Primogeniture
PRIMOGENITURE
PRIMOGENITURE implies seniority by birth; legally, it denotes the right of the eldest son to inherit the estate of a parent to the exclusion of all other heirs. Its wide use in medieval England followed the introduction of continental feudalism by the Normans, who stressed the wishes of a lord to keep his holdings intact to ensure the rents, fees, and military services arising from these tenures. Otherwise, a vassal, the person holding land from a feudal lord, might distribute his tenure among his sons in a way that would defeat the economic basis of the feudal structure. By the fourteenth century practically all free tenures were subject to primogeniture. In 1540 the British Parliament passed a statute that allowed owners of land held in fee simple, as well as many feudal tenures, to pass their holdings to persons other than their eldest sons by will. Feudal tenures were abolished in 1662, after which all freehold land could be willed. By this time, feudalism, except for the manorial system, was in decline. Although feudalism influenced institutional development in America, it was chiefly in its manorial aspects that primogeniture affected the New World.
Primogeniture existed in almost all of the original thirteen colonies. In Massachusetts the earliest colonial laws provided for partible descent, or division of the property. In cases of intestacy, property was divided among all the children, with the eldest son getting a double portion. This rule was also in effect in Pennsylvania. In New England, except for Rhode Island, stout opposition gradually reduced inheritance through primogeniture, so that by the American Revolution it had practically disappeared and had been replaced by partible inheritance. In New York and the southern colonies, where economic and social forces favored large estates, primogeniture generally prevailed, much to the dissatisfaction of those who viewed the institution as an alien and undesirable practice. Its effect was limited, however, because families of the gentry tended to distribute property through wills.
The movement for free and equitable inheritance was fostered by those sponsoring the American Revolution. Stimulated by the democratic philosophy of Thomas Jefferson, the Virginia assembly attacked primogeniture and finally, in 1785, abolished it. Georgia and North Carolina had done the same in 1777 and 1784, respectively. The other states followed this lead, although it was not until 1798 that Rhode Island abolished primogeniture. Since that date, primogeniture has not been in effect anywhere in the United States.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brewer, Holly. "Entailing Aristocracy in Colonial Virginia: 'Ancient Feudal Restraints' and Revolutionary Reform." William and Mary Quarterly. 54, no. 2 (April 1997): 307–346.
Cantor, Norman F. Imagining the Law: Common Law and the Foundations of the American Legal System. New York: HarperCollins, 1997.
Haskins, George Lee. Law and Authority in Early Massachusetts: A Study in Tradition and Design. Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books, 1968. The original edition was published in 1960.
Morris, Richard B. Studies in the History of American Law, with Special Reference to the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. 2d ed. Studies in History, Economics, and Public Law, no. 316. Philadelphia: J. M. Mitchell, 1959. The original edition was published in 1930.
W. FreemanGalpin/c. p.
See alsoEntail of Estate ; Land Policy .
