Portugal

views updated

PORTUGAL

Before psychoanalysis was institutionalized in Portugal, certain cultural events paved the way for the reception that Freud's doctrines were later to receive. It is widely accepted that the birth of psychoanalysis in France and Austria was influenced by experiments relating to hypnosis (Mesmer and Charcot). Similarly, we can say that in Portugal José Custódio de Faria (1756-1819), known as Abbé Faria, was an important precursor. Born in Goa, he studied theology in Lisbon and Rome before becoming a priest. He was in Paris in the troubled days of the French Revolution and the Empire, and it was there that he became a disciple of the magnetists. He studied under Mesmer and Puységur, and the theories he presented in his book, De la cause du sommeil lucide (1819, The Cause of Lucid Sleep), were ahead of his time — he was the first to abandon theories of magnetic fluids and anticipated his contemporaries in his descriptions of post-hypnotic suggestion.

The impact of Freud's discoveries began to be felt in Portugal at the beginning of the twentieth century. Egas Moniz (1874-1955) was the first to present the bases for Freud's theory. Moniz had taken an interest in sexology early in his career, and in 1901 he published a book entitled Sexual Life (Physiology and Pathology), which ran to several thousand copies in a few years. In 1925 he published a remarkable biography of Abbé Faria. Because Moniz was preoccupied with sexual life and hypnotism, it was only logical for him to take an interest in psychoanalysis also. In fact, between 1915 and 1925 he published several articles on psychoanalytic theory and method. In two of these articles Moniz described two long cures of neurotic patients, with whom he used the couch, free association, and dream interpretation. In both cases he managed to resolve the neurotic conflicts by having recourse to psychoanalytic psychotherapy. As time went by Moniz's activities centered increasingly on neurological problems. After he discovered cerebral angiography (1927), for which he won the Nobel Prize, he devoted himself entirely to neurology—to the exclusion of psychotherapy and the sexual life. We may well wonder how the psychoanalytic movement would have evolved in Portugal if Moniz, who really was a man of genius, had continued with his initial research and joined Freud's Viennese circle instead of going to work in Paris with Pierre Marie, Jules Déjerine, and Joseph Babinski.

Other psychiatrists, like Sobral Cid (1877-1941), a professor of psychiatry at the university of Lisbon, and Diogo Furtado (1906-1963), one of the most brilliant neuro-psychiatrists of his day, manifested great interest in the theory of psychoanalysis. But they did not continue Moniz's therapeutic work, nor his observations.

After these false starts, a Portuguese psychoanalytic movement finally saw the light of day in the 1950s. Portuguese physicians, beginning with Francisco Alvim and Pedro Luzes, went to Switzerland to train in Raymond de Saussure's Geneva group. They became full members of the Swiss Society and met in Geneva with Spanish analysts who were also in training there (Pedro Bofill, Pere Folch Mateu, and José Rallo Romero).

Together they decided to organize the Luso-Spanish Psychoanalytic Society, which the International Psychoanalytic Association (IPA) recognized as a study group at the Paris Congress in 1957. Two years later this study group was admitted as a component society at the Copenhagen Congress. The Luso-Spanish Society continued to grow, with the addition of analysts who were generally trained abroad, but training progressively came to be set up in Spain and Portugal.

In 1966, the Iberian group split because of problems of distance and other difficulties, giving birth to the Portuguese study group. Although the IPA may have granted the Luso-Spanish Society the status of a component society somewhat prematurely, too much time was allowed to pass before the Portuguese study group was recognized as a provisional society (1977) and then a component society (at the Helsinki Congress in 1981). This can largely be explained by the change in the IPA statutes, which became increasingly demanding in terms of the required number of members, with benchmarks being used to establish intermediary stages.

The title "Portuguese Psychoanalytic Society" nevertheless began to be used (locally) in 1971. Prior to 1981, several international meetings and congresses had already been held in Portugal. In 1968, the twenty-ninth Congress of Romance-Language Psychoanalysts was organized in Lisbon. Pedro Luzes presented a report entitled "Thinking Disorders in Clinical Psychoanalysis." It was one of the first works from outside Great Britain to stress the importance of Bion's research into thinking. In 1978 the second Conference of the European Federation of Psychoanalysis was held in Estoril on the theme: "The Narcissism of the Psychoanalyst." In 1980, again in Estoril, the First World Congress on Infant Psychiatry, dedicated to the memory of René Spitz, focused on normal and pathological aspects in the first two years of infant life. The forty-fourth and fifty-fourth Congresses of French-Speaking Psychoanalysts met in Estoril and Lisbon, respectively, in 1984 and 1994.

Since 1989, biennial Iberian congresses of psychoanalysis have brought together the Portuguese Society, the Spanish Society (with its headquarters in Barcelona), and the Madrid Psychoanalytic Association. Together these institutions publish the Iberian Directory of Psychoanalysis in the Castilian language.

In 1975, the Portuguese Psychoanalytic Society inaugurated an Institute of Psycho-analysis. As a center for psychoanalytic treatment its main function is to provide assistance. It is also active in providing psychoanalytic training. In addition to ten consulting chambers, the institute has several meeting rooms and an ample library containing all the most essential psychoanalytic books and reviews. The Society publishes the Portuguese Review of Psychoanalysis every semester. The first issue appeared in 1985. In terms of scientific activities and dissemination of psychoanalysis, it is important to mention the scientific encounters that usually take place twice a year, called symposia (when predominantly clinical) and seminars (when predominantly cultural).

The problem of schools and divergent currents in psychoanalysis made its presence felt in Portugal, as everywhere else, though perhaps less acutely than in other countries, probably because in the context of a small society deep rifts and intense rivalries run the risk of destroying the analytic group. In the period between the 1940s and the 1980s, when the Portuguese Psychoanalytic Society was finding its feet, the opposition between so-called Freudian (also called "classical") analysts and Kleinian analysts came to a head. In the Freudian camp were Francisco Alvim (who trained in Raymond de Saussure's group in Geneva) and João dos Santos (who trained in Paris). Kleinian ideas were introduced to Portugal by Pedro Luzes who, while working in the same Geneva group as Alvim, was also analyzed by Marcelle Spira (a Swiss analyst who received Kleinian training in Argentina). The Freudian nucleus sought support from the Paris Psychoanalytic Society. Beginning in 1962, Pierre Luquet, its representative in Portugal, provided regular teaching for more than twenty years. The Kleinian group received more limited support from the British. Today the theoretical ideas of most of the members and students in the Portuguese Society are mixed, having both Freudian and Kleinian roots. This epistemological constitution is close to what the British call Group B. The Portuguese Psychoanalytic Society recently undertook the task of institutionalizing the training of child psychoanalysts among young analysts and candidates. To do so they relied mainly on French analysts (Florence Guignard, Annie Anzieu, Jean Bégoin, Didier Houzel, Donald Meltzer, and Antonino Ferro).

Several tendencies claiming to have a dynamic model of the mental continue to evolve along parallel lines. Some, being analytical, take their inspiration from the teachings of Jacques Lacan. Others are influenced by the systemic current (group analysis and family therapy). The psychoanalytic trend as defined above nevertheless dominates all of these movements.

Pedro Luzes

Bibliography

Chemouni, Jacquy. (1990) Histoire du mouvement psychanalytique. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

Luzes, Pedro. (1979). Four recently discovered letters by Freud to a Portuguese correspondent. A contribution to the pre-history of psychoanalysis in Portugal. International Review of Psycho-Analysis, 6, 437-440.

More From encyclopedia.com