Debs, Eugene V.

views updated

Eugene V. Debs

BORN: November 5, 1855 • Terre Haute, Indiana

DIED: October 20, 1926 • Elmhurst, Illinois

American political party leader; union leader

Eugene V. Debs headed the American Socialist Party for more than thirty years. He was instrumental in helping it achieve some impressive results in national elections early in the twentieth century. A longtime labor union leader, Debs emerged as America's most prominent socialist, a title that remained attached to his name eighty years after his death. He ran as his party's presidential candidate five times between 1900 and 1920. The votes cast for him helped bring some of his more radical ideas about economic justice into the political mainstream in the United States.

"What is socialism? Merely Christianity in action. It recognizes the equality in men."

Working on the railroad

Eugene V. Debs was born on November 5, 1855, in Terre Haute, Indiana. The town, located on the Wabash River, was home to French Canadian fur trappers in its earliest days. Coal mining and the railroads had brought growth and prosperity to the area by the time Debs was born. His parents, Jean and Marguerite, were originally from the city of Colmar in the Alsace region of France, near the German border. Jean Debs was the son of a wealthy textile manufacturer, but had been disinherited from the family fortune when he married Marguerite, who was a worker in the textile factory.

In Terre Haute, Marguerite ran a grocery store out of the first floor of their home. Jean had received an excellent education as a young man, even studying in Paris, France, for a time, and passed on his love of literature to Eugene and his younger brother Theodore. As the family store prospered, Eugene was able to attend a local academy, the Old Seminary School, but transferred into the public-school system in 1867. He was eager to begin working, however, and left school at the age of fourteen to take a job in one of the railroad shops. It was a large garage where railroad cars were repaired or refurbished. His first job was cleaning the grease off freight cars, but he eventually moved up to a letter-painting job. In 1871 he was promoted to locomotive fireman with the company. This job actually put him on the train, tending the engine-car furnace that powered the steam locomotives.

Debs became regretful that he left school so early, so he enrolled in classes at a local business college. He was reportedly quite upset when his high school class graduated without him in 1873. An economic downturn occurred that same year, which was triggered by the failure of some prominent East Coast banks. As a result, the railroads cut back on their routes and laid off thousands of employees. Debs went to St. Louis, Missouri, to find work and was shocked to see how the poor lived in cities outside Terre Haute. It was the closest experience to a situation he had previously only read about in books, such as the novel Les Miserables (1862), one of his favorite stories, by French writer Victor Hugo (1802–1885). Eventually Debs returned to Terre Haute and found a job as a clerk in the offices of a food wholesaler. Though he was no longer a fireman, he was able to join the city's Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen. Though the group was called a union, it was more of a charitable association. It did not involve itself in the struggle for better working conditions or higher wages, but instead provided group insurance rates for its members.

Since his earliest years, Debs had been an easygoing, well-liked student, and his early success in social settings carried over into his roles as co-worker and then Brotherhood member. He thought the organization could do more to help its members get through periods of layoffs like the 1873 economic downturn. From his own experience as a fireman, he also knew the job was a hard and dangerous one—sometimes even deadly—and he thought there should be rules established to ensure each fireman's safety on the job. He quickly rose to a leadership position, and in 1878 was made associate editor of the Firemen's Magazine. That same year, he ran for and won the job of Terre Haute city clerk as a Democratic candidate. Reelected in 1881, he was also made secretary-treasurer of the Brotherhood, which had doubled in size thanks to his organizing efforts.

From politician to union leader

Debs ran for and won a seat in the Indiana House of Representatives in 1884, but his two years there turned him against legislative politics and its behind-the-scenes compromises. In 1885 he wed Kate Metzel, the daughter of a prominent couple in Terre Haute. Though Debs lived most of his life in that city, his work kept him away from home for long periods of time. The couple never had children.

As a young man, Debs believed that workers and their bosses essentially had the same goals: prosperity for themselves, for their companies, and for their communities. But as he grew older, he saw the brutal treatment employees suffered because of the tremendous push to increase profits. The labor movement was just beginning to emerge as a significant force during the 1880s, and Debs was shocked at how quickly company management moved to fire, blacklist, or even physically harm workers who demanded fair wages and a reduction in hours to an eight-hour day. Blacklisting occurred when someone was tagged as a troublemaker, which made finding another job virtually impossible.

