Externality

views updated

Externality

What It Means

An externality is a side effect of any market activity (an activity related to the buying and selling of goods and services) that either harms or benefits a third party not involved in that particular activity. For instance, a paper mill may pollute the air around its site, but this is not factored into the price of the paper that is ultimately sold. Neither the producer nor the buyer of the paper bears the costs related to the pollution. Instead, the people who live near the paper mill bear these costs, some of which may be economic costs (doctor’s bills for lung ailments) and some of which may be difficult to quantify in terms of money (an unpleasant smell that disrupts children’s outdoor playtime). Such pollution would be called a negative externality.

Economic activity also frequently results in positive externalities. When one person in a neighborhood renovates her home, for example, she obviously increases the market value of her own property. But she also increases, to some degree, the value of other homes in the neighborhood and the feelings of well-being that neighborhood residents experience because of the improved appearance of the house and area.

Externalities that harm a third party are called negative externalities or third-party costs; externalities that benefit a third party are called positive externalities or third-party benefits. The phrase “spillover effect” is also frequently used interchangeably with “externality,” because an externality spills over the boundaries of a buyer-seller transaction to affect uninvolved people.

For economists, both positive and negative externalities represent market inefficiency and are thus potential flaws in the theory, widely accepted in the world of economics, that markets generally achieve maximum economic efficiency. There is no single answer, however, as to how or whether externalities should be addressed.

When Did It Begin

The positive and negative side effects of business activity have no doubt always existed, but negative externalities in particular began increasing exponentially in the nineteenth century as a result of the Industrial Revolution.

The Industrial Revolution was the dramatic shift (made possible by new technologies such as coal-burning steam engines and new techniques for manufacturing textiles and steel) in Western Europe and North America from societies dominated by agriculture and manual labor to societies dominated by mechanized industrial production. In addition to reshaping society at every level, the industrial advances of this time enabled businesses to produce goods on a much larger scale than ever before. The greatly increased production benefited people in countless ways and made possible the development of modern capitalism (a system in which private individuals, not the government, own businesses). It also led, however, to a dramatic increase in negative externalities such as pollution and the depletion of natural resources. These externalities multiplied during the twentieth century, as populations grew and new technologies made possible ever-greater increases in production.

The British economist Alfred Marshall (1842–1924), author of the most widely used economics textbook of his time, Principles of Economics (1890), first theorized that there might be externalities (or external costs) that are not accounted for by the price system. One of Marshall’s students at the University of Cambridge, Arthur Pigou (1877–1959), developed Marshall’s idea further in his book The Economics of Welfare (1920).

More Detailed Information

The fundamental concept of all economic theory is the notion that supply, demand, and prices work together to coordinate economic activity. The law of demand dictates that as the price of a given product rises, consumers become less and less likely to buy that product; and the law of supply dictates that as the price of a product rises, sellers will be willing to sell more and more of that product. In a market, where buyers and sellers freely interact with one another, these opposing laws will result in a balancing of the desires of each side. By trial and error, the price of any product eventually reaches an equilibrium point, a point at which sellers will provide exactly as much of a given product as buyers want to buy. According to economic theory, such efficiency is most easily produced by markets.

Consider the example of the paper mill again. The paper company and its consumers, according to the laws of supply and demand, would (after a process of trial and error) collectively arrive at the equilibrium price for paper, the price at which the forces of supply and demand are equal. Exactly the amount of paper that consumers require is produced, and exactly the amount of paper that the company is willing to supply is produced. This process represents the most efficient allocation of resources possible, according to supply-and-demand theory.

But in actuality, society at large will have to bear the costs of the pollution (for instance, as medical bills, as loss of property value, and as the natural resource of clean air), so the price that society pays for the paper is actually higher than what the paper company is charging. By failing to take into account the externalities of their transaction, the paper mill and paper consumers have arrived at a false equilibrium price. A correct determination of the equilibrium price would have taken the potential costs of pollution into account, but the pricing system alone cannot do this.

This situation, in which a market has failed to produce maximum efficiency, is called market failure. Economists believe that market failure also occurs when positive externalities are not integrated into the pricing system. In the case of renovating properties, the woman who improves her property increases the value of her neighbors’ properties without being directly compensated for this service; although she might have strong motivations for continuing to keep her property in good condition, she would be more likely to do so if the market supplied her with a direct economic incentive. Likewise, her neighbors are less likely to maintain their own houses than they would if they had a clear economic incentive for doing so. The market supplies no reliable mechanisms for encouraging people to maintain their houses’ appearance, so there will always be more demand for this activity than there will be residents willing to supply it.

Economists sometimes speak of the presence of externalities in terms of the private cost vs. the social cost of a good. If, for example, you buy a car, the purchase price of your car, together with your gasoline and other maintenance costs, represent the car’s private cost. The total cost to society of your car-related purchases, however, is greater than the price you pay to the dealer and service-station owners. Driving your car results in pollution that can cause health problems for people uninvolved in the purchase of your car, and that contributes to global warming, which scientists and economists expect to impose severe costs on society and the economy. Cars also cause traffic. Traffic imposes costs on the government (such as increases in the size of the police force), and traffic also cuts into the profits of businesses whose delivery drivers and office workers spend time in traffic jams instead of using that time to generate revenue for the company. A more general cost of traffic is that it decreases the well-being of all the individual drivers who endure it. These negative externalities represent real costs to society, even though they can be hard to calculate in dollar amounts. Adding the external costs of your car (the costs of the externalities) to the private cost of your car yields the overall price paid by you and society for your car. This total price is called the social cost.

Arthur Pigou, who pioneered the concept of social vs. private costs, argued that governments should intervene to correct the gap between these costs. In the case of negative externalities, such as pollution, Pigou recommended that the government tax the industries involved. In the case of positive externalities, he recommended that the government subsidize (or pay part of the manufacturing costs of) the industries involved. This would promote social well-being, but it would do so, in theory, by increasing economic efficiency.

Recent Trends

In the case of both negative and positive externalities, part of the reason that market solutions are not readily available is that it is often difficult, if not impossible, to estimate the cost that negative externalities inflict on people and the gains that people enjoy because of positive externalities. The court system today is full of individual citizens demanding payment for the costs (some economic and some harder to quantify) of negative externalities. Likewise, governments often try to correct the market inefficiencies created by externalities; they can do so by taxing activities that generate negative externalities (which increases companies’ production costs and therefore theoretically spurs cuts in supply), subsidizing activities that generate positive externalities (money to help cover expenses, which decreases production costs and therefore theoretically spurs increases in supply), and putting in place other laws.

The U.S. government, for instance, regulates pollutants expelled by factories by imposing fines if pollution rises above certain levels. The effectiveness of these regulations is often contested, however. Some of the worst air polluters in the country find it less expensive to pay the fines imposed by the government than to update their equipment and thus cut pollution. Their payments of fines may technically bring about a balancing of supply and demand by factoring in the costs of externalities, but their actions arguably do little to repay the public for the costs they must bear as a result of the pollution.

Meanwhile, some economists question whether government intervention can ever rectify market inefficiency, because government workers are not able to process nearly as much information as can decentralized markets governed by the laws of supply and demand. Further, these economists argue, even the most efficient government involvement results in added costs (of hiring regulators, processing paperwork, and enforcing new rules, for instance) that might ultimately outweigh any balancing out of supply and demand.

More From encyclopedia.com