Zeno of Elea
ZENO OF ELEA
Greek philosopher of the Parmenidean school; b. c. 489 b.c. While still quite young he wrote a series of 40 arguments designed to defend the Eleatic denial of motion and plurality. Only fragments of this book are extant. In about 450 b.c. he traveled to Athens and possibly taught there for some time. His political activities reputedly resulted in his being put to death by the tyrant Nearchus of Elea, although the date and details are not known. Aristotle called him the father of dialectics because of his ability to draw two contradictory conclusions from an opponent's assumptions.
Zeno's arguments against pluralism appear to be directed to the Pythagoreans who held that extended physical bodies are composed of nonextended mathematical points. Zeno argued that everything in the universe is both infinitely large and has no size at all, a blatant contradiction. The infinite divisibility of any physical body regardless of size means that it is composed of an infinite number of elements, and is thus infinitely large. On the other hand the body has no size at all because no number of nonextended units can produce an extended body. A parallel argument comes to the conclusion that any plurality is both finite and infinite.
Zeno's famous four paradoxes concerning motion, presented in Aristotle's Physics (239b 5–240a 18), are as follows: (1) It is impossible to traverse any finite distance because one must first reach the midpoint, then the next midpoint, then the next, etc., to infinity. (2) In the race between Achilles and the tortoise, who is given a head start, Achilles can never win because when he reaches the point from which the tortoise started, the tortoise has moved a short distance ahead, etc., to infinity. (3) A flying arrow is at rest, for at any moment it occupies some place, and when it is in a place it is at rest. (4) If two bodies, A and B, are traveling toward each other with equal velocity, then A passes B twice as fast as it passes another body C at rest. Therefore, a whole time is equal to half of itself.
The basic point behind Zeno's paradoxes is that the infinitely divisible becomes actually divided to infinity when traversed. His arguments emphasized the need for a more adequate theory of the continuum. Although his thought was more polemical than constructive, Zeno's intriguing paradoxes are a classic statement of the problems of the continuum and have won him a permanent place of importance in the history of philosophy and science.
See Also: continuum; motion.
Bibliography: Sources. h. diels, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker: Griechisch und Deutsch, ed. w. kranz, 3 v. (9th ed. Berlin 1956); v. 1 (10th ed. Berlin 1960–61). k. freeman, tr., Ancilla to the Pre–Socratic Philosophers (Cambridge, Mass. 1957). Studies. h. d. r. lee, Zeno of Elea (Cambridge, Eng. 1936). j. burnet, Early Greek Philosophy (4th ed. London 1930; reprint New York 1957). f. c. copleston, History of Philosophy (Westminster, Md. 1946–63) 1:54–59.
[r. j. blackwell]
