More, Thomas
Thomas More
February 6, 1478
London, England
July 6, 1535
London, England
Humanist, author, statesman
"This means that if they suddenly had to part with all the gold and silver they possess—a fate which in any other country would be thought equivalent to having one's guts torn out—nobody in Utopia would care two hoots."
Thomas More in Utopia.
The life of the English humanist and statesman Thomas More exemplifies the political and spiritual upheaval of the Protestant Reformation, the movement to reform the Catholic Church. Now known for his revolutionary work Utopia, More was beheaded for opposing the religious policy of Henry VIII (1491–1547; see entry).
Influenced by humanists
Thomas More was born in London on February 6, 1478, to parents whose families were connected with the city's legal community. His education began at a prominent London school, Saint Anthony's. In 1490 he went to work for Archbishop John Morton (c. 1420–1500), the closest adviser of King Henry VII (1457–1509; reigned 1485–1509). In 1492 he attended Oxford University in England, where he first encountered Greek studies. There he seems to have been tempted to become a priest or a monk. Following his father's lead, however, More began studying law when he returned to London two years later. By 1498 More had gained membership in Lincoln's Inn, an influential lawyers' fraternity. Around this time More also came under the influence of John Colet (c. 1466–1519), an important scholar and preacher.
Colet was educated in Italy and brought back to England a controversial method of studying Scriptures (text of the Bible, the Christian holy book), which was developed by humanists. Humanists were scholars devoted to reviving the literary and philosophical works of ancient Greek and Roman writers. They believed that Scriptures should be read within an historical context instead of being regarded as sacred texts that should never be questioned or analyzed. Colet caused a sensation by lecturing on the historical aspects of Paul's Epistles (Letters) to the Romans from the New Testament (the second half of the Bible). Around 1498 More similarly drew attention to himself by lecturing on City of God by Saint Augustine of Hippo (354–430), one of the first Christian theologians.
In 1499 More met the famous Dutch humanist Erasmus Desiderius (c. 1466–1536; see entry) and began studying Greek. Together More and Erasmus collaborated on translating works by the Greek satirist Lucian of Samosata (c.120–c.190). Lucian had parodied, or made fun of, pagan superstitions and was widely regarded as an atheist (one who does not believe in God or gods). More and Erasmus learned from Lucian the art of humorous ridicule for a serious purpose, aiming at criticizing the superstitions and immoral practices of Christians without directly doing so. At the time, questioning church doctrines and superstitions was very dangerous. Using parody or satire was a way to disguise one's true message while calling church traditions into question.
Develops political views
While More continued his studies and translations with Erasmus, he advanced in his career and took on family responsibilities. In 1504 or 1505 he married Jane Colt, a young woman from the country. After bearing four children she died in 1511. Within a month More was married again, to a widow named Alice Middleton.
When King Henry VII died in 1509, More greeted his death with passionate poems dedicated to young Henry VIII. More was sharply critical of the old king, making Henry VII seem a mean and overbearing ruler. In one of these poems, which were published in a collection in 1518, More expressed his preference for a republic (government consisting of representatives of the people) over a monarchy (government controlled by one ruler). Senators in a republic, he said, are chosen by reasoned argument, but monarchs are chosen by chance. He recognized, however, that people rarely had any choice in the government that rules them. In twelve of his poems he condemned tyranny, or rule by extreme force that limits the rights and freedoms of citizens. Also during this time More undertook a history of King Richard III (1452–1483; ruled 1483–85), but he may have given up writing this work to devote his time to Utopia.
Publishes Utopia
In 1511 More was appointed undersheriff of London. This job involved acting as an adviser at the court of King Henry VIII and as a negotiator with foreign merchants. Four years later More took his first official trip abroad, to Antwerp in present-day Belgium. When he returned to London he began Utopia, a fiction that he wrote in Latin and modeled on the ancient Greek philosopher Plato's Republic. Published in 1516, Utopia describes an imaginary land that is free of the ostentation, greed, and violence that plagued the society of Henry's England. More's inspiration for the book was the discovery of the Americas.
In the first part of Utopia More recounts his meeting with a sunburned Portuguese mariner named Raphael Hythloday, who has been with the explorer Amerigo Vespucci (1454–1512) in the New World. Hythloday is a philosophical traveler, both opinionated and virtuous. As Hythloday, More, and More's friend Peter Giles converse, Hythloday launches into a critique of the ills of European society. Every place he has seen in his voyages seems superior to Europe. He bitterly criticizes the injustice of the English legal system that allows a few to amass great wealth, while multitudes endure such extreme poverty that they have to beg or steal to survive.
In the second part of Utopia Hythloday speaks enthusiastically of a republic on an island off the coast of Brazil. It had been founded 1,760 years earlier by a compassionate conqueror named Utopus, who wrote a constitution for a system that would make its citizens virtuous and its society secure. Hythloday then goes on to describe in great detail the structure of this society. The root of all social problems can be traced to the holding of private property. A person who has property develops pride and wants to acquire more wealth, oftentimes at the expense of others who have little or nothing. In the Utopian society, personal property, private life, and individuality are abolished, and those who break the laws are punished by enslavement or death. Gold, silver, and jewels are made essentially worthless (see accompanying box). Husbands and wives are alone only when they sleep. Utopians eat, work, travel, and spend their leisure time in groups. Regulations are severe, and the punishment given for the offenses is central not only to the government, but to religion as well. All Utopians are required to believe that God exists and that in a future life he will reward good and punish evil deeds done in this life. Without such a belief, no one can be a good citizen. The punishment of human law must be backed up by the threat of divine vengeance. The citizens of Utopia, therefore, readily convert to Christianity. By the end of the book, More had drawn a bleak estimate of the human condition.
