Fatigue
Fatigue
Fatigue is an experienced state of discomfort, aversion, and inability to perform, otherwise known as tiredness or weariness (Bartley 1943; Bartley & Chute 1947). The term applies to the total individual (the organism-as-a-person) and not properly to an organ or tissue. Fatigue is to be distinguished from impairment, which refers to the inability of cells or tissues to perform. Fatigue is sometimes confused with work decrement, for quite often the inquirer is actually interested in work output rather than in the state of the performer.
Fatigue is brought about in various ways, one common cause being discomfort in muscles induced by exertion, another being impairment. Very often, however, fatigue arises from some sort of disorganization within the individual. This is induced, in part, through confrontation with circumstances that are disliked or considered futile and useless. The disorganization referred to here can be described at various body-process levels. Disorganization can involve a disruption in the proper timing of various processes or a conflict between these processes with subsequent tension, awkwardness, and forgetfulness that result in discomfort and the realization of inadequacy.
Chronic fatigue often represents an unwholesome outlook on daily routine or life in general or arises from personality disorganization rather than some debilitating body processes at a lower level (Muncie 1941).
Critique of common conceptions . The common outlook that confuses fatigue with impairment is characterized by several points, some of which are acceptable and some not (Bartley 1951). First is the view that activity modifies the acting system, and that the modification is a chemical one. Fatigue is taken to be such a modification. However, this is really impairment and is a phenomenon that takes place at the tissue level, whereas fatigue is a phenomenon at the personality level–the experience, the self-awareness of condition. It is also assumed that fatigue can be either a general body condition or specifically localized. The slowing down of a process is taken to be the evidence of fatigue or, by some writers, to be fatigue itself. Here again, it seems to be impairment that is at issue.
Conventional assumptions shift from considering fatigue as tissue effects to considering it as the way the organism-as-a-person behaves. Even at this level compensation is generally overlooked in human performance. This is evidenced in the tacit assumption made by many that the subject has only one way of performing a given task. For example, it is not presumed that one muscle fiber group may be recovering while some other group is taking its place in carrying on over-all performance. But this type of compensation does occur, and it makes many of the simple, customarily performed “fatigue” experiments inappropriate and inadequate.
It is also false to assume that fatigue developed in one kind of performance may be measured by using an altogether different performance as a test.
The concern with fatigue as distinct from work output arises most directly and forcefully in medical practice and is even encountered in athletics. Physicians are being constantly confronted with patients who complain of tiredness, sometimes in connection with convalescence from debilitating disease or simply as a syndrome of its own (Alvarez 1941; Harms & Soniat 1952; Muncie 1941). On the other hand, work output is generally the main concern in industry (Dill et al. 1936; Edwards et al. 1935). Fatigue is often a term incorrectly inferred when an individual notices certain symptoms. In this case, what is called fatigue is self-diagnosis rather than something that arises as a directly felt inability to perform. Thus, a patient may tell an ophthalmologist that he has visual fatigue, inferring this (a self-diagnosis) from the fact that after reading awhile what he sees becomes blurred. This is different than his reporting how he feels. Such a usage of fatigue is to be avoided if the language on fatigue is to be consistent.
Finally, according to the conventional view, there are several kinds of fatigue. The more basic categorization distinguishes objective fatigue (work decrement); subjective fatigue (the experience of tiredness); and physiological fatigue (change or reduction in a specific body process).
Although there are various additionally specified kinds of fatigue, when fatigue exists it is essentially the same in all cases. The core of fatigue is the self-realization of relative inability to carry on. It is a negative orientation toward a task demand. Although the stance toward demand is always essentially the same, various fringe details (various sensory and other components) may vary from case to case, but they are mere details in the unique over-all syndrome that is distinguishable as fatigue.
For example, fatigue arising in intellectual tasks should not be called mental fatigue, if by that one means a special kind of fatigue. Mental fatigue is only the fatigue that arises in intellectual (mental) tasks. Despite the fact that many kinds of tasks may lead to fatigue, no implication that there are many kinds of fatigue should be made.
So many loosely related phenomena have been called fatigue that it has been suggested that the word be done away with entirely (Muscio 1921). Bartley and colleagues (Bartley 1943; 1951; 1957; Bartley & Chute 1945; 1947) have chosen rather to retain the word in its original meaning (i.e., for the phenomena first labeled “tiredness”) and rename other phenomena associated with it.
Problems in studying fatigue . Many studies that are meant to be studies of fatigue begin with questions about the experience of tiredness and inability to continue performance and end up by bypassing these questions and by providing information about other problems. For example, an investigator may note that workers in a plant feel sluggish and ineffective during mid-morning and mid-afternoon. He may suppose that this has something to do with blood sugar level. In his study he finds that at these times blood sugar level is lowest. He may then try a plan whereby the workers take in the same total amount of food per day but eat varying numbers of meals. Some eat two, some three, some four, and some even five meals per day. Blood sugar level is then tested periodically throughout the day. It is found that where many meals are eaten the blood sugar level never falls as low at any part of the work day as it does when few meals are eaten. At this point, the investigator assumes his study is completed. He should continue and determine whether the feeling of sluggishness is eliminated or greatly reduced by redistributing food intake into a greater number of meals, with the total intake held constant. It is only when he has performed this additional step that the original questions of sluggishness and inefficiency receive an answer. It is only then that the investigation becomes a fatigue investigation.
