Memphis

views updated

MEMPHIS

Founded in 1819, the city of Memphis sits on the bluffs overlooking the Mississippi River. Its history is often associated with racial conflict and strife. Race riots after the Civil War marred its Reconstruction history, and in the 1890s Memphis journalist Ida B. Wells-Barnett publicized the horrors of lynchings in her town and across the South, focusing in particular on how African American men were terrorized in the name of protecting white women's sexual virtue. Throughout the twentieth century, Memphis saw the rise of, and resistance to, the African American civil rights movement. When one of the movement's most prominent leaders, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., came to Memphis to help negotiate an end to the long-standing sanitation workers' strike, he was assassinated at the downtown Lorraine Motel on 4 April 1968.

Although these episodes in Memphis's history are well documented, the city's LGBT past has also found its way into the historical record. One of the most widely known moments of Memphis's pre-Stonewall past is the sensationalized 1892 Alice Mitchell–Freda Ward murder case. The 26 January 1892 Memphis Appeal-Avalanche suggested that Mitchell slashed Ward's throat because "her erstwhile bosom friend … treated her coldly." The case was conducted as a lunacy inquisition rather than a criminal trial, and the testimony of expert medical witnesses, friends, family, and even Mitchell was published in the local newspaper. In the end, Mitchell was declared insane and committed to the Tennessee State Asylum, where she died in 1898. The way this case was sensationalized is an early example of the social construction of same-sex sexuality as deviant.

Around the same time as the Mitchell–Ward case, the Memphis Public Ledger published the story of Marie Hinkle, a professional male impersonator. When Hinkle's engagement at the Broome Variety Theater in Memphis ended, she made plans to travel to New York for another engagement. Two female admirers, Ione and Lizette, wanted to accompany Hinkle to her train and ended up in a fight for Hinkle's attention. In its coverage, the media focused on links between violence and cross-dressing, concepts sexologists routinely employed to make sense of same-sex sexuality at the turn of the twentieth century.

Since Memphis is bordered on the west by the Mississippi River and on the south by the state of Mississippi, urban development concentrated in the east. By World War II two main sites of popular gay life emerged in the downtown and midtown areas of the city. The earliest gay-straight mixed bars included the Rathskeller, the Rendezvous (a landmark barbeque restaurant), and such private bars as the Aristocrat and Raven, all of which were located in the downtown area. In the 1970s and 1980s gay bars opened their doors both downtown and midtown—an area east of downtown where Rhodes College and the University of Memphis are located. Public parks—Court Square and Confederate Park in downtown and Overton Park in midtown—also emerged as sites for cruising and sexual encounters. Building gay and lesbian communities was possible in these milieus—bars and parks—but creating a political community in a conservative atmosphere was considerably more difficult.

Despite public activism on the West Coast with the Mattachine Society and Daughters of Bilitis in the 1950s or on the East Coast with the Stonewall Riots in 1969, gay Memphians displayed little or no political activism during these eras. Prior to the mid-1970s, references to gay community in Memphis likely meant circles of friