Fruit of the Loom, Inc.
Fruit of the Loom, Inc.
founded: 1926
Contact Information:
headquarters: 5000 sears tower, 233 s. wacker dr. chicago, il 60606 phone: (312)876-1724 fax: (312)993-1749 toll free: (800)447-8761 url: http://www.fruit.com
OVERVIEW
Fruit of the Loom is a vertically integrated international apparel company, one of the leading U.S. manufacturers of basic apparel and boys'-and-men's and girls'-and-women's underwear and the top supplier to the U.S. screen print T-shirt market. In 1996, Fruit of the Loom was the fourth largest U.S. apparel company and the fourth largest licensed apparel maker. That same year, it was the seventh most admired apparel company as ranked by Fortune magazine. With a total of 98 offices and manufacturing and warehouse facilities in over 50 locations worldwide, Fruit of the Loom makes products under brand names that include Fruit of the Loom, BVD, Gitano, Wilson, and Pro Player. In the 1990s mismanagement left the company in bad shape and investors were outraged. Fruit of the Loom's efforts to move manufacturing offshore were intended to improve the company's production efficiency and cost position, but increased foreign competition, intense price pressure, and mounting debt have left the company with profound operating challenges. Trying to salvage the company in early 1998 at least enough to prepare it for sale, Fruit of the Loom's chairman of the board and CEO, William F. Farley, proposed to move operations to the Cayman Islands.
COMPANY FINANCES
Fruit of the Loom struggled through the second half of the 1990s, losing ground to fashion underwear brands like Calvin Klein and yielding its number one position to Sara Lee Corporation's Hanes. In 1995, Fruit of the Loom recorded an after-tax charge of $287 million to pay for worldwide restructuring efforts to improve operations and reduce the company's cost structure. That year, the company closed 9 plants in the United States and laid off more than 6,000 employees. The following year, Fruit of the Loom returned to profit with net earnings of $151.2 million despite flat sales totaling about $2.44 billion. In 1997 the company reported disappointing earnings, which were largely attributed to price discounting and significant promotional activity. That year, Fruit of the Loom's operating cash flow was a negative $94.9 million; the company had sales of only about $2.14 billion and a net income of negative $487 million. Fruit of the Loom's price-earnings (P/E) ratio was 41.7. At the end of 1997, Fruit of the Loom's total outstanding debt reached $1.2 billion, and the company announced that it was taking another after-tax charge, this time for $372 million, to help make the company more competitive. The sum would be used to help pay for Fruit of the Loom's worldwide restructuring efforts, including the closing and disposal of several domestic manufacturing and distribution facilities.
ANALYSTS' OPINIONS
In early 1998, Fruit of the Loom's chairman and CEO, William Farley, announced his plan to move Fruit of the Loom offshore to the Cayman Islands where foreign income is not subjected to corporate tax—Fruit of the Loom's tax rate would fall from 28 to 11 percent. Though presented as a plan to help the company come back from years of debt and failed attempts at restructuring, some held that Farley was largely interested in preparing Fruit of the Loom for sale. In May 1998, Credit Suisse First Boston analyst Dennis S. Rosenberg suggested that two years of solid performance and free cash flow of at least $300 million could indeed put Fruit of the Loom in a good position for a sale.
HISTORY
Polish immigrant Jacob Goldfarb began his clothing business in 1926 with the goal of producing low priced, quality undergarments—most notably, the popular one-piece men's underwear known as the "unionsuit." Appropriately, Goldfarb called his business The Union Underwear Company. Originally, Goldfarb operated without a factory, buying fabric from a supplier, delivering it to a cutter, then sending the cut pieces to a shop for sewing and finishing. In 1930 promoters from Frankfort, Kentucky, looking for a business to provide employment and money for their town during the Depression, offered to donate a plant for Goldfarb's Union Underwear Company, thereby uniting all the manufacturing operations in one location. By the end of the decade, Goldfarb purchased a 25-year license to use the Fruit of the Loom trademark, hoping the brand would help make his products nationally known. In 1952 Gold-farb opened a Union Underwear plant in Campbellsville, Kentucky, that stood in marked contrast to his earliest approach to manufacturing. This facility provided for on-site knitting and bleaching, in addition to cutting, sewing, and finishing, thereby providing even greater vertical control.