Debs believed that a larger union would be a major step for American workers, and the railroad was a good place to start. His idea was for a union that included all the employees in the railroad industry. At the time, the unions were small brotherhoods like the Firemen, who jealously guarded their job classifications. An umbrella group made up of all workers, he argued, would be a more effective way to bargain with management for better wages and working conditions. After some struggle, Debs finally succeeded in forming the American Railway Union (ARU) in 1893 and served as its first president. Another economic downturn in 1893 sent crowds of new members to its ranks.

The U.S. economy had expanded since the end of the American Civil War (1861–65), and the population and workforce had grown immensely along with it. The country was prosperous and a world leader in several industries, but workers were considered expendable, or easily replaced. Workers who organized to bargain for job security, safety, and a decent wage could be fired immediately and put on a "blacklist" that circulated among managers in a town. Companies hired thugs to harass strikers who were picketing. When major labor strikes turned violent, union leaders could even face murder charges if anyone was killed on the picket line.

Arrested and jailed

Debs rose to national prominence in the spring of 1894. In May, workers of the Pullman Company outside Chicago, Illinois, went on strike. They built the railway sleeping cars that were attached to most passenger trains, which served as the most common form of long-distance travel at that time. But Pullman workers lived in a company town, which meant that the company built and owned everything in the town, including the houses, stores, bank, library, and the like. Workers were required to live in the town, called Pullman, and had their rent, grocery bills, and even

César Chávez and "La Causa"

César Chávez was the leader of the United Farm Workers of America (UFW) for several decades. His union represented the thousands of migrant laborers who toiled in U.S. agricultural fields. Legal recognition of the union marked an important turning point in the history of the American labor movement.

Chávez was born in 1927 in Yuma, Arizona, one of five children in his family. His parents had come to Arizona from Mexico some twenty years earlier and owned a ranch in Yuma. But financial hardships caused by the Great Depression (1929–41) caused many farmers and ranchers to lose their properties when they could not repay bank loans. The Chávez family was one of them. They moved to California to look for jobs as field hands.

The family soon found that being migrant workers, or part of a group of manual laborers who moved from one site to another to pick crops for cash, meant exceptionally difficult work for extremely low wages. Often they earned just a dollar a day and were forced to live in camps or in their cars. Sometimes they would work for weeks, but were cheated out of their pay at the end of the season by dishonest bosses. By the time Chávez quit school around age thirteen, he had attended more than thirty different schools. Like other migrant-worker families, the Chávezes suffered many hardships, including discrimination. Some stores even posted signs that read "Whites Only."

Around the time Chávez left school to work full time in the fields, the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) began assembling migrant laborers. Chávez's father and uncle joined, although it was dangerous to be associated with organized labor at that time. Some union leaders were harassed and even physically attacked.

After serving in the U.S. Navy during World War II (1939–45), Chávez returned to the grape vineyards near Fresno, California. In 1951 he joined the staff of the Community Services Organization (CSO), a social-services agency that served the Hispanic American community, and eventually became its director in 1958.

In 1962 he began his own organization, the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA). In 1965, when grape-pickers from another labor group went on strike, Chávez and his NFWA locals joined in. The strike received heavy media coverage and became known as "La causa" ("The Cause"). The phrase would later be applied to the larger movement that sought to improve the lives of migrant workers.

The grape-growers eventually gave in and agreed to negotiate with the unions. Soon Chávez's NFWA merged with another group to become the United Farm Workers Organizing Committee (UFWOC). One of its first successes was signing labor contracts with two major California wine producers. In the meantime, strikes against other grape growers continued. A table grape boycott was initiated by Chávez, who asked Americans to stop buying supermarket grapes until they could be sure the men and women who picked those grapes worked reasonable hours for a fair wage. The boycott was well-publicized. National sales of table grapes dropped 12 percent.

Chávez's union won this fight, though it took several years. The battle was helped by high-ranking Catholic bishops in California, some of whom had worked with the largely Mexican American, migrant worker population and knew how poor the families were. Chávez was a devout Roman Catholic and attended religious services daily. His faith and commitment to social justice helped him lead the union through many difficulties during the 1970s and 1980s. Chávez called for another boycott in the mid-1980s to draw attention to the use of pesticides (chemicals that are used to kill insects) by grape growers. He died on April 23, 1993, in Arizona. Married since the late 1940s, he was the father of eight children.

library-use fees subtracted from their paychecks. The situation worked well enough in good economic times, but when wages dropped and hours lengthened, while rents remained the same, families suffered tremendous hardships.

