Conflict Resolution in Early New England
Conflict Resolution in Early New England
Methods. Legal systems serve as formal ways to resolve conflicts in communities. But going to court is not the only way to resolve a conflict. Indeed, one reason that the colonial legal systems remained fairly simple in the 1600s was that they did not grow until the society was large enough and faced conflicts that required formal processes. Most disagreements between human beings are settled directly, but some conflicts prove harder to resolve, so all communities develop mechanisms of conflict resolution that extend beyond the individual. Colonial New England had three such venues: the town, the church, and the courts.
Well-Ordered Communities. Many of the early New England settlements were dominated by Puritans, who showed much concern for well-ordered communities. They often viewed their churches as bound by covenants with God, and they saw their communities this way as well. The maintenance of order was very important to them, not only to promote security but also because they believed it to be their religious duty. Yet they knew from experience that the good intentions of people do not necessarily promote order, and so they accepted governmental and legal systems as necessary for the survival of the community.
Towns. When colonists were given permission by the colony’s government to settle a new area, it was to create a town with farms around it. The town then became the focal point of local government, and through the local government and the annual town meetings that developed, the community could establish standards of behavior, control land development in the area, and resolve disputes that divided settlers.
Church. Townspeople often were church members, and the church actively addressed disputes among its
members and not infrequently took disciplinary action against members whose behavior was found unacceptable. The Bible, in which they passionately believed, taught them to resolve their differences with one another individually, and if that did not work, to take two or three other people along to assist. If that still did not produce satisfaction, the offended party was admonished to take the issue to the church.
Limits. But while the town and the church served as principal ways of regulating the community, by themselves they were not adequate. Town meetings might pass regulations to define the limits of acceptable behavior, but they did not meet frequently enough to enforce their decisions. The church could regulate disputes among its willing members, but its power was limited to those who would cooperate. As much as these people believed in their government and their churches, it took courts to fill the gap in conflict resolution.
Courts. The Puritans understood the need for a court system to settle disputes that could not be resolved through informal mechanisms. The complexity of land ownership and owners’ rights made the courts indispensable to maintaining order within a few years of settlement. There was too much room for misunderstanding, and the stakes were too high to rely on oral agreements in these matters.
Gradual Independence. Early on, the courts reflected the values of the church to a strong degree. But by the 1660s the courts began to diverge a bit. The church’s influence on the community was not as strong as it had been around the time of the founding of the early New England colonies in the 1630s. As a result the courts sometimes acted not in the interests of the church but instead to protect individuals from the church.
Source
David Thomas Konig, Law and Society in Puritan Massachusetts: Essex County, 1629-1692 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1979).
