Wagner, Robert Ferdinand
Wagner, Robert Ferdinand
(b. 20 April 1910 in New York City; d. 12 February 1991 in New York City), lawyer, diplomat, and liberal Democratic politician who served three terms as mayor of New York City.
Wagner was the only child of Margaret McTague and Robert Ferdinand Wagner, who served in the United States Senate from 1927 to 1949 and advocated for the creation of the Social Security system and the passage of landmark labor laws. His mother died of injuries sustained in an automobile accident when he was only nine years old, so “Young Bob” often accompanied his father to political events and grew up in an atmosphere of liberal Democratic politics.
After the death of his illustrious father in May 1953, Wagner dropped the “junior” from his name. His elder son, who also became prominent in New York City politics, then became known as Robert F. Wagner, Jr.
As a boy Wagner made numerous trips to Europe, especially to Germany where his father was born. After attending prestigious private schools in New York and Connecticut, Wagner entered Yale and graduated in 1933. After postgraduate work at the Harvard Business School and the School of International Relations in Geneva, Switzerland, he attended Yale University Law School, earning his LL.B. in 1937.
In 1937 he won the New York State Assembly seat once held by his father. In the assembly, Wagner sponsored public housing programs, sought to establish compulsory health insurance, and worked to improve labor relations. He was twice reelected, but after the entry of the United States into World War II in December 1941, Wagner resigned to join the army air corps. He served in the Eighth Bomber Command and rose to the rank of lieutenant colonel. Meanwhile, on 14 February 1942 Wagner married Susan Edwards of Greenwich, Connecticut, at Saint Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City. The couple had two sons.
After his discharge in 1945 Wagner served in a variety of appointed positions in New York City’s government. When his father resigned from the Senate in 1949, Wagner announced his interest in succeeding him, but he did not get his party’s nomination in a special election to fill the seat. Instead, he ran successfully for the borough presidency of Manhattan, a position he held until December 1953. While in that office Wagner again sought the Democratic nomination for his father’s old Senate seat but lost the primary election in August 1952. However, in September 1953 Wagner won the New York City Democratic nomination for mayor and went on to defeat his Republican opponent in November.
In January 1954 Wagner entered the office he would hold for three four-year terms, a feat achieved by only two other men: Fiorello La Guardia before him and Edward I. Koch after him. However, his tenure (1954-1965) came at a time when the city was undergoing major demographic change. Many members of the white middle class were moving to nearby suburbs, while increasing numbers of poor Puerto Ricans and southern blacks were moving to the city. Thus, Wagner was mayor during a period of tremendous social and economic change.
During his mayoralty, Wagner recognized the right of city employees to form unions and bargain collectively, thereby setting a pattern for municipal labor unions throughout the country. He secured the building of thousands of units of public housing, including many for middle-income families. He helped develop the nation’s first municipal law outlawing discrimination in housing based on race (Sharkey-Brown-Isaacs Law of 1957).
However, the influx of poorer people in need of social services led to a rapid increase in the city’s expenditures, which began to outpace revenues. Rather than raise taxes, Mayor Wagner resorted to borrowing, saying “a good loan is better than a bad tax.” Thus, say his critics, were sown the seeds of New York City’s fiscal crisis of the early 1970s. But Wagner’s efforts to respond to problems arising from the change in the city’s ethnic and racial composition perhaps enabled New York to escape the kind of devastating race riots that tore apart Los Angeles, Detroit, and Newark, New Jersey, during the 1960s, though racial strife did occur in Harlem and Brooklyn in July 1964.
Meanwhile, in 1956, Wagner made another bid for the United States Senate, gaining his party’s nomination but losing the general election to his Republican opponent, Jacob K. Javits. Wagner easily won reelection as mayor in 1957, but four years later he lost the support of the regular Democratic “bosses” of the city’s five boroughs. However, he easily defeated their candidate in the party primary and went on to win the general election of 1961. Wagner’s victory has been credited with permanently breaking the power of “Tammany Hall”—the old municipal Democratic party machine.
Wagner’s first wife died on 2 March 1964. He married his second wife, Barbara Joan Cavanagh, on 26 July 1965. The couple, who had no children, separated in December 1969 and divorced in June 1971. Wagner, a Roman Catholic, secured a church annulment.
After declining to seek a fourth term as mayor, he entered a law partnership in 1966. From May 1968 to March 1969 he was the U.S. ambassador to Spain. After returning to the United States he announced his candidacy for mayor, but was defeated in the Democratic primary in June.
Wagner continued to practice law. On 30 January 1975 he was married for a third time to Phyllis Fraser Cerf, the widow of Bennett Cerf, the cofounder of the Random House book publishing company. They had no children. In March 1977 the New York State Senate confirmed him as a commissioner of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, and in June he became the agency’s vice chairman.
From 1978 to 1980 Wagner was President Jimmy Carter’s special envoy to the Vatican, with which the United States had only informal diplomatic ties. In that capacity he arranged a June 1980 meeting between President Carter and Pope John Paul II and helped plan the pope’s 1981 U.S. tour. In 1983 he was appointed to another term as commissioner of the Port Authority and continued as its vice chairman.
Wagner, who had been suffering from bladder cancer, died of heart failure at his home in Manhattan. He is buried in Calvary Cemetery in Queens, New York.
Wagner’s legacy to the cultural life of New York City was immense. Not only was he instrumental in preserving Carnegie Hall, the city’s premier venue for classical music, he played a major role in the creation of Lincoln Center, the home of the city’s foremost performing arts institutions, including the New York City Opera and the Metropolitan Opera. He also helped bring the 1964 World’s Fair to Flushing Meadows in Queens, New York.
In the political realm, Wagner deserves credit for taking a leading role in bringing about the final demise of the old Democratic political machine known as Tammany Hall. As Sam Roberts put it in the New York Times on 14 February 1991, Wagner’s victory in 1961 “redefined the mayoralty and established its preeminence over the party.”
Wagner’s personal papers are in the LaGuardia and Wagner Archives at LaGuardia Community College of the City University of New York, in Long Island City. His official mayoral papers are in the New York City Department of Records and Information Services, Municipal Archives. A brief biographical sketch covering his early career may be found in Current Biography 1954. The Administration of Robert F. Wagner (1960), published by the Office of the Mayor, City of New York, gives an official view of the accomplishments of the Wagner administration from 1954 to 1960. Chris McNickle, To Be Mayor of New York; Ethnic Politics in the City (1993), provides an extensive discussion of Wagner’s mayoralty. Obituaries are in the New York Times, the Daily News, and the New York Post (all 13 Feb. 1991).
Roman Rome
