Learning Disorders
Learning disorders
Definition
Learning disorders (LD) refer to a significant deficit in learning due to a person's inability to interpret what is seen and heard, or to link information from different parts of the brain.
Description
Academic deficiency is frequently associated with neurologic and psychological disorders. Severe academic problems may occur as a primary disorder of learning. Learning disorders can be classified in three major types: disorder of written expression (DWE); reading disorder (RD); and mathematics disorder (MD). The description of learning disorders corresponds to the educational legal designation of learning disabilities. Learning disabilities are legally defined by Public Law in a law called the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, or IDEA. The IDEA defines a learning disability as a disorder in written or spoken language that results in an imperfect ability to listen, think, read, spell, write, or do mathematics. The act excludes persons who have learning impairments that are solely due to hearing problems, visual problems, motor problems, mental retardation , or due to environmental deprivation. The rules and related laws of IDEA stipulate that children with LD are entitled to free education and special services. A fourth category of LD has also been established for an LD that does not fulfill all the criteria (called an LD not otherwise specified.) Age of onset of LD is closely related to clinical presentation. Most cases of LD can be detected between preschool and second grade. Typically, onset of LD before first grade, often demonstrates developmental delay in learning new concepts at home, or as a delay in performance in school (delay is observed relative to other children and is observed by school officials). If the onset of LD occurs in early grade school (first or second grade), then observations typically include slow learning and difficulty completing and mastering schoolwork which often results in poor grades.
Demographics
LD occurs in approximately 5% to 10% of the population of which about 50% are classified as reading disorder. The remaining 50% of LD falls under the categories of disorder of written expression, mathematics disorder or atypical LD. LD is more common in males than females by 2:1 or 4:1 ratio. Children with LD have an increased risk for emotional behavioral problems and comorbidity (50% of the 1.6 million children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder [ADHD] have an LD). Approximately 2% to 8% of elementary school children have reading disorder (dyslexia). Speech disorder occurs in approximately 10% of children younger than 8 years of age. ADHD is a comorbid condition that occurs in approximately four million school-aged children (20% of them are unable to focus their attention to required tasks in school and at home).
Causes and symptoms
Reading Disorder
The cause of reading disorder is underactivity in the left superior posterior temporal lobe (planum temporale). Research using functional and structural neuroimaging techniques, demonstrates that this underactivity is evident during reading tasks. It is believed that the planum temporale is a region that is important for phonologic processing. Genetic studies reveal that there is a higher concordance rate for RD in identical (71%) than fraternal (49%) twins. Additionally, heritability of RD may be more than 50% especially in a disorder with a focal deficit in phonologic processing (phonologic dyslexia). Some genetic investigations have identified possible genes for RD, located on chromosome six and 15. Modern research techniques have demonstrated that RD is the result of brain deficits in processing sound units and sound-symbol relationships.
Most of the persons diagnosed with reading disorder (RD) have average or higher intelligence. RD is considered synonymous with dyslexia , since spelling and reading are related. Persons with RD often have deficits with spelling. Affected individuals have difficulty with phonologic processing. This means that affected persons have deficits in the process of identifying and manipulating individual sounds (phonemes) within larger sound units (morphemes and words.) Symptoms usually appear before early grade school. Patients cannot translate a visual stimulus (letters) into a meaningful blend of sounds (i.e. they have deficits in phonics). Reading is slower and more mechanical even with treatment. Typically, reading takes more effort in affected patients, often requiring intense concentration, especially on the pronunciation and identification of individual words. The increased concentration required during reading can impair the person's attention ability, causing mental fatigue, attention problems (less attention available for comprehension and memory). Sometimes, but not often, children may have visualization-comprehension or memory deficits causing RD. Persons with visualization-comprehension weakness often exhibit difficulty visualizing what is being read. The cause of visualization-comprehension weakness occurs because of deficits in visual organization (nonverbal skills.) This is a vital deficit since reading comprehension is based on some visualization (nonverbal skills.) However, in the majority of affected children with RD it is the deficits in phonologic processing (processing phonemes within morphemes and words) that are responsible for difficulty with comprehension or memory.
Mathematics Disorder
The cause of mathematics disorder (MD) is thought to be due to a nonverbal weakness. MD could take various forms and therefore the causes also change. There may be deficits visualizing and visually organizing mathematical concepts and manipulations. Some patients may have short-term or working memory deficits which can interfere with processing mathematical calculations. The cause of MD can be linked to a larger atypical LD.
The symptoms of MD can vary. Patients can exhibit dyscalculia or acalculia (deficits in mathematical calculation). Dyscalculia patients may over-rely on memory and tangible aids, because they have deficits to mentally calculate arithmetic manipulations. Symptoms in some patients can include deficits in memory (short term and working memory or deficits in visual organization or mathematical concepts).
Disorder of Written Expression
The cause of the disorder of written expression in some persons may be due to deficits in visual-motor integration and motor coordination. Most causes of DWE occur because there are deficits in the brain concerning information translation from auditory-oral modality to visual-written modality. The cause of this deficit is unknown.
