Product Review Services

views updated


As the number of consumers shopping on the Web has increased, so has the number of online services available to these shoppers. For example, Shopping bots such as,, and help consumers find the best deals on products. Site evaluation services like and steer shoppers to reputable online merchants. BBB Online, the electronic arm of the Better Business Bureau, also looks after online shoppers, providing dispute resolution services when needed and issuing "seals" to online merchants whose business practices meet Better Business Bureau criteria. Shoppers seeking information about products themselves have a variety of online options as well, including expert product review compiler Consumer Search and consumer review sites,, and


In the late 1990s, expert reviews of all kinds of products became available on specialized Web sites. For example, began reviewing cellular telephones, as well as the cellular telephone service plans available in various geographic areas. reviewed digital cameras. Publications like PC World put their product reviews online. Even Consumer Reports began publishing its reviews on the Web for a fee. Wanting to offer shoppers a single, comprehensive source of product information, Derek Drew and Carl Hamann created New York-based in May of 2000. According to Drew, he had been contemplating creating such a site since the early 1990s when he found himself reading three different computer magazines in an effort to make a decision about which desktop publishing system would best serve his interests at the time.

Doing the work for consumers, ConsumerSearch culls publications like Consumer Digest, Consumer Reports, and PC World for several reviews of a single product. ConsumerSearch's writers, several from leading publications likes The New York Times >, PC Magazine, and Consumer Reports, then compile a Full Story report which analyzes what the various experts said about the product. Summaries are offered in a Fast Answers section. The site also posts links to the original reviews, offers a description of each of the major reviews, and ranks the reviews. After they have finished perusing the site's content, shoppers who identify a product they wish to purchase can link directly to various retailers selling the product, and ConsumerSearch earns a commission off each product sold via one of these links. The firm also makes money through advertising.


Competing with sites like ConsumerSearch are a wide range of sites that use product reviews written by consumers. According to a January 2001 article of PC World, "the difference between an expert site and one that uses consumer reviews can be the difference between a well-written opinion full of facts and a vague endorsement or a flaming condemnation of a product." To increase the credibility of its consumer product reviews, one consumer product review site,, allows users to rate reviewers; it also labels the reviews of writers who earn the "trusted reviewer" distinction. Reviews by those who have proven untrustworthy can be blocked via filtering software. also stands out because it pays it writers a nominal fee, one to three cents each time their reviews are read.

Brisbane, California-based was founded in May of 1999 by executives from Yahoo!,Netscape Communications Corp., and @Home. August Capital and Benchmark Capital gave the startup roughly $8 million in venture capital. A preview of the product evaluation site was launched that September, which prompted Goldman Sachs, Dell Computer Corp., and Bowman Capital to issue another $25 million in funding. Epinions spent the rest of the year forging alliances with portals like Lycos, Inc. and Excite@Home, both of whom agreed to add Epinions' reviews to their shopping channels. Microsoft Corp.'s MSN network began using Epinions' reviews at its eShop in July of 2000. The success of these partnerships prompted the site to create its Content Partner Program, which allowed Web sites to incorporate the reviews into their existing content for a syndication fee.

During its first full year of operation, Epinions won several awards, including being named Best Product Advice Web Site by Yahoo! Internet Life. Its reviews database includes more than 200,000 products and services and more than 1 million reviews. The site also houses buying guides, product definitions, and how-to guides. Along with selling its reviews to other Web sites, the firm makes money by sending shoppers who had decided on a product to online merchants like and Travelocity.

Another online product review site based on consumer input is The site was first created in 1996 as, a site for mountain biking devotees that included reviews of bikes, seats, handlebars, and related biking accessories. Eventually, the site expanded into a hub that now encompasses 18 product specific sites, one of which is the original mountain biking site. Other sites include and, "where enthusiasts of different activities can get news and information and product reviews," writes CNET columnist Troy Wolverton. "These amateur experts provide detailed reviewswithout the expense of hiring an editorial staff." The site makes money by licensing its content to shopping portals such as Yahoo! and AltaVista, selling advertising on its site, and allowing users to click through to various online merchants, who paid a fee for each product purchased by a shopper coming from ConsumerReview. In July of 2001, ConsumerReview and auction giant eBay reached an agreement whereby ConsumerReview will provide product reviews to eBay and provide links to eBay from several of its sites.

Product review site got its start in 1995 as, a site that allowed Internet users to access postings from newsgroup service Usenet. During its first five years of operation, Deja underwent two major overhauls. According to a June 2000 article in BusinessWeek Online, "In May 1999, it shortened its name and relaunched as a site where consumers could swap opinions on thousands of products and services, from VCRs to veterinarians. In March, Deja molted again, this time into what it calls a 'precision buying service,' where consumer reviews are bolstered by expert opinions, related magazine articles, and numerical ratings."

The firm's planned 1999 initial public offering (IPO) never panned out, mainly because non-cash advertising agreements accounted for nearly one-fourth of its revenues, a fact which concerned investors, particularly those already growing leery of startups. Deja withdrew its (IPO) application in June of 2000. The troubled firm eventually reduced its staff from 140 to a mere 20 employees.

Like many dot.coms, several of the leading product review sites, including and epinions, were forced to cut costs in 2001 as investors began demanding profitability. In January of 2001, epinions laid off 27 percent of its workforce. Deja continued its downsizing efforts, cutting another 10 percent of its staff before being acquired by Google Inc. in February of 2001. Less fortunate product review sites, such as and, declared bankruptcy.

While the need for online services such as product reviewing will likely continue to grow as the rate of online shopping increases, the viability of the online product review site business model, as with most other e-commerce models, has yet to be proven.


"ConsumerReview Proves Content Is Still King." Silicon Valley Business Ink, January 25, 2001. Available from

ConsumerSearch, Inc. "About ConsumerSearch." New York: ConsumerSearch, Inc., 2001. Available from "Epinions Timeline." Brisbane, CA:, 2001. Available from

"A Glitch in Deja's Latest Incarnation." BusinessWeek Online, June 8, 2000. Available from

Keizer, Gregg, and David Bock. "How to Pick the Best Products, Shop for the Best Prices, and Close the DealAll Online." PC World, January 2001.

Schoenberger, Chana R. "The Opiners." Forbes. September 4, 2000. Available from

Turner, Rob. "Consumer Reports: Are the New Online Communities Your Best Source of Consumer-Product Advice?" Money, January 1, 2000.

SEE ALSO: BBBOnline;; Gomez Advisors