"No place"
Thomas More believed that personal property is the basis of all social problems. Nevertheless, he knew that even when personal property has been eliminated, the desire for wealth remains. More addressed this issue in Book Two of Utopia. In the following passage Hythloday, the main character, explains how gold and jewels have been made essentially worthless in Utopia and why that society works so well.
According to this system [of government], plates and drinking-vessels, though beautifully designed, are made of quite cheap stuff like glass or earthenware. But silver and gold are the normal materials, in private houses as well as communal dining-halls, for the humblest items of domestic equipment, such as chamber-pots [toilets]. They also use chains and fetters [chains for the feet] of solid gold to immobilize slaves, and anyone who commits a really shameful crime is forced to go about with gold rings on his ears and fingers, a gold necklace round his neck, and a crown of gold on his head. In fact, they do everything they can to bring these materials into contempt [disregard]. This means that if they suddenly had to part with all the gold and silver they possess—a fate which in any other country would be thought equivalent to having one's guts torn out—nobody in Utopia would care two hoots.
It's much the same with jewels. There are pearls to be found on the beaches, diamonds and garnets on certain types of rock—but they never bother to look for them. However, if they happen to come across one, they pick it up and polish it for some toddler to wear. At first, children are terribly proud of such jewellry—until they're old enough to register that it's only worn in the nursery. Then, without any prompting from their parents, but purely as a matter of self-respect, they give it up—just as our children grow out of things like dolls, and conkers [a game played by children during the Renaissance], and lucky charms.
Source: More, Thomas. Utopia. Paul Turner, editor. New York: Penguin Books, 1965, pp. 86–87.
Named lord chancellor
In the meantime, Henry VIII had invited More to become a councilor in the royal court. More's deep suspicion of rulers and politics made him reluctant to accept the invitation, but he finally agreed to the appointment in 1517. He went on to build a career in diplomacy, legal service, and finance. More eventually learned that his early doubts about serving Henry had been justified. By 1523 More had risen to the position of speaker of the House of Commons (lower branch of Parliament). Under the direction of the lord chancellor of England, Cardinal Thomas Wolsey (c. 1475–1530), More had to promote a highly unpopular war levy (tax) that was ultimately discontinued. In negotiations with other European countries, More was constantly frustrated by Henry's warlike nature and Wolsey's political ambition. More wanted to stop wars so that the Christian faith and culture could be preserved. In 1529 Henry appointed More lord chancellor of England, replacing Wolsey, who had failed to obtain the pope's approval of the annulment (an order that declares a marriage invalid) of the king's marriage to Catherine of Aragon (1485–1536). More now occupied the highest administrative office in the land. Yet he soon found himself in a distressing role as Henry's chief agent in dealing with the pope.
While serving as chancellor, More was deeply engaged in writings against Lutherans (followers of religious reformer Martin Luther; see entry) In such works as Dialogue Concernynge Heresyes (1529) and Apologye (1533) he defended the Catholic Church, even though he was aware of its flaws. More steadfastly held that heretics (those who violate the laws of the church) should be burned for their blasphemy (showing of contempt) against God's true church. At the same time, Henry was drawing further away from the church because the pope still refused to grant him a divorce. In 1532 More resigned from office, primarily because of illness and distress over Henry's outright threat to break from the church. Finally, Henry simply announced that the pope had no authority in England. Statutes passed by the Reformation Parliament in 1533 and 1534 named the king supreme head of the church, now called the Anglican Church or Church of England, and cut all ties with the papacy. The Anglican Church thus became an independent national body.
More recognized the dangers posed by his pro-Catholic writings, so he tried to avoid political controversy. But Henry pressured him to reject the pope's jurisdiction in England. More refused Henry's order because he did not want to contribute to disharmony within the Christian world. In April 1534 More was summoned for interrogation by royal officials. When he did not change his position he was put on trial for treason (betrayal of one's country) and found guilty. He was beheaded on July 6, 1535. Although More is most often remembered as the man who defied Henry VIII, the significance of his life extends beyond the realm of English history. During the turbulent years of the early Reformation, he worked to revitalize Christianity within the church through his active involvement in humanism. In 1935 he was declared a saint by the Catholic Church. More's Utopia continues to be read, and is considered a classic work on the ideal society.
For More Information
Books
Ackroyd, Peter. The Life of Thomas More. New York: Nan A. Talese, 1998.
More, Thomas. Utopia. Paul Turner, editor. New York: Penguin Books, 1965.
Video Recordings
A Man for All Seasons. Burbank, Calif.: RCA/Columbia Pictures Home Video, 1985.
Web Sites
Jokinen, Anniina. "More, Thomas." The Lumninarium. [Online] Available http://www.luminarium.org/renlit/tmore.htm, April 5, 2002.
Knight, Kevin. "More, Thomas." Catholic Encyclopedia. [Online] Available http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14689c.htm, April 5, 2002.
"More, Thomas." Redefining the Sacred. [Online] Available http://www.folger.edu/institute/sacred/image8.html, April 5, 2002.
