Feminist Theology

views updated

Feminist Theology

Feminist theology examines the history, beliefs, and practices of religious traditions from feminist perspectives. More accurately termed "feminist theologies," the field encompasses a wide array of theoretical and experiential approaches to issues of sex and gender, as well as age, class, identity, and race. Feminist theologians have pioneered theories and methods in comparative religion, ethics, the history of religion, liturgy, religious philosophy, ritual, the sociology of religion, and textual interpretation.

Contemporary American feminist theologies are rooted in the nineteenth-century "first wave" of feminism, which sought both political and social equality for women. While much of this early feminist movement focused on emancipation and social welfare, a number of its leaders recognized that religious beliefs and practices also played a significant role in determining the status of women. They criticized the androcentrism (male focus) of biblical interpretation, religious leadership, and theological arguments used to justify the subordination of women.

This critique of religious androcentrism was taken up with the emergence of "second-wave" feminism in the 1960s and 1970s and provided a foundation for the new field of feminist theological inquiry. Pioneering feminist theologians exposed sexism in existing religious constructs. As with many other areas of feminist scholarship, this critical work was given expression in both academic and community settings. An important purpose of the work was (and continues to be) both to challenge and reconstruct intellectual paradigms and to effect feminist transformation of religious institutions.

In addition to the critical perspectives involved in seeking to eliminate androcentrism, early feminist theologians laid the groundwork for religious reforms and renewal that continue to the present. On a philosophical level, feminist theologies concerned with women's experience questioned and proposed new constructions of traditional views of divinity, human nature, revelation, salvation, and other religious categories. They sought to develop methodologies that valued feminine qualities of inclusivity and relationship. The reality and significance of lesbianism became a category of both inquiry and activism. New rituals and liturgy were created, rooted in distinctive female life-cycle events, such as menstruation and childbirth, as well as previously hidden areas, such as battering, incest, rape, and sexual abuse.

At the same time the work of other feminist theologians was based on a rejection of separate female and male human nature or spirituality. These theologians sought to transform religion by fully integrating women's teachings and experience into a common, egalitarian spiritual practice for women and men.

Feminist theological innovations also occurred within existing schools of contemporary religious thought, especially within liberation theology, a movement based on compatible values of the integration of theory and activism as well as an overriding concern with liberating social transformation. Feminist theologians were influenced by scholarship in other fields as they created new methods of textual analysis and historical interpretation.

Concurrent with attempts to integrate feminism into existing dominant traditions was a strain of feminist theology—or more accurately, thealogy (goddess study)—that rejected those institutions altogether in favor of new and re-created goddess-centered traditions. These thealogians emphasized an unbreakable link between the self- and social esteem of women and explicitly female images of the divine. They were also responsible for the growth of research into suppressed goddess imagery and traditions within andro-centric religions.

By the late 1970s and early 1980s, American minority groups were asserting their voices within the field of religious studies, demanding greater recognition as distinctive groups whose historical, spiritual, and communal experiences remained unexpressed in the feminist theologies of the academy. These groups challenged others to incorporate a greater awareness of racism, classism, heterosexism, and anti-Semitism into their work as feminist theologians. Such concerns regarding diversity reflected discussion in the larger feminist movements of the time and had an impact on feminist theologies in several ways.

One effect was the development of distinct strands of feminist theology based on differences of identity. By the early 1980s African-American feminists began to refer to themselves as "womanists," reclaiming and reinterpreting a distinctive cultural language to name a simultaneous female and black identity. Soon afterwards, Latina feminists coined the term mujerista to express a commitment to a perspective fully inclusive of their identities as both women and members of diverse Hispanic communities. In a similar manner, Asian Americans, Jewish Americans, Native Americans, and Muslim Americans have developed feminist theologies in which feminism is understood as interwoven in, rather than opposed to, their specific cultural identities.

A second direction brought about by an increased awareness of difference and diversity among women was that these issues themselves became the subject of feminist theological inquiry. As the 1980s progressed, the influence of deconstructionism, a movement critical of the notion of stable or singular identities, led to a questioning of whether there should or even could be any coherent explication of "female" experience. This critique demanded a more sophisticated analysis of the interplay among multiple, evolving, and competing forms of individual and group identities. It called into question the significance of work that assumed any fixed perspectives, including sex, race, and class. Early feminist theorists distinguished what they understood to be biologically determined sex (female or male) from socially constructed gender (femininity or masculinity). Now feminist theologians began to examine the fluidity of all these categories and develop an analysis of "gendered" power relations among men as well as women in religious contexts. Influenced by queer studies, feminist theologies have also challenged normative, static categories of sexuality and brought to light supressed homoeroticism within religious traditions.

No longer able to generalize about all women, feminist theologians have increasingly focused their work on specific women, historical and contemporary, and the particularities of their experience. This abandonment of the attempt to formulate a singular voice has allowed a renewed unity of purpose in which feminist theologies speak not for but with each other in a common enterprise.