Homelessness

views updated

Homelessness

Modern forms of homelessness

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Homelessness is a condition of detachment from society characterized by the absence or attenuation of the affiliative bonds that link settled persons to a network of interconnected social structures.

Homelessness takes many forms, depending on the type of detachment involved and the local circumstances. Homeless families and homeless men appear, so far as can be determined, in all largescale societies. Homeless women and children are relatively rare. Their appearance denotes wide spread disorder and instability, such as follow famines and civil wars.

Degrees of homelessness. Homeless families fall into three general types: permanent wanderers, such as gypsies and carnival performers; wanderers with a fixed base, especially migratory farm workers; and refugees, for whom homelessness is an accident and not a way of life. Homeless men fall into a variety of categories.- single men in itinerant occupations, such as peddlers, tinkers, and sailors; migratory laborers; vagrants and beggars; religious mendicants; outlaws and other fugitives; and hoboes and derelicts.

These types suggest that homelessness is a matter of degree, ranging from temporary to perma nent and from the loss of a single affiliation to the absence of all affiliations. In general, homelessness is less acute for families than for individuals. The homeless family may have no place in any community, but its members carry a web of roles and obligations with them wherever they go. Some, like the gypsies, develop something like a portable community independent of the surrounding social structure. Others, like the millions of families displaced toward the end of World War II, are ren dered homeless without their consent and resume normal affiliations at the first opportunity.

There is even more variation in degree of home-lessness among men without families. Some, like the itinerant worker, may preserve multiple affiliations: occupational, religious, political, and so on. They are only as homeless as their mobility forces them to be. Others, like religious mendicants, elect one overriding identification that supplants all of their former roles.

At the extreme point of the scale, the modern skid row man demonstrates the possibility of nearly total detachment from society. The present discussion is focused on this end of the homelessness scale and omits any consideration of the minor degrees of homelessness represented by Bohemians, “beatniks,” troubadours, residents in alien societies, and other adventurers whose partial detachment from role obligations is arranged deliberately and with substitute goals in view.

Homelessness as a syndrome. The common characteristics of homeless populations display a distinct and unmistakable pattern that is roughly applicable to any homeless population though fully descriptive of none. Homeless persons are poor, anomic, inert, and nonresponsible. They command no resources, enjoy no esteem, and assume no burden of reciprocal obligations. Social action, in the usual sense, is almost impossible for them. Lacking organizational statuses and roles, their sphere of activity extends no further than the provision of personal necessities on a meager scale. Their decisions have no implications for others. Only the simplest forms of concerted action are open to them, since homelessness is incompatible with sustained involvement in a complex division of labor.

The observable behavior of the homeless person consists largely of activities that furnish subsistence or enjoyment without incurring responsibilities: mendicancy, petty crime, scavenging, casual conversation, and an incurious attention at spectacles. This quality of social inertness renders him both innocuous and helpless. He is unlikely to engage in major crime or political movements or to protest his own condition forcefully. A certain apathy regarding self-preservation often develops in addition to the collective helplessness. The home less in great cities and in refugee camps stand and watch their companions assaulted by strangers without offering to interfere and without taking any measures to protect themselves. The combined effect of poor nutrition, exposure of all kinds, neglect of injuries and illness, and insensitivity to emergencies leads to very high rates of morbidity and mortality among homeless persons as compared to the settled population around them.

The homeless versus the settled. For reasons not entirely understood, the presence of homeless persons often arouses a degree of hostility in the settled population that seems entirely disproportionate. Ancient ballads preserve the image of the gypsy as rapist and kidnapper. Being homeless or vagrant became a felony in England in the fourteenth century and a capital crime under the Tudors; it is still treated as a criminal offense in most American and European cities. These external attitudes and the punitive measures to which they lead further separate the homeless man from his settled neighbor. Homeless populations often occupy an underworld with a special argot, secret signs, and a conventional refusal to communicate with outsiders. Such manifestations may lead romantic observers to imagine an entire clandestine social system, such as the “kingdom of beggars” or the “hobo republic,” but on closer view, these fantasies disappear and reveal the homeless as an aggregate of unrelated individuals who share a common situation and some elements of a common culture.