In 1955 a newly formed holding company called the Pacific & Reading Corporation, formerly the Philadelphia & Reading coal railroad and mining operation, took over Union Underwear, providing it with additional financial resources and enabling it to expand its operations. By this time, Union Underwear was Fruit of the Loom's most prominent licensee—in fact, Union Underwear had grown much larger than Fruit of the Loom—and people had come to identify the brand more with underwear than with fabric. In 1961, to ensure future availability of the Fruit of the Loom trademark, Philadelphia & Reading purchased the Fruit of the Loom Licensing Company. In 1968 Northwest Industries acquired Pacific & Reading, and so, also, Union Underwear. A year later, in an effort to perk up the advertising for its underwear, Union hired well-known and somewhat controversial sportscaster Howard Cosell to appear in five of its television advertisements over the following three years.
In 1975 Union Underwear began its "Fruit of the Loom Guys" campaign, which would be tremendously successful, greatly increasing Union Underwear's market share and brand awareness with consumers. The year after that campaign was launched, Union purchased the 100 year old BVD trademark, which the company used for a separate line of underwear targeted at a more up-scale market. Union branched out from men's and boys' underwear and, in 1978, began making "Underoos" decorated underwear for both boys and girls. Also in the 1970s, Union began supplying undecorated T-shirts to the screen print market. Soon this enterprise developed into an enormous business supplying plain T-shirts, sweatshirts, and sweat pants to wholesalers. The business was called Screen Stars.
The 1980s was a heady time of leveraged buyouts, and in 1984, William Farley purchased Northwest Industries for $1.4 billion, thereby acquiring Fruit of the Loom. Farley privatized Northwest Industries and renamed it Farley Industries. The following year Farley restructured the company, sold about $260 million in shares, and changed the name of Union Underwear to Fruit of the Loom, Inc. Farley focused on maximizing profits of Fruit of the Loom, then the top U.S. under-garment company with about 35 percent of the market.
Farley cut costs at Fruit of Loom, sold off many of Farley Industries' other businesses, and used asset sales and revenues from bond issues to modernize domestic operations and expand into Europe. Over the course of the 1980s, Fruit of the Loom expanded into men's fashion underwear, women's underwear, socks, and sportswear. During this time, the activewear market tripled in sales while the underwear market only increased by about 6 percent per year. By the end of the 1980s, Farley Industries was a worldwide textile and clothing corporation bringing in about $4 billion in sales annually. Capital improvements left Fruit of the Loom strapped with debt, and interest expenses consumed huge portions of annual sales revenues—10 percent in 1989. In the late 1980s, low-priced imports began to erode Fruit of the Loom's market share of basic men's undergarments. In 1987 the company went public and changed its name to Fruit of the Loom. The following year, Fruit of the Loom phased out its Fruit of the Loom Guys in favor of a modern campaign with the slogan "We fit America like we never did before." This campaign emphasized Fruit of the Loom as a basic apparel brand for all ages and both sexes and featured family scenes, as well as ads showing the first woman in panties on network TV.
FAST FACTS: About Fruit of the Loom, Inc.
Ownership: Fruit of the Loom, Inc. is a publicly owned company traded on the New York Stock Exchange.
Ticker symbol: FTL
Officers: William F. Farley, Chmn. & CEO, 54, $2,850,000; Larry K. Switzer, Sr. Exec. VP & CFO, 53, $1,085,000; Richard D. Davis, Sr. VP & General Manager Activewear; Robert F. Heise, Sr. VP & Chief Information Officer
Employees: 32,900
Principal Subsidiary Companies: Some of Fruit of the Loom's principal subsidiaries include: Brundidge Shirt Corp.; Camp Hosiery Inc.; Fruit of the Loom Inc. South Carolina Div.; Gitano Group Inc.; Jeanerette Mills Inc.; Panola Mills Inc.; Pro Player Inc.; Salem Sportswear Corp.; and Union Underwear Company Inc.
