Homelessness

views updated

Homelessness

In the late twentieth century, homelessness became a serious issue in the United States. Increased numbers of men and women were living in shelters or on the street. Many viewed homelessness as a condition caused by excessive drinking and drug abuse. Although this view has a long history in American life, the picture is in fact more complicated. Other factors besides alcohol and drug abuse have contributed to the problem of homelessness in modern society.

ALCOHOL, DRUG, AND MENTAL HEALTH (ADM) PROBLEMS AMONG HOMELESS CLIENTS IN 1996
Specific CombinationsPast Month (%)Past Year (%)Lifetime (%)
Alcohol Problem Only13129
Drug Problem Only776
Mental Health Problem Only171510
Alcohol/Drug Problems71015
Alcohol/Mental Health Problems101015
Drug/Mental Health Problems578
Alcohol/Drug/Mental Health Problems81430
No Alcohol, Drug, or Mental Health Problems342614
source: Interagency Council on the Homeless. "Homelessness: Programs and the People They Serve," U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 1999. <http://www.whitehousedrugpolicy.gov/publications/policy/ndcs01/table27.pdf>.

A Historical Background of Homelessness

The word "homeless" can be understood in two ways. In its most literal meaning, "houseless," the word has been used to describe people who sleep outdoors or who live in temporary housing. In earlier generations, a homeless person was often a hobo, and the local police station was the most likely place to find temporary housing. In the second meaning of the word, "homeless" describes someone who lacks a sense of belonging to a particular place and who has little or no connection to a community.

In the rural- and small-town society of the nineteenth century, family was strongly linked with place. Home was the basis for community and social order, and traditions of people helping each other and joining together to control troublesome behavior grew out of this sense of place. To be homeless was to be unattached, outside this web of support and control. It was also to be without the resources necessary for living. Many of the young men and women who moved from farm to city, or those who emigrated during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, were unattached in this respect. In fact, such groups as the YWCA, YMCA, and various ethnic organizations were established both to help and oversee these "homeless" people.

By the 1840s, it was common for Americans to link homelessness with a habit of drunkenness. In the popular view, drunkards, usually men, drank up their wages and impoverished their families; they lost their jobs and their houses, and drove off their wives and children by cruel treatment. They became outcasts and drifters, and their wives entered poorhouses while their children became inmates of orphanages. By the 1890s, the public held the same ideas about people who abused drugs such as opium, morphine, and cocaine and the unhappy circumstances of their families.

The Effect of Homelessness on the Economy

Homelessness in the United States has often been the result of conditions beyond the control of the individuals themselves. Studies of homelessness prior to the Great Depression noted that the numbers of homeless people went up and down depending on economic conditions. Severe problems with the United States economy in the late- nineteenth and early-twentieth century caused large numbers of people to lose their jobs and thus their financial security.

Scholars investigating the problem of homelessness before the depression also noted the importance of employers' decisions about hiring and firing. When the economy soured, workers without families to support and workers seen as the least productive were the first

[Image not available for copyright reasons]

to be fired. For example, employers assumed that single young women would be supported by their families and that married women did not really need a second income. Older men, single men known to drink heavily, and members of ethnic or racial minorities were more often marked for layoff. By contrast, in boom times employers relaxed their standards for hiring and job performance. All but the most seriously disabled, and the most unreliable heavy drinkers and drug users, could find some kind of work. As a result, when the economy was good, the numbers of the homeless shrank.

Working Conditions and Health Care

Pre-depression observers also emphasized the impact of other factors on homelessness, including working conditions, the health and strength of the worker, and the lack of government support for people who lost their income. Working conditions were often dangerous, and diseases such as tuberculosis affected large numbers of people. Many men became disabled by disease or workplace accidents, often at a young age. There was not much in the way of welfare to support people when they had lost their jobs. In addition, medical treatment at the time was often ineffective. As a result, these men rapidly sank into terrible poverty. They were forced to beg, find a meal at soup kitchens, and sleep in shelters or the cheapest lodgings infested with vermin. (These lodgings came to be called "flophouses.") Some of these men were heavy drinkers, and some were drug users. But these problems often grew out of the conditions of poverty and rootlessness.

Scholars of homelessness also realized that the urban areas where homeless people clustered, as well as the businesses—both legal and illegal—they were involved in, reinforced a homeless way of life. In these areas, called "hobohemias" before the depression and later "skid row," the poor and the homeless could find cheap restaurants, saloons, residential hotels and lodging houses, private and eventually public welfare agencies, and agencies that listed opportunities for "day" work. They could also find a flourishing drug trade in many corners of skid row.

By the 1940s, skid row was where poor single men disabled by age, injury, and/or chronic illness wound up. They survived on private charity, small allowances from public welfare, modest pensions, and a bit of income from odd jobs. It is important to note that these men were not homeless in the sense of having no place to live. However, they were homeless in the sense of remaining outside the bounds of society. Contrary to popular belief, only a minority—perhaps one-third—were heavy drinkers and drug users.

New Government Programs and Policies

The period from 1941 to 1973 was a time of prosperity in the United States. During the same period, the government increased welfare programs, such as Medicare, affordable housing, and benefits for the disabled. New programs to help heavy drinkers and drug users were created, and local governments began investing in projects to clean up urban areas and give new life to cities. Many observers believed that skid row would disappear.

One important result of these changes was to improve the economic circumstances of the elderly. Today, very few of the homeless are elderly. Other results were not as people had hoped. Some cities bulldozed their skid-row area. But the people driven out of skid row did not go on to find other, better housing or better lives. In fact, homelessness became a literal condition: the poor had no houses to live in.

In the early 1980s the media began to report on a new generation of younger homeless people. These people appeared to have high rates of mental illness, heavy drinking, and drug use. As a result, many observers explained the new homelessness as a result of policies that concerned mental hospitals and imprisonment for public drunkenness and minor drug offenses. During the 1960s and 1970s many states "deinstitutionalized" both mentally ill people and alcoholics and addicts. In other words, large numbers of state hospital patients were released. New laws made it much harder to commit a person involuntarily to a mental institution.

Many states also "decriminalized" public drunkenness. People who were drunk in public were sent to places where they could sober up rather than to jail. Similarly, many minor drug offenders were kept out of jails. Homelessness was described by many as a condition in which troubled and troublesome people found themselves. They were not only houseless, they were barred from institutions that had once sheltered them.

Current Situation

Some recent studies of homelessness continue to claim that perhaps 85 percent of homeless people are substance abusers and/or mentally ill. However, these studies have a serious flaw. Their estimates of substance abuse and mental illness rely on measurements of lifetime substance abuse, rather than measurements of current substance abuse. A measure of whether a person has ever had a severe mental illness or substance abuse disorder will always produce much higher rates than a measure of a current disorder (defined as occurring within the previous six months or one year of the study).

Probably a more accurate estimate, provided by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, is that about a third of the homeless people in the United States have serious mental illness, and more than half also have an alcohol and/or drug problem. The proportion is much higher among single men and much lower among adults who are homeless in family groups, most often single women with children.

Heavy drinking, drug use, and mental illness are certainly risk factors that make it more likely that some people will become homeless. Yet clearly most people with such problems never become homeless. To explain homelessness, then, other risk factors must be considered as well. These factors were first discussed a century ago, and still apply to the modern problem of homelessness. These factors include changes in the economy, the supply of available and affordable housing, the availability of support systems such as welfare and medical care, and whether a person has the support of his or her family.

An additional factor contributing to homelessness in the late- twentieth century was the size of the baby-boom generation. The risk for developing mental-health, alcohol, and drug problems is greatest between the ages of 18 and 25. The huge baby-boom generation reached this age at the same time as the supply of jobs, housing, and other material goods was becoming scarce.

Changes in the Economy. Changes in the economy have increased the number of highly skilled, well-paid technical jobs (such as those in the field of computers) and low-skilled, poorly paid service jobs (such as those in the fast-food industry). At the same time, these changes have reduced the number of semiskilled, well-paid jobs in the field of manufacturing. This shift from a manufacturing to a service economy is known as deindustrialization. Hardest hit by this shift are the younger members of the huge baby-boom generation (born between 1946 and 1964), especially Hispanics and African Americans. People in this group may lack the advantage of higher education or advanced technical training when they try to find work. They are not qualified for highly skilled work but cannot make a decent living in service jobs. People who work for low hourly wages are sometimes called the "working poor." Although many of these people work very hard, they remain poor and vulnerable to losing their housing.

Housing. Along with changes in the job market, the cost of rental housing rose sharply in the 1980s. The amounts of aid given by federal and state welfare programs and unemployment insurance did not rise enough to meet these costs. As a result, it became increasingly difficult for poor families to establish and maintain households.

The 1990s were a time of economic growth. However, this prosperity did not lessen the problem of homelessness. The general prosperity of the decade had little effect on the poorest members of society. In addition, economic expansion usually has the effect of increasing rents. The number of low-rent apartments decreased by 13 percent from 1996 to 1998. At the same time, the Department of Housing and Urban Development provided assistance to fewer households. The crisis in affordable housing became worse during the great boom.

People with serious mental illness are overrepresented among the homeless population. While only 4 percent of the U.S. population has serious mental illness, five to six times as many people who are homeless (20–25%) have serious mental illness, and many more have milder forms of mental health problems. The reasons for this over- representation are complex. Some mentally ill people are homeless because they were released from institutions or hospitals, or have not been hospitalized despite a need. Moreover, since they have trouble keeping a job, they are often poor or financially unstable, and they receive little or no health care. Thus, their symptoms are often active and untreated, making it very difficult for them to negotiate meeting basic needs for food, shelter, and safety. Up to half of the mentally ill homeless also have substance use problems, which can make it harder to obtain a stable living situation. Also, according to the National Resource Center on Homelessness and Mental Illness, people with serious mental illnesses have greater difficulty exiting homelessness than other people. They are homeless more often and for longer periods of time than other homeless subgroups. Many have been on the streets for years. Numerous government and private agencies have proposed plans to reduce and eventually prevent the problem of homelessness among the mentally ill, but progress will likely be slow.

Conclusion

Every night in the United States, about 750,000 people are homeless. In a year, between 2.5 million and 3.5 million people experience homelessness for some period of time (days to months). Among people who remain homeless for long periods, rates of heavy drinking and drug use are very high. It is not the case, however, that drinking and drugs directly cause homelessness. Drinking and drug use may cause health problems and troublesome behavior, such as criminal activity. These health and behavior problems contribute to job loss, loss of family support, or loss of housing. Problems in the economy worsen these circumstances. In addition, far fewer people who need care and treatment for mental-health and addiction problems can turn to institutions as a place to live during recovery. As a result of many factors other than drinking and drugs, the homeless became a visible problem on the streets of American cities.

see also Alcohol: History of Drinking; Alcohol- and Drug-Free Housing; Poverty and Drug Use; Risk Factors for Drug Abuse; Treatment: History of, in the United States.

More From encyclopedia.com