A theory of homelessness. The Germanic term “home,” with its special connotations of warmth, safety, and emotional dependence, has no exact equivalent in other linguistic systems. Aside from its familiar overtones, it expresses the idea of a fixed place of residence shared with a limited number of other persons. In current usage, home does not imply a family (unrelated persons can “make a home” together), a household (a rest home may be much larger), more than moderate fixity (in any given year, more than one in five U.S. families moves to a new home), or exclusivity (a special body of tax law covers taxpayers with two or more homes). Living outside a family, with no permanent address, does not make a priest or a soldier homeless, but the man who occupies the same lodging on skid row for forty uninterrupted years is properly considered homeless. The essence of the concept goes beyond residential arrangements. Homelessness is best visualized as a relationship to society at large and best understood by examining the difference between the settled and the homeless.

A settled, active adult in any society participates simultaneously in several major types of organization. This participation anchors him in the social structure by linkages with near and distant kin, neighbors, compatriots, superiors and subordinates, co-workers, departed ancestors, sacred and supernatural personages, persons with the same special interests, and even those who like to play the same games. Each of these memberships involves duties and privileges, restraints and rights, status and roles. Each requires sustained interaction with particular other persons who enter into the subject’s life history and become part of the audience for his socially meaningful acts.

The pattern of these affiliations varies in detail from one time and place to another, but the main outlines remain unchanged. In modernized countries of the twentieth century, the individual’s at tachment to society seems to be mediated through eight major types of organization: family, school, community, state, production group, occupational union, church, and recreational associations. Taken together, these memberships define who the settled person is, how he schedules his days and his years, and the benefits he may claim from, and the duties he owes to, the social order. Above all, they identify the others who are influenced by him and define the extent of that influence.

The fully homeless man is unaffiliated in all sectors. He is not an active member of any organization and therefore has no enforceable responsibilities toward fellow members, no audience of persons influenced by his actions, no claim on social rewards beyond whatever minimum has been set to avoid the scandal of his starvation, and no duties to fulfill except those imposed as a condition of remaining in the territory. Clearly, this condition will be uncomfortable and sometimes dangerous. On the other hand, it may be attractive to those who reject the cultural goals together with the means of achieving them.

Homelessness as an ideal. The age of modernization is singularly unsympathetic to the positive values of homelessness. However, in other times and places it has been regarded as a desirable, or at least admirable, way of life.

The exaltation of homelessness as an ideal is a central, recurrent theme of Christianity, reflecting such scriptural teachings as “lay not up for your self treasures on earth.” Poverty, detachment from previous affiliations, and the abandonment of worldly aspirations are the first principles of monasticism. The Christian ethos of vagrancy was most fully developed by St. Francis of Assisi and the several orders of wandering, mendicant friars who followed the Franciscan model.

A parallel theme runs through Muslim history. The “St. Francis of Islam” is Mulai ’Abd al-Qadir al-JIlani (1078–1166), the patron of the needy and suffering. From the Muslim viewpoint, the beggar performs a kind of social service by enabling others to attain merit by almsgiving: “As long as Islam flourishes,” says one writer, “there will be beggars, for there will always be devout people who will give away all they have, and so become beggars themselves” (Edwards 1912, p. 931).

In addition to friars, hermits, and holy beggars, Christianity and Islam recognize and honor the pilgrim, who becomes a homeless wanderer temporarily, partly for the spiritual benefit of visiting the sacred shrine and partly to withdraw from settled society. In the Middle Ages pilgrims played a vital part in integrating both the Christian and Muslim worlds. The pilgrim routes to Mecca and Medina, to Rome and Santiago de Compostela, are as crowded today as ever, but the modern pilgrim is more often a religious tourist than a holy vagrant.

The ethos of vagrancy is even more conspicuous in Buddhism. Buddha and his disciples were members of an already ancient order of wandering almsmen, and Buddha charged his disciples to “go forth and wander about for the good of the Many.” The bhikshu-sangha was (and is) a community of homeless men entered by “going forth from a house to a houseless state.” A bhikshu is an almsman. “He is differentiated from an ordinary beggar by the sacramental character of his begging. His beggary is not just a means of subsistence, but an out ward token that he has renounced the world and all its goods and thrown himself for bare living on the chances of public charity” (Dutt 1962, p. 36).

Similar themes exalting homelessness and attaching a positive value to mendicancy may be discerned in Hinduism, the religion of Zoroaster, and a number of Hellenistic cults. Indeed, approval and abhorrence of religious mendicancy may occur together. One appeal of the world religions may lie precisely in their ability to combine doctrinal elements supporting the performance of status obligations with others that allow the believer to with draw from the world without penalty.

Modern forms of homelessness

Although the traditional types of homelessness may still be observed on the contemporary scene, they are overshadowed by new forms that arise directly from the dominant processes of the modern era: industrialization, urbanization, decolonization, and the redistribution of political power. The three types to be considered here are refugees, migratory workers, and skid row men.

Refugees. Involuntary migration has occurred throughout historic times, but the displacements of the twentieth century have been unprecedented in scale, scope, and duration. Refugees are persons who migrate to escape actual or threatened persecution because of their race, religion, political convictions, or for any reasons related to war (Proud-foot 1957, pp. 53, 446). A broader definition of refugees includes any persons compelled to abandon their homes because of events for which they cannot be held responsible (Vernant 1953, p. 3).

The involuntary migration of refugees contrasts sharply with voluntary migration in search of economic opportunities. Voluntary migrants are mostly young adults usually assured of a welcome in the host country and of continued ties with the country of origin. Involuntary migration often affects entire communities, including people of all ages and conditions, uprooted without their consent and set down in a place selected at random, where their numbers increase their helplessness.

The wars and revolutions of the twentieth century have created both temporary and permanent refugees. The temporary refugee may flee from his home in the face of an invading army to return at the first opportunity. The permanent refugee leaves a country where his enemies have come to power with no real hope of eventual return. Sometimes he is resettled after an interval of hardship in a new community among people of his own persuasion. But if no such place is available, he may linger indefinitely in refugee camps, living on a dole. One observer speaks of Heimatlosenauslander as “ultimate refugees” and describes their loss of affiliations:

Here you meet men whose environment has ceased to succour them. In their former normal life they had the solace of their homes in times of weariness or perplexity, perhaps even in times of unemployment. They had the consolation of their church in times of spiritual need and of family sadness. They had their trade union and political association in times when work and politics preoccupied them. They had their village inn and folk festivals on high days and holidays. All these props and cushions in life’s pilgrimage are taken from them…. (Rees 1960, p. 37)

The large-scale refugee movements of the twentieth century began with the Balkan wars of 1912–1914. World War I displaced several million civilians, most of whom were subsequently relocated. Almost every major disturbance of the interwar period generated a refugee problem, and World War ii displaced between 20 and 50 million persons; the exact number is unknown and cannot be accurately estimated. In the postwar period, the displacement of populations continued unabated in Europe, Asia, Africa, the Near East, the islands of the Pacific, the Mediterranean, and the Caribbean. Not without reason has this been called the “cen tury of the homeless man.” Most refugees are ultimately resettled, but not without great cost in suffering and dislocation. Meanwhile, the making of refugees continues at a rate that reflects the peculiar and fanatical character of twentieth-century nationalism.

Migratory farm laborers. Large-scale agriculture often requires large amounts of hand labor for brief seasonal periods. This situation frequently occurs during the transition from a plantation or family farm system with a fixed labor force to a fully mechanized system of cultivation. The transition may extend over several decades, during which the local labor force is incapable of planting and harvesting a crop without outside help. Arranging the appearance of the required number of workers at the right time and place is a perennial problem for the planters. Protecting the workers against exploitation and the natural hazards of migration is a major problem for whatever authorities assume the responsibility.

Seasonal migratory labor is required for such diverse products as coffee, cocoa, rubber, cotton, citrus fruits, wheat, apples, potatoes, and wild rice. The seasonal movement of migratory workers is significant throughout the world, often transmitting a modernizing influence from advanced to backward areas. The preliterate tribesmen brought to the coastal banana plantations of Central America, the Italian peasants cultivating sugar beets in France, the tribal Africans who migrate to cocoa plantations of Ghana, and the Mexican braceros picking peaches in Oregon all acquire new ideas and attitudes to carry back with them.

Movements of this kind are often internal as well as international. In the United States in the middle 1960s, for example, Mexicans were admitted annually on a temporary basis under a farm labor program jointly administered by the two countries, and sizable numbers were drawn under other programs from Canada, the British West Indies, Japan, and Puerto Rico. But the stream of migrants is also fed by many internal groups: Indians, mountain whites, Spanish Americans, and southern Negroes. The annual cycle begins in the South and moves steadily northward with the advancing season; some workers follow the wheat harvest all the way from southern Texas to Manitoba.

Migratory laborers vary in degree of homeless-ness. John Steinbeck’s novel, The Grapes of Wrath, painted an unforgettable picture of migrant families displaced from their ancestral farms in Oklahoma during the depression and cut loose to drift helplessly from one temporary job to another. Even in times of prosperity, the United States has an estimated one million transients who have no fixed base (Shotwell 1961, p. 34); and there are many others who have home bases to which they return between seasons or when forced back by unemployment.

A migrant work force may be composed of single men, entire families, or both. Their living and working conditions range from adequate to wretched. Like other homeless persons, migratory workers are prevented from forming or retaining normal affiliations and are subject to disproportionate hostility from their settled neighbors.

Migrancy engenders community resentment, puts in peril such practical aspects of normal family living as regular schooling for children, housing that is sanitary and convenient and conducive to wholesome family relationships, voting privileges, stable income, health and welfare services available to residents. Migrancy reduces to zero the chance to develop the feeling of belonging to a stable community. (Shotwell 1961, pp. 36-37)

The farm laborer occupies a place at the very bottom of the socioeconomic ladder, doing the most work for the lowest wages with less security and opportunity than any other segment of the population.

Solidary organizations among migrant laborers are rare. Attempts to unionize them, when not vio lently suppressed, have usually failed. However, a loose form of crew organization often develops, whereby a group of individuals or families is represented by a leader who negotiates with employers and arranges transportation and lodging.

The impact of this form of homelessness on in dividuals is mitigated by its temporary character. The available evidence suggests that most migra tory workers return to a settled life at the first opportunity, often in an area they have discovered as migrants.

The skid row man. In proportion to their numbers, skid row men in the United States and comparable homeless men in western Europe have received disproportionate attention from both scientific and literary observers. In a study using 1950 census data, Bogue (1963) identified skid row areas in 41 American cities and estimated their combined homeless population at under 100,000. The individual settlements are correspondingly small. Careful enumerations in the New York Bowery, one of the most conspicuous skid row areas in the world, disclosed less than seven thousand homeless men in 1964 and 1965 (Baker 1965, p. 7).

The name “skid row” (or “skid road”) appar ently derives from the log skidways on which felled timber was transported in the forests of the Pacific northwest. It came to be applied to the Seattle area where lumbermen wintered and then to similar enclaves in other cities where single homeless men were housed in dormitories and lodging houses, surrounded by facilities that served their special needs. Most of these enclaves, in their present locations, can be traced back about a century. In recent decades, their populations have been declining, although irregularly; and the migratory workers identified as the principal inhabitants of “hobo-hemia” after World War i (Anderson 1923) have given way to the practically immobile pensioners, alcoholics, and disadvantaged workers who make up the bulk of the population today.

The interest aroused by skid row may be explained partly by its unique institutions, partly by its high visibility, partly by the resistance of the skid row alcoholic to ameliorative programs, and partly by a life style that deviates dramatically from the success-oriented, family-centered ethos of the surrounding society. The visible facilities are cubicle lodging houses, cheap restaurants and bars, missions, barber colleges, secondhand stores and pawnshops, newspaper reading rooms, sidewalk gatherings, all-night movies and burlesque shows, tattoo parlors, “jungles” near railroad yards, and the “revolving door” of police court and workhouse. In several major cities the original area has been cleared in the course of urban redevelopment, but substitute skid rows have invariably appeared.

Ethnic and occupational characteristics vary somewhat from one skid row to another, but the population is almost exclusively male. Their average age is much higher than that of the general popu ation; a large proportion are past the usual age of retirement (Bogue 1963, pp. 8-10). About a third of the men are heavy drinkers, frequently arrested for drunkenness and apparently addicted to alcohol, although there is some doubt about their being true alcoholics. The remainder are divided between social drinkers, whose need for liquor is apparently controllable, and moderate drinkers or abstainers (Bogue 1963, pp. 90-93). Most report themselves unmarried and without active family ties. Their histories show less than average involvement in family relationships from early childhood on (Pitt-man & Gordon 1958, pp. 10, 125-138). Their organizational affiliations have often been slight throughout adult life, reflecting a permanent state of social detachment. The typical skid row man has a background of intermittent unskilled or semiskilled employment, with minimal involvement in political, religious, and recreational organizations (Bahr & Langfur 1966).

Morbidity and mortality rates are startlingly high. The risks of contagious disease, infection, exposure, injury, and malnutrition are greater on skid row than in any other urban environment (Bogue 1963, pp. 199-230). Most men live close to the margin of bare subsistence on sporadic earnings, pensions, relief payments, begging, or some combination of these. A few depend on savings or assistance from relatives; a few enjoy regular incomes and remain on skid row by preference (Bogue 1963, pp. 13-17; 46-77).

In addition to the core population, the skid row area provides temporary accommodation for migratory workers and work seekers, eccentrics, and fugitives of various kinds. Some of these men are not strictly homeless, and some homeless men have no contact with skid row. However, the predominant type is unmistakable.

The principal current trends in the status of skid row inhabitants are decreased mobility and a decline of relative income. There is, however, a rising provision of public assistance for them, and experimental programs are being undertaken in the rehabilitation of alcoholics.

Theodore Caplow, Howard M. Bahr, and David Sternberg

[Directly related is the entryRefugees. Other relevant material may be found inDrinking and alcoholism, article onsocial aspects; Migration.]

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Anderson, Nels 1923 The Hobo: The Sociology of the Homeless Man. Univ. of Chicago Press.

Bahr, Howard M.; and Langfur, Stephen J. 1966 Social Attachment and Drinking in Skid-row Life Histories. Unpublished report, Columbia Univ., Bureau of Applied Social Research.

Baker, Michael A. 1965 An Estimate of the Population of Homeless Men in the Bowery Area, New York City, February 28, 1965. Unpublished manuscript, Columbia Univ., Bureau of Applied Social Research.

Bogue, Donald J. 1963 Skid Row in American Cities. Univ. of Chicago, Community and Family Study Center.

Caplow, Theodore 1940 Transiency as a Cultural Pattern. American Sociological Review 5:731–739.

Cirtautas, Claudius K. 1957 The Refugee: A Psycho logical Study. Boston: Meador.

Dutt, Sukumar 1962 Buddhist Monks and Monasteries of India. London: Allen & Unwin.

Edwards, Albert 1912 The Beggars of Mogador. Out look 101:929–936.

Gilmore, Harlan W. 1940 The Beggar. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Press.

Holborn, Louise W. 1960 The World’s Refugees: Every one’s Concern. Washington: American Association of University Women, Committee on International Relations.

International Labour Review Staff 1957 Interterritorial Migrations of Africans South of the Sahara. International Labour Review 76:292–310.

Martin, Norman F. 1957 Los vagabundos en la Nueva Espana, siglo XVI. Mexico City: Editorial Jus.

O’Connor, Philip 1963 Vagrancy: Ethos and Actuality. Baltimore: Penguin.

Oregon, Bureau of labor 1959 …And Migrant Problems Demand Attention: The Final Report of the 1958-1959 Migrant Farm Labor Studies in Oregon. Salem: The Bureau.

Orwell, George (1933) 1950 Down and Out in Paris and London. New York: Harcourt. ? Orwell is the pseudonym of Eric Blair.

Pittman, David J.; and Gordon, C. wayne 1958 Re volving Door: A Study of the Chronic Police Case Inebriate. Glencoe, 111.: Free Press.

Pollitt, Daniel H.; and Levine, Selma M. 1960 The Migrant Farm Worker in America: Background Data on the Migrant Worker Situation in the United States Today. Washington: Government Printing Office.

Proudfoot, Malcolm J. 1957 European Refugees, 1939-1952: A Study in Forced Population Movement. London: Faber.

Rees, Elfan 1960 Common Psychological Factors in Refugee Problems Throughout the World. Pages 31-43 in World Federation for Mental Health, Uprooting and Resettlement. London: The Federation.

Shotwell, Louisa R. 1961 The Harvesters: The Story of the Migrant People. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday.

Solenbergeb, Alice W. 1911 One Thousand Homeless Men: A Study of Original Records. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, Charities Publication Committee.

Stoessinger, John G. 1956 The Refugee and the World Community. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press.

Straus, Robert 1946 Alcohol and the Homeless Man. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 7:360–404.

Sutherland, Edwin H.; and Locke, Harvey J. 1936 Twenty Thousand Homeless Men: A Study of Unem ployed Men in the Chicago Shelters. Philadelphia: Lippincott.

Vernant, Jacques 1953 The Refugee in the Post-war World. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press.

Vexliard, Alexandre 1956 Introduction à la sociologie du vagabondage. Paris: Rivière.

Wallace, Samuel E. 1965 Skid Row as a Way of Life. Totowa, N.J.: Bedminster.

Wood, Margaret M. 1953 Paths of Loneliness: The Individual Isolated in Modern Society. New York: Columbia Univ. Press.

More From encyclopedia.com