Chief Competitors: Fruit of the Loom not only manufactures about 35 percent of all male and 15 percent of all female underwear sold in the United States, but it is also the top supplier to the U.S. screen print T-shirt market. The company's principal competitors include: Sara Lee Corporation, manufacturer of Hanes products and Champion athletic knitwear products and the top U.S. maker of intimate apparel, women's and girls' underwear, boys' and men's underwear, and socks; Jockey International, manufacturer of men's, women's, and children's underwear and activewear; and Calvin Klein Inc., maker of haute couture and ready-to-wear apparel including underwear, jeans, and sportswear
In 1988, for the first time since Farley acquired Northwest Industries, Fruit of the Loom showed a profit. In 1990 the company again used male celebrities to sell underwear, this time on network TV. The following year, Fruit of the Loom launched the "It's your time" campaign for its line of casual wear, now expanded to include infant and toddler apparel. At this time, Fruit of the Loom became a top company in underwear for infants and toddlers and in 1994, it purchased the Gitano brand. Farley continued efforts to restabilize the company, reducing its debt by over $332 million with increased sales reaching $1.4 billion. In 1995 Fruit of the Loom closed 9 plants in the United States, laid off over 6,000 employees, and began moving operations to Central America and the Caribbean.
With the stated goal of more than doubling Fruit of the Loom's revenues to $5 billion, Farley had bought smaller apparel companies and had soon built a virtual empire, as well as a virtual mountain of debt—$1.2 billion by 1997. Some of the companies lost money and none yielded the hope for profit. In May and June of 1997 Farley angered investors by selling about 900,000 of his shares of Fruit of the Loom stock, raking in over $30 million just prior to announcing a 51-percent fall in second quarter earnings. Fruit of the Loom took a $101-million charge in 1997 to pay for a legal judgment from a suit filed by a business sold in 1986. Also in 1997 the company announced layoffs of 7,700 employees at seven plants, two of which it would be closing. Despite Fruit of the Loom's two restructuring efforts, and its layoffs and plant closings, in 1997 operating results had fallen to a $283-million loss. Moreover, by this time Fruit of the Loom had lost market share to Calvin Klein and Tommy Hilfiger, who captured part of the market by defining men's underwear as fashionable. With its production license for Ralph Lauren, Hanes elbowed Fruit of the Loom out of its number one spot in the undergarment industry. By 1998 Fruit of the Loom's debt stood at 50 percent of capital, and the company had average annual interest payments of $100 million. At this point, Farley announced plans to move Fruit of the Loom to the Cayman Islands where foreign income is not subject to corporate taxes.
STRATEGY
Jacob Goldfarb employed several marketing strategies with tremendous results. In the 1940s, he developed the idea of bundling three pairs of underwear in one cellophane package; this idea permanently changed the way most basic underwear were sold in the United States. In 1955 Goldfarb launched extensive nationwide advertising employing banners, posters, signs, and admission tickets, and broke new marketing ground in the industry by becoming the first company to advertise underwear on network television. At about the same time, mass merchandisers were beginning to appear on the retail scene, and Union began to ally itself with them; by the early 1990s, 45 percent of men's basic underwear would be sold in discount stores.
As early as 1969, Union Underwear began the then-unusual move of using celebrities to promote its underwear. First, Howard Cosell appeared in five of the company's TV commercials. Then the company hired British comedian Terry Thomas, hoping his "Englishness" would lend an air of superiority to the product. In 1990 Fruit of the Loom would return to this strategy, this time actually showing celebrities like Ed Marinaro, Patrick Duffy, and David Hasselhoff, for example, in their Fruit of the Loom underwear in commercials on network television.
CHRONOLOGY: Key Dates for Fruit of the Loom, Inc.
- 1851:
B.B. & R. Knight Brothers create a cloth trademark called "Fruit of the Loom"
- 1926:
Jacob Goldfarb begins a low-priced, high-quality undergarments business called The Union Underwear Company
- 1930:
Investors in Frankfort, Kentucky, offer to donate a factory to Union to bring jobs to the town
- 1938:
Goldfarb purchases a 25-year license for the Fruit of the Loom trademark
- 1948:
Begins marketing Fruit of the Loom in a printed cellophane bag with three pairs of underwear inside, now an industry packing standard
- 1955:
Philadelphia & Reading Corporation buys Union
- 1961:
Philadelphia & Reading acquires the Fruit of the Loom Licensing Company
- 1968:
Goldfarb steps down as the company chairman
- 1975:
Union introduces the "Fruit of the Loom Guys"
- 1976:
Acquires BVD
- 1984:
William F. Farley acquires Union's parent company
- 1985:
Union Underwear is renamed to Fruit of the Loom, Inc.
