geographical areas. The lower house, the State Duma, holds the authority to confirm the appointment of the prime minister in addition to its legislative functions. Following more than sixty years of Communist rule during the twentieth century, democracy brought stunning changes to Russia in the 1990s, but perhaps none so surprising as a return to an autocratic style of leadership under President Vladimir Putin (1952–), who has taken full advantage of the authorities granted him by the constitution.
Background
Stretching across 6.6 million square miles and eleven time zones, Russia is the world’s largest country in area, and ranked sixth in population with 142 million people. Just over 80 percent of its citizens identify themselves as ethnic Russians, with the remaining 20 percent consisting of minorities from the former Soviet republics. Its origins as a state date back to the ninth-century founding of Kievan Rus in nearby Ukraine, the first unified entity of the Eastern Slavic tribes. By the 1400s the center of power had shifted from the city of Kiev to the more heavily fortified settlement in Moscow. Rulers there began using the title of “czar,” the Russian-language variant of “caesar,” and carried out an ambitious expansion program that established autocratic rule across a vast empire stretching from Europe to the Pacific Ocean.
St. Petersburg, built by Czar Peter the Great (1672–1725), was the opulent capital of imperial Russia after 1712, and it was there that the Romanov dynasty was overthrown in 1917 during World War I. A seizure of power by Communist hardliners known as the Bolsheviks followed later that year, and the new government re-established Moscow as the capital. The terms “Russia,” “Soviet Union,” and “USSR” (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) have often been used interchangeably, but technically Russia (as the Russian Soviet Federated Socialist Republic, or RSFSR), was only the largest of the constituent Soviet republics during the Soviet period. It was also the most powerful, and the Communist Russian elite who ruled it and the rest of the Union enjoyed privileged status. The control maintained by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) began to wane with the introduction of reforms by Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev (1931–) after 1985, and the first multiparty elections since 1917 were held in March 1990. Three months later, the RSFSR’s new parliament, the Congress of People’s Deputies, issued a declaration of sovereignty. A year later, in June 1991, the first presidential elections in the RSFSR took place, and an outspoken, reform-minded former Communist official named Boris Yeltsin (1931–2007) won the office by a landslide.
Yeltsin played a crucial role in the dissolution of the Soviet Union following an attempted coup by Communist Party operatives against Gorbachev in August 1991. With that event, the individual constituent republics began declaring independence, and the economic situation became perilous. Yeltsin responded by transferring Soviet assets, institutions, and authorities to Russian control over the next three months, and outlawed the Communist Party for its role in the failed coup. Citing a 1922 Treaty on the Creation of the Soviet Union, which contained a clause permitting the constituent republics to secede, Yeltsin and the leaders of Ukraine and Belarus signed the Belavezha Accords on December 8, 1991, followed several days later by a meeting with leaders of Soviet republics in Central Asia. The end result of these agreements was the formal dissolution of the Soviet Union and the establishment of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) in its stead. Gorbachev resigned on December 25.
Government Structure
During its first two years in existence, Russia was governed by a 1978 Soviet-era constitution, although this was amended in several sections in order to allow for significant changes to the country’s political and economic structure. The new Russian Constitution was approved by referendum on December 12, 1993. Under it the president holds the right to dissolve parliament, has the power to initiate national referenda, and is granted immunity from prosecution. He or she is elected to a four-year term by direct vote and is limited to two terms. The prime minister serves as head of government and is appointed by the president but subject to a confirmation vote by the lower house of the legislature. In theory, impeachment of a president is possible in the event of high treason or other serious crimes, but the stringent process requires actions by both houses of the legislature, the Supreme Court, and the Constitutional Court, making a legal ouster unlikely in practice.
Russia’s bicameral parliament is jointly referred to as the Federal Assembly. Its upper chamber is the 178-seat Federation Council, which consists of two deputies from each of Russia’s 89 administrative divisions. The 1993 constitution did not specify how the Federation Council was to be chosen, and initially the membership included regional governors and leaders of regional assemblies. When Putin came to power in 2000, however, he overhauled the selection system, providing for the election of the Federation Council deputies by the regional assemblies.
The lower house of Russia’s Federal Assembly is the State Duma, with 450 seats. Half of them are allocated to candidates from single-mandate constituencies who won a majority vote in legislative elections, and the other 225 come from party lists of candidates. These latter 225 seats are allocated on a proportional basis according to election tallies, and parties must receive a minimum of 7 percent in the popular vote in order to qualify for seats. The deputies of the State Duma serve four-year terms, and may issue a no-confidence vote in the current government, appoint or dismiss the head of the Central Bank, and initiate legislation—although this last power is not exclusively theirs. The Constitution grants deputies of the lower house the right to override decisions of the Federation Council by a two-thirds vote, and presidential vetoes may be nullified with the same percentage in a joint vote of both houses.
The judicial branch in Russia is blighted by pervasive corruption and attempts by elected officials to influence outcomes. Both are a legacy of the Soviet era, when the judiciary functioned as a rubber-stamp body for the policies of the Communist Party. At the top of the post-Soviet judiciary is a Constitutional Court, charged with reviewing legislation, presidential decrees, and international treaties. Its nineteen judges are appointed by the president and confirmed by a vote of the Federation Council, as are the justices of the Supreme Court, which is the final court of appeal for criminal and civil cases. The number of judges on the Supreme Court is not fixed by the constitution, but they are appointed in the same manner as the Constitutional Court. This appointment process also applies to the High Court of Arbitration, which hears commercial disputes. Russian law does not recognize the principle of judicial precedent (abiding by previous court decisions) in issuing rulings. Criminal-case conviction rates in Russia are abnormally high, generally estimated above 95 percent, and judges who acquit defendants are often targeted for review or dismissal. Jury trials have been introduced in some regions and have a slightly higher acquittal rate than trials decided from the bench; however, jury trials comprise only a small percentage of criminal trials in Russia and have been more likely to be overturned on appeal by the state.
Russia is divided into eighty-nine administrative regions, covering six territories known as kraya; ten okruga, or autonomous districts; twenty-one ethnic enclaves; fifty oblasts, or provinces; and two municipal districts, St. Petersburg and Moscow. These regions have historically battled with the Moscow government over certain governance issues. During the early years of the Russian Federation, Yeltsin bested his political opponents in Moscow by winning support from regional politicians, to whom he granted greater autonomy in return for their help. However, this policy eventually intensified separatist sentiments in some of the eighty-nine regions. When Putin came to power he reasserted federal authority by establishing seven super-regions, called federalnyye okruga, which are Northwest, Central, Volga, North Caucasus, Ural, Siberia, and Far East. A plenipotentiary representative, or presidential envoy, is appointed by Putin to oversee each of them, and these loyalists wield a great deal of administrative power over locally elected officials.
Political Parties and Factions
Political parties have failed to achieve any genuine status in Russia, which observers link to the country’s long history of absolute monarchy and then one-party rule. New parties are usually formed before legislative elections, but then dissolve. For the 1993 elections, the Russia’s Choice Party was created, followed two years later by the Our Home Is Russia Party. The Unity Party won eighty-two seats in the State Duma in 1999, and was the bloc that backed Putin’s ascension to power. It evolved into the United Russia Party in 2003 in time for parliamentary elections, in which it won 222 seats. The Communist Party has continued to win a substantial number of seats in each election since independence.
In the mid 1990s a group of newly rich entrepreneurs began to influence Russian politics. They had typically accrued their fortunes from privatization deals in which Yeltsin’s government sold off the formerly state-run industries during Russia’s transition to a free-market economy. Accordingly, they backed Yeltsin in his 1996 presidential re-election bid. They did the same for Putin in the 2000 race, but once elected the new president swiftly moved to end their influence. Some of the oligarchs were arrested, and others fled the country. Russia’s wealthiest citizen, Mikhail Khodorkovsky (1963–), who was chair of the Yukos petroleum company is the best-known example. Khodorkovsky had publicly stated his support for increased transparency and democracy in Russia, and had strong connections to financial powers outside the country. He was arrested in 2003, put on trial, and sentenced to nine years in prison for fraud and tax evasion. Meanwhile, Yukos’s assets were frozen by Putin’s government, and the company was later declared by authorities to be bankrupt.
Major Events
Russia’s fragile democracy has faced threats on several fronts since Communist rule ended in the early 1990s. Yeltsin’s reform program met with serious opposition from Communists in the Russian Supreme Soviet, and in September 1993 he ordered that body dissolved. When the deputies refused to budge, troops were sent in to oust them. In 1994 a separatist war broke out in Chechnya, a predominantly Muslim area of the Caucasus that had declared its independence from Russia, and Chechen rebels battled Russian troops over the next two years.
In 1996 Yeltsin was reelected, but he suffered a heart attack between the first round of balloting and a run-off election—a perilous situation kept secret from the public for a time, which left the government essentially rudderless. A year later, a recovered Yeltsin concluded a peace treaty with the Chechen rebels specifying that a decision on Chechnya’s status would be delayed until 2002. In 1998 Russia teetered on the brink of financial disaster with the collapse of the ruble, but a serious economic crisis was averted. Yeltsin still faced major opposition and resigned on December 31, 1999, in a surprise announcement. Putin was prime minister at the time and automatically became acting president. He was elected by direct vote in March 2000.
Putin’s government resumed the war in Chechnya, despite the terms of the 1997 peace accord, after an apartment building in Moscow was the target of a supposed Chechen terrorist attack in 1999. The war escalated in October 2002 after the seizure of a Moscow theater during a performance; 850 audience members and theater personnel were held hostage, and more than 150 people died in the incident. In September 2004 nearly four hundred people were killed in an attack by Chechen separatists on a school in Beslan, a city in the autonomous republic of North Ossetia. Most of the fatalities in the incident resulted when Russian special forces took action against the hostage-takers, who were holding about twelve hundred adults and children at gunpoint in the school gymnasium. Putin’s tough tactics against Chechen rebels in these crises prompted concern that he was reestablishing a dictatorial-style regime in Russia. One outspoken critic of his policies was the journalist Anna Politkovskaya (1958–2006), who was fatally shot in the elevator of her Moscow apartment building in October 2006 in what appeared to be a contract killing. Weeks later, Alexander Litvinenko (1962–2006), a former officer in the Russian state security service, died in London, England, where he had been living. Litvinenko had publicly accused Putin of responsibility for Politkovskaya’s death, and British authorities launched a massive investigation that tied his death to poisoning by radiation after he met with a Russian operative linked to the Federal Security Service, known by its Russian-language acronym FSB.
Twenty-First Century
The Russian economy was growing at a pace of more than 6 percent annually in 2007 due in large part to its natural resources industries, including exports of oil, gas, timber, and metals. Because of the rapid economic growth, observers warned that the country’s low birth rate and demographic shifts may result in a shortage of workers within the next decade. In addition, labor migration within Russia has led to ethnic tensions and was blamed for an increase in hate crimes. As of 2007, in an effort to entice workers to affected areas, the government was offering housing, relocation allowances, and cash incentives to returning ethnic Germans who had been forced out of Russia during Communist rule.
During his two terms in office Putin had consolidated power at the federal level and silenced his liberal opponents. While some of his policies, such as tight control of the media, were considered antidemocratic by Western standards, they received broad support within Russia, and his approval rating was among the highest in the world for a national leader. The 1993 constitution limits Putin to two terms in office, and the next presidential elections are scheduled for March 2008. Several politicians close to him, including FSB officers and the female governor of St. Petersburg, Valentina Matviyenko (1949–), are believed to be the most likely successors to the office.
Fish, Michael Steven. Democracy Derailed in Russia: The Failure of Open Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Jack, Andrew. Inside Putin’s Russia. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
Remnick, David. Resurrection: The Struggle for a New Russia. New York: Random House, 1997.