Patients often exhibit spelling deficits that include problems with punctuation, grammar, and development of ideas during writing. Writing samples from persons with DWE are typically brief, simple, or may be difficult to comprehend because of grammar and punctuation errors. Patients with visual-motor deficits write with so much care that they often lose track of ideas and thoughts. If motor coordination is the only cause then symptoms may be classified more appropriately as a motor skills disorder not a DWE. Typically symptoms are not apparent until the third or fourth grade, when academic exercises demand development of ideas.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of LD can be made if there is significant discrepancy between intelligence test scores (raw ability to learn) and achievement test score (actual learning achievement). However, the diagnosis can be a complex process since there is no universal agreement concerning the magnitude of discrepancy between test scores, nor is there a consensus concerning which test scores should be analyzed to obtain a statistical analysis of discrepancy. Tests should be administered to establish that low intelligence alone is not the cause of underachievement (i.e. children with mental retardation are not diagnosed with LDs.) There are several psychological tests that separately measure intelligence (i.e. Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children) and achievement (Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement, K-TEA).
Treatment Team
The treatment team typically includes school counselors, education specialists, specialists in learning disorders, school psychologists or clinical psychologists (with advanced clinical training in administration and interpretation of psychological tests (psychometrics). Tests for achievement and intelligence should be administered and interpreted by a clinical psychologist or a school psychologist. Only a duly licensed or certified clinical or school psychologist can administer the recommended psychological tests. A full written report of results and interpretation of results is typically prepared and submitted to concerned persons.
Treatment
Before treatment is initiated, a very comprehensive evaluation is necessary with standardized achievement and intelligence tests.
Treatment for RD-affected persons involves a plan that provides intensive tutoring to develop phonologic processing and fluent word reading with treatment objectives that emphasize comprehension. There are several treatment approaches (Gillingham-Stillman Approach, Fernald-Keller Approach or Lindamood-Bell Reading Program) that provide intensive phonic practice and phonic associations with sensory integration or mnemonic strategies to remember letter-sound blends and relationships.
Treatment for MD can vary widely since MD can have a variety of causes and presentations. The treatment program is typically highly individualized and specific to enhance and expand upon strengths to improve weaknesses and math errors. Sometimes analogies are utilized to demonstrate abstract concepts and to build upon concepts (concrete learning) until the concept becomes understood or mastered. Flash cards and practice drills can help to memorize simple mathematical operations such as multiplication tables. MD due to visual-organization deficits can be treated with visualization techniques to improve math errors.
Treatment for DWE can involve interventions that help to improve written expression caused by a deficit in the expressive task of writing. There are several treatment plans that include writing in more "natural environments" (i.e. encourages keeping a diary or making "lists"), writing notes and outlines before attempting writing prose, and talking-to-writing progression. The talking-to-writing progression approach initially involves the affected child taking the role of dictating while another person writes for the child. As the treatments progress, the roles are gradually reversed until the child is able to dictate and write without assistance. Treatment continues with dictation until the child is independently thinking and writing. Treatment interventions for atypical LDs involve objectives to expand on the child's strengths (i.e. verbal and rote learning strengths) and to provide additional experience and practice in nonverbal weakness areas. Atypical LDs are complex disorders and treatment interventions are detailed and typically include teaching social and nonverbal material with extensive practice and concrete examples; teaching the affected person in rote in a predictable fashion; and the utilization and application of known algorithms to new situations. Additionally, treatment can include practicing organizational skills at home; practicing attention to visual and auditory (verbal information); and to encourage supervised and highly structured and inter-active peer experiences.
Clinical trials
There are many clinical trials (http://www.nlm.nih.gov) currently in progress. The studies currently sponsored by governmental agencies focus on topics that include coping, diagnosis, symptoms specific aspects of disorders, and law and public policy.
Prognosis
It is rare for persons with LD to completely improve their academic deficiencies. However, performance in the area of weakness can significantly improve with appropriate treatment interventions.
Recovery
Recovery is slow and patients are often in specialized intervention programs (MD, DWE) or are part of programs that offer specific treatments (RD).
Other Atypical LDs
There are two common patterns of working memory deficits. Nonverbal learning disability (NVLD) is a neuropsychological syndrome characterized by deficits in comprehension, motor skills, visual-perception organization, tactile perception and novel problem solving, comprehension, visual memory, concept formation, and integration/organization of information. However, NVLD patients exhibit strengths in simple verbal skills, rote learning, memory, and knowledge of facts. In addition to weakness in mathematical achievement most persons affected by NVLD also tend to have problems with written expression, reading comprehension and social skills. Persons affected with working memory deficits tend to lose track of information as they are mentally processing that information or other information. Patients with working memory deficits often have problems with mathematical manipulations (which requires working memory), and the disorder is often accompanied by ADHD. Working memory is defined as the ability to remember information while executing another cognitive task.
Resources
BOOKS
Behrman, Richard, E., et al., eds. Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, 17th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders, 2004.
Goetz, Christopher G., et al, eds. Textbook of Clinical Neurology, 1st ed. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Company, 1999.
PERIODICALS
Frank, Y., and Steven G. Pavlakis. "Brain Imaging in Neurobehavioral Disorders." Pediatric Neurology 25, no. 4 (October 2001).
Kronenberger, William G., and David Dunn. "Learning Disorders." Neurologic Clinics 21, no. 4 (November 2003).
Toppelberg, Claudio O., and Theodore Shapiro. "Language Disorders: A 10-Year Research Update Review." Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 39, no.2 (February 2000).
WEBSITES
National Center for Learning Disabilities. <http://www.ld.org>.
National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders. <http://www.nidcd.nih.gov>.
ORGANIZATIONS
National Institute of Mental Health, Office of Communications. 6001 Executive Boulevard, Room 8184, MSC 9663, Bethesda, MD 20892-9663. (301) 443-4513 or 1-866-615-6464; Fax: (301) 443-4279.
Laith Farid Gulli, MD
Nicole Mallory