- 1998:
Farley announces plans to move Fruit of the Loom to the Cayman Islands
Union Underwear launched an extremely successful advertising campaign in 1975 when it introduced its Fruit of the Loom Guys. The Fruit of the Loom Guys campaign featured three men dressed as three of the items composing the companies trademark: an apple, a bunch of grapes, and a leaf. The campaign doubled Union Underwear's share of the men's and boys' underwear market and increased public recognition of the brand to 98 percent.
A less successful campaign was launched in response to Hanes Knit Products' 1982 "Inspector 12" advertising campaign. Hanes' campaign featured a quality control character who would always judge Hanes brand superior to Fruit of the Loom. Fruit of the Loom responded with a series of advertisements all ending with the tagline, "Sorry Hanes. You lose!" Eventually, this "underwar" resulted in a legal battle that was settled out of court with the requirement that both companies withdraw their advertisements.
Fruit of the Loom anticipated the value of developing licensing partnerships to expand its line and boost sales. Its partnerships included agreements with Warnaco, manufacturer of slips and bras, and Wilson, who agreed to Fruit of the Loom's manufacturing a complete line of athletic activewear under the Wilson label. Other licensing partnerships included some with major U.S. professional sports leagues like the National Basketball Association and the National Football League, as well as large entertainment companies like Time Warner and Walt Disney. Fruit of the Loom acquired it own sportswear companies including Salem Sportswear in 1993, and Artex Manufacturing Inc. and Pro Player in 1994.
In September 1997, to promote its newly designed men's briefs, Fruit of the Loom ran an ad in over 1 million subscription issues of Rolling Stone magazine featuring an actual 3-inch pair of men's briefs made from the same fabric and including the same improved features as the full-sized briefs. The tiny briefs prompted such a large and enthusiastic consumer response that Fruit of the Loom distributed another 200,000 ad inserts the following month. Consumers used them as soda can holders, golf club covers, and as apparel for stuffed animals.
CURRENT TRENDS
In the 1990s Fruit of the Loom began laying off employees, closing plants, and moving manufacturing operations overseas. In early 1998, chairman and CEO William Farley announced plans to relocate the company to the Cayman Islands. To some, it wasn't clear whether Farley was interested in saving the company or in saving his own investment as the largest shareholder since a move to the Caymans wouldn't go far toward solving Fruit of the Loom's fundamental operating problems. Farley claimed that the move would eventually save the company about $100 million annually by trimming the tax rate from 28 to 11 percent, and this money could be used to pay off debt.
But apparently, the relocation would provide more than a corporate tax break for the company. Fruit of the Loom's filings with the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) revealed that the Cayman move had been structured so Farley would receive a huge personal tax break not available to other investors. In the first half of 1998, Farley owned 10 percent of the company, or 7 million shares—82 percent were class B shares worth 5 votes each, giving him a 30-percent voting stake in the company. The relocation was structured to keep Farley's voting majority, and under the terms of the relocation, he would have an opportunity to purchase preferred shares in a Fruit of the Loom subsidiary called FTL-Delaware, the first Fruit of the Loom shares to offer dividends since the company went public in 1987.
PRODUCTS
Fruit of the Loom offers basic, value-priced clothing for infants to senior citizens. Active wear, athletic sportswear, casual wear, children's wear, hosiery, sports-licensed apparel, and underwear are its leading products. The company sells products principally under the brand names Best, Botany 500, BVD, Fruit of the Loom, Fun-pals, Gitano, John Henry, Kangaroo, Lofteez, Munsing-wear, Pro Player, Salem Sportswear, Screen Stars, and Wilson.