When the Pullman workers went on strike, the ARU did not join them, but Debs authorized a boycott strategy. Under the terms of the boycott, ARU members refused to handle Pullman railroad cars anywhere in the nation. Since the Pullman cars were on almost every train, they had to be detached in order for the trains to be kept moving. The boycott meant a massive slowdown of all rail traffic across the nation.

Debs was in Chicago during the intense weeks of the strike. It was a time when tensions ran so high that some people worried that another civil war might break out. This time, they feared, the workers might rise up against the owners. Debs was working long hours to help settle the Pullman strike peacefully, but in early July the U.S. government authorized the use of federal troops to end the strike. The reason given for such a drastic measure was that the U.S. mail was being delayed, and the federal government could legally step in when that was the case. Labor historians, however, note that few mail cars and routes were actually affected by the strike. Violence broke out when the federal troops arrived.

Debs was arrested for violating an injunction, or court order, that required the strikers to return to work. He was held in the Cook County jail. A sympathetic sheriff allowed him to bring in a fox terrier to scare away the rats that lived in the filthy jail cells, but the dog was terrified at the size of the pests and had to be removed, whimpering and shaking. A week later, Debs was out, too, having been released on bail, and began to prepare for his trial. His attorney was Clarence Darrow (1857–1938), and though the case was appealed all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, Debs and the other union leaders spent six months in jail.

"Christianity in action"

The Pullman strike broke the ARU, which disbanded. Debs was inspired to return to politics. This time, however, he was convinced that the mainstream Democratic and Republican parties could not help the average American worker. Only socialism promised a better future, he believed. Socialism is a political philosophy that directs citizens to form a cooperative government that works toward serving the good of the entire population. In this kind of economic plan, the immense profits earned by businesses, which were the result of the physical labor of workers and not from the cleverness of a handful of managers, would be shared more equally. "What is socialism?" Debs asked in 1897 when he announced the formation of his new group, Social Democracy in America. "Merely Christianity in action," he answered, according to the book Eugene V. Debs: Citizen and Socialist. "It recognizes the equality in men."

A year later, Debs's group became the Social Democratic Party. In the 1900 national elections, he was its presidential candidate and won 97,000 votes. A year later, his group reorganized and renamed itself the Socialist Party of America. In 1904 convention delegates again nominated Debs as the front-runner for the White House, and the party won an astounding 400,000 votes, more than four times the 1900 tally.

Debs's brand of socialism caught on at a time when America was enjoying a tremendous population growth. Its cities were dominated by factories, whose workers were mostly new arrivals from various European countries. Some of these immigrants were already familiar with the concept of socialism, which had roots in central Europe and imperial Russia. By 1908, when Debs ran a third time as his party's presidential candidate, he told audiences that voting for either of the two main parties would change nothing in America. All it would do, he argued, was keep the current system in place, and that was a system that did nothing to help the worker, but everything to profit the leaders of big business and their political buddies.

Debs's 1908 presidential campaign crisscrossed the nation on a train that was known as the "Red Special." The party did not gain much ground over the previous election in 1904, but made a powerful comeback in 1912. In that year, 897,011 votes were cast for Debs and his vice-presidential candidate, Emil Seidel (1864–1947) of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, the first socialist ever to be elected mayor of a major U.S. city. Debs and Seidel won 6 percent of the total popular vote cast. It was a stunning showing by third-party candidates, one that had not been repeated by any socialist party candidates as of the early twenty-first century.

Arrested and jailed again

The 1912 election was the high point for Debs and the American Socialist Party. The organization began to fall out of favor with the public during the first few years of World War I (1914–18), a conflict in which Great Britain, France, the United States, and their allies defeated Germany, Austria-Hungary, and their allies. The war began in Europe in 1914 but the United States delayed joining the fight until 1917. The tide turned against the American Socialist Party due, in part, to its strong opposition to U.S. involvement in the conflict on any level. In his speeches and writings, Debs argued that American participation overseas would cost thousands of innocent lives, but that business interests stood to earn immense profits.

In 1916 Debs rejected the nomination for president at the socialist party convention. The current president, Democrat Woodrow Wilson (1856–1924; served 1913–21), won the White House again that year. A few months after beginning his second term in office, Wilson approved the deployment of the first U.S. troops in the war. Public opinion was still so divided over U.S. involvement that Wilson urged the U.S. Congress to pass the Espionage Act of 1917 shortly afterward. The law made it a crime, punishable by a $10,000 fine and up to twenty years in jail, for a person to deliver written or spoken opinions of the war that might interfere with the operation or success of the U.S. troops. The act also forbid the expression of ideas that might discourage enlistment in the armed forces.

