Environmental Impact Assessment
Environmental impact assessment
A written analysis or process that describes and details the probable and possible effects of planned industrial or civil project activities on the ecosystem , resources, and environment . The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) first promulgated guidelines for environmental impact assessments with the intention that the environment receive proper emphasis among social, economic, and political priorities in governmental decision-making. This act required environmental impact assessments for major federal actions affecting the environment. Many states now have similar requirements for state and private activities. Such written assessments are called Environmental Impact Statements or EISs.
EISs range from brief statements to extremely detailed multi-volume reports that require many years of data collection and analysis. In general, the environmental impact assessment process requires consideration and evaluation of the proposed project, its impacts, alternatives to the project, and mitigating strategies designed to reduce the severity of adverse effects. The assessments are completed by multidisciplinary teams in government agencies and consulting firms. The experience of the United States Army Corps of Engineers in detailing the impacts of projects such as dams and waterways is particularly noteworthy, as the Corps has developed comprehensive methodologies to assess impacts of such major and complex projects. These include evaluation of direct environmental impacts as well as social and economic ramifications.
The content of the assessments generally follows guidelines in the National Environmental Policy Act. Assessments usually include the following sections:
- Background information describing the affected population and the environmental setting, including archaeological and historical features, public utilities, cultural and social values, topography , hydrology , geology and soil , climatology, natural resources , and terrestrial and aquatic communities;
- Description of the proposed action detailing its purpose, location, time frame, and relationship to other projects;
- The environmental impacts of proposed action on natural resources, ecological systems, population density, distribution and growth rate, land use , and human health. These impacts should be described in detail and include primary and secondary impacts, beneficial and adverse impacts, short and long term effects, the rate of recovery, and importantly, measures to reduce or eliminate adverse effects;
- Adverse impacts that cannot be avoided are described in detail, including a description of their magnitude and implications;
- Alternatives to the project are described and evaluated. These must include the "no action" alternative. A comparative analysis of alternatives permits the assessment of environmental benefits, risks, financial benefits and costs, and overall effectiveness;
- The reason for selecting the proposed action is justified as a balance between risks, impacts, costs, and other factors relevant to the project;
- The relationship between short and long term uses and maintenance is described, with the intent of detailing short and long term gains and losses;
- Reversible and irreversible impacts;
- Public participation in the process is described;
- Finally, the EIS includes a discussion of problems and issues raised by interested parties, such as specific federal, state, or local agencies, citizens, and activists.
The environmental impact assessment process provides a wealth of detailed technical information. It has been effective in stopping, altering, or improving some projects. However, serious questions have been raised about the adequacy and fairness of the process. For example, assessments may be too narrow or may not have sufficient depth. The alternatives considered may reflect the judgment of decisionmakers who specify objectives, the study design, and the alternatives considered. Difficult and important questions exist regarding the balance of environmental, economic, and other interests. Finally, these issues often take place in a politicized and highly-charged atmosphere that may not be amenable to negotiation. Despite these and other limitations, environmental impact assessments help to provide a systematic approach to sharing information that can improve public decision-making.
See also Risk assessment
[Stuart Batterman ]
RESOURCES
BOOKS
Rau, J., and D. G. Wooten, eds. Environmental Impact Analysis Handbook. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1980.
OTHER
The National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, as Amended, P.L. 91-140 (1 January 1970), amended P.L. 94-83 (9 August 1975).