In the 1980s, Fruit of the Loom began its evolution from being a basic underwear manufacturer to being an apparel company producing socks, sweatshirts, men's fashion underwear, and women's underwear. Within four years of launching its women's underwear division in 1984, Fruit of the Loom led that category with a 10-percent market share. By the late 1980s brand extensions made up over 40 percent of revenues. In 1991, Fruit of the Loom began offering infants' and toddlers' apparel and Warnaco started to produce and market bras under the Fruit of the Loom name. In 1993 Fruit of the Loom struck a deal with Wilson Sporting Goods to manufacture and sell Wilson athletic wear in the United States. Also in 1993, Fruit of the Loom acquired Salem Sportswear. The following year, the company purchased Artex Manufacturing, which licensed sports leagues and famous cartoon characters from Disney, Peanuts, and Looney Tunes. Fruit of the Loom's three-year licensing agreement with Walt Disney Co. allowed Fruit of the Loom to manufacture and sell apparel sporting Disney characters in the Middle East, Europe, and eastern Europe.
GLOBAL PRESENCE
Fruit of the Loom's main market is the United States, which in 1996, accounted for 85 percent of the company's total sales and 86 percent of the company's total operating income. In 1995 Fruit of the Loom began moving operations to Mexico, the Caribbean, and Central America, hoping to reduce operating costs. Fruit of the Loom maintains 47 manufacturing facilities in Canada, El Salvador, Honduras, Ireland, Jamaica, Morocco, the United Kingdom, and the United States and hopes to move its headquarters to the Cayman Islands by the end of the decade.
EMPLOYMENT
During the 1990s, Fruit of the Loom shut down many U.S. plants and facilities. Some operations it moved abroad; some it simply closed. In 1995 the company closed nine U.S. plants and laid off upwards of 6,000 workers. In 1997 it laid off more than 7,700 employees at seven plants, two of which it closed altogether. In April 1998, the company announced that it would close its Campbellsville, Kentucky, plant and thereby lay off more than 800 more workers. All told, from 1994 to early 1998, Fruit of the Loom laid off 16,355 employees.
By the start of 1998, Fruit of the Loom had almost entirely eliminated its U.S. sewing operations, moving them to cheaper locations abroad. The incentive for U.S. garment makers to move manufacturing operations abroad is powerful. On average, U.S. apparel workers are paid $8 an hour, plus benefits; minimum wage in Mexico is $1 an hour; in Haiti, the minimum hourly wage is $.29. Larry Martin, president of the American Apparel Manufacturers Association observes that "[l]abor costs are 40 percent of making a garment, so it's pretty difficult to compete at $8 to $10 an hour."
SOURCES OF INFORMATION
Bibliography
1997 fruit of the loom annual report. chicago, il: fruit of the loom, inc., 1997.
aran, kimberly. "fruit of the loom to license disney, but europe's no magic kingdom." crain's chicago business, 31 october 1994.
business rankings annual, detroit, mi: gale research, 1998.
"calvin klein inc." hoover's online, 18 may 1998. available at http://www.hoovers.com.
dougal, april s. "fruit of the loom, inc." international directory of company histories, vol. 8. detroit, mi: st. james press, 1994.
"fruit of the loom ratings placed on watch neg by s&p." business wire, 12 february 1998.
"fruit of the loom to cut 800 jobs in another plant closing." new york times, 16 april 1998.
"fruit of the loom, inc." hoover's online, 28 july 1998. available at http://www.hoovers.com.
hunt, nigel. "fruit of the loom cuts about 3,000 us sewing jobs." reuters business report, 11 november 1997.
"jockey international." hoover's online, 18 may 1998. available at http://www.hoovers.com.
lazich, robert s., ed. market share reporter- 1998, detroit, mi: gale research, 1997.
poole, shelia m. "kentucky town in despair over losing apparel plants." the atlanta journal and constitution, 27 november 1997.
"s&p description: fruit of the loom." standard & poor's, 15 april 1998.
"sara lee corporation." hoover's online, 18 may 1998. available at http://www.hoovers.com.
"tiny briefs mean big news for fruit of the loom." business wire, 28 september 1997.
weimer, de'ann. "fruit of the loom: a killing in the caymans?" business week, 11 may 1998.
For an annual report:
on the internet at: http://www.fruit.comor write: corporate communications center, inc., 400 s. jefferson, ste. 303, chicago, il 60607
For additional industry research:
investigate companies by their standard industrial classification codes, also known as sics. fruit of the loom's primary sics are:
2252 hosiery, nec
2322 mens/boys' underwear & nightwear
2329 mens/boys' clothing, nec
2341 women/children's underwear