On June 16, 1918, Debs gave a speech before the state branch of the American Socialist Party in Canton, Ohio. As detailed in Eugene V. Debs: Citizen and Socialist, Debs said: "Wars throughout history have been waged for conquest and plunder…. And that is war, in a nutshell. The master class [the leadership] has always declared the wars; the subject class [the common worker] has always fought the battles." A government agent was in the Canton audience, and wrote down every word of the speech. Debs was indicted, formally accused of the crime, by a federal grand jury under the terms of the Espionage Act and arrested. He was charged with sedition, or participating in an illegal action that could provoke resistance to the lawful authority, and one in which the disruption or overthrow of the government was possible.

Debs was convicted but appealed his case on the grounds that the Espionage Act was unconstitutional and violated Americans' right to freedom of speech, which was guaranteed by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. At his sentencing hearing, he told the judge that he did not fear prison, and his words became one of his most famous speeches. "Your Honor, years ago I recognized my kinship with all living beings, and I made up my mind that I was not one bit better than the meanest on earth," he said, according to the SoJust.net: A Document History of Social Justice Web site. "I said then, and I say now, that while there is a lower class, I am in it, and while there is a criminal element I am of it, and while there is a soul in prison, I am not free."

New era for American labor

On April 12, 1919, Debs entered a federal prison in Atlanta, Georgia. He was sixty-four years old and spent two-and-a-half years there. He made his final bid for president while imprisoned, and he and the socialists won nearly a million votes in the 1920 presidential election. President Warren G. Harding (1865–1923; served 1921–23) pardoned him two days before Christmas 1921. On the day of Debs's release, the warden let every inmate out of his cell, an extraordinary act, so that the two thousand prisoners could gather in the main building and say their farewells to Debs. Once again, he had been immensely well liked by his fellow prisoners as well as his jailers. But the ordeal had ruined his health and he died on October 20, 1926, in the Lindlahr Sanitarium of Elmhurst, Illinois.

Historians note that the 1912 presidential election was a turning point in the history of American social reform. The current president, Republican William Howard Taft (1857–1930; served 1909–13), was challenged by former president Theodore Roosevelt (1858–1919; served 1901–09) and his newly formed Progressive Party. This was viewed as a struggle between big business (the Republicans) and anti-business (the Progressives). The Democratic Party candidate was Princeton University president Woodrow Wilson, who edged out both Taft and Roosevelt to win the White House.

While Debs and his party came in fourth place in the vote tally, it was the highest percentage of the popular vote ever won by a socialist candidate up until that time in U.S. election history. By the early part of the twenty-first century, this record still stood. Upon taking office, Wilson approved of many of the ideas put forth by Debs and Roosevelt, and he took several measures that brought an end to the long, regulation-free status that corporations in America had enjoyed up until then. One of the most important pieces of legislation during Wilson's first term was the Clayton Anti-Trust Act. It revised the operating rules for U.S. corporations that conducted business across state lines, but one paragraph exempted labor unions from being punished for interfering with interstate commerce.

For More Information

BOOKS

Carey, Charles W., Jr. Eugene V. Debs: Outspoken Labor Leader and Socialist. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow, 2003.

Chace, James. 1912: Wilson, Roosevelt, Taft & Debs—The Election That Changed the Country. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2004.

Krull, Kathleen. Harvesting Hope: The Story of Cesar Chavez. San Diego, CA: Harcourt, 2003.

Salvatore, Nick. Eugene V. Debs: Citizen and Socialist. Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1982.

PERIODICALS

Edwards, Owen. "Broad Shoulders." Smithsonian (October 2005): p. 29.

Huberman, Leo. "The Debs Way." Monthly Review (October 2003): p. 38.

Jones, Arthur. "Millions Reaped What Cesar Chavez Sowed." National Catholic Reporter (May 7, 1993): p. 5.

Zinn, Howard. "Eugene V. Debs and the Idea of Socialism." Progressive (January 1999): p. 16.

WEB SITES

"An American Hero." The Cesar E. Chavez Foundation. http://www.cesarechavezfoundation.org/cesarechavez.html (accessed on June 26, 2006).

Debs, Eugene Victor. "Statement to the Court" (September 18, 1918). SoJust.net: A Document History of Social Justice. http://www.sojust.net/speeches/eugene_debs_sedition.html (accessed on June 26, 2006).

Eugene V. Debs Foundation. http://www.eugenevdebs.com/ (accessed on June 26, 2006)

More From encyclopedia.com