One of the persistent problems in dealing with fatigue is its measurement. It is always expected that if an entity exists it can be measured. The definition of fatigue as a relation to demand in which the individual feels his own inability to go on makes easy measurement unattainable. When work output is all that is to be measured, such measurement is easily made. However, the problem of measuring fatigue as defined here is no different from the problem of measuring anxiety, depression, boredom, hope, anger, or a virtually uncountable number of other states of the organ-ism-as-a-person. Thus, the concept of fatigue should not be singled out for criticism because it refers to a phenomenon difficult to quantify. Nevertheless, such criticism has been leveled, at times, against what is conventionally called “subjective fatigue,” for that reason.
The first point to be recognized is that the phenomenon in question must exist in order to be measured or dealt with in any way. The first step in studying it is to produce it. The second is to manipulate conditions under which it occurs. The next point to realize is that the person fatigued is the only one able to state when it exists. The observations made by all others have to do with overt performance, body process, or both, which are not fatigue although they may be closely related to it in some way. It is also to be recognized that the problem of quantitatively dealing with fatigue involves either developing a fatigue scale or choosing a fatigue point, such as the point at which the performer is no longer able to continue.
It will become quickly evident that in most cases the crucial conditions that lead to fatigue lie within the subject himself rather than the external conditions that produce the demand. Whatever is done to study fatigue, the organism-centered approach is necessary. In fact, it is necessary in trying to understand work output as well.
In certain ways, the phenomena that are per-sonalistic rather than environmental can be studied more concretely than might be supposed. For example, it certainly is possible to manipulate goals (which are personalistic phenomena). In setting a task for a subject one can tell him something that will indicate the amount of time required to perform the task. One can then vary the amount of time so indicated to see what remoteness of goals has to do with the self-assessments of the subjects at various moments during performance and whether this variable has anything to do with the point at which “exhaustion” is reached. Other such dimensions and their body-process concomitants can also be chosen.
Another problem in studying fatigue has to do with how far various subjects will push themselves either in their use of energy resources or in experiencing bodily discomfort. This problem is related to motivation, and its solution may actually be a way of dealing with or measuring motivation. This problem is encountered not only in psychological experimentation but also in the physiological treadmill experiments. Some subjects “reach their limits” in muscular exertion before oxygen debt occurs, while others do not. No physiologist would expect that a subject would be exhausted before oxygen debt appears. These results illustrate the difference in the amount that individuals will push themselves. Thus the problem of subjectivity is as inherent in many phases of physiology as in psychology. Hence it cannot be disposed of by assuming that it occurs only in nonbehavioristic types of research.
Relieving fatigue. Various drugs and other substances have been tried by investigators to relieve fatigue and improve performance in athletic activities (Karpovich 1959; Smith & Beecher 1959).
Fatigue may often be relieved by inducing a change of attitude or attention or by shifting from one task to another rather than by rest (inactivity). Supposedly the needed change involves reorganization within the individual rather than a replenishment of energy.
Fatigue and the syndrome called stress by Selye (1956) have a lot in common, particularly certain factors of origin. Selye’s discoveries and concepts go a long way toward providing a bodily basis for human incapacity, and when this is coupled with a monistic psychology, which attempts to understand human behavior, considerable progress seems to be possible.
S. Howard Hartley
[Other relevant material may be found inACHIEVEMENT MOTIVATION; INFANCY, article OnTHE EFFECTS OF EARLY EXPERIENCE; SLEEP; STRESS.]
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ALVAREZ, W. C. 1941 What Is the Matter With the Patient Who Is Chronically Tired? Journal of the Missouri State Medical Association38 : 365–368.
HARTLEY, S. HOWARD 1943 Conflict, Frustration and Fatigue. Psychosomatic Medicine5 : 160–163.
BARTLEY, S. HOWARD 1951 Fatigue and Efficiency. Pages 318-347 in Harry Helson (editor), Theoretical Foundations of Psychology. New York: Van Nostrand.
HARTLEY, S. HOWARD 1957 Fatigue and Inadequacy. Physiological Reviews37 : 301–324.
HARTLEY, S. HOWARD; and CHUTE, ELOISE 1945 A Preliminary Clarification of the Concept of Fatigue. Psy-chological Review52 : 169–174.
HARTLEY, S. HOWARD; and CHUTE, ELOISE 1947 Fatigue and Impairment in Man. New York: McGraw-Hill.
DILL, D. B. et al. 1936 Industrial Fatigue. Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology18 : 417–431.
EDWARDS, H. T.; THORNDIKE, A.; and DILL, D. B. 1935 The Energy Requirement in Strenuous Muscular Exercise. New England Journal of Medicine213 : 532–535.
HARMS, H. E.; and SONIAT, T. L. L. 1952 The Meaning of Fatigue. Medical Clinics of North America36 : 311–317.
KARPOVICH, P. V. 1959 Effect of Amphetamine Sulfate on Athletic Performance. Journal of the American Medical Association170 : 558–561.
Muncie, Wendell 1941 Chronic Fatigue. Psychosomatic Medicine3 : 277–285.
Muscio, B. 1921 Is a Fatigue Test Possible? British Journal of Psychology12 : 31–46.
Selye, Hans 1956 The Stress of Life. New York: McGraw-Hill.
SMITH, G. M.; and BEECHER, H. K. 1959 Amphetamine Sulfate and Athletic Performance. Journal of the American Medical Association170:542–557.
Whiting, Helen F.; and ENGLISH, HORACE B. 1925 Fatigue Tests and Incentives. Journal of Experimental Psychology8 : 33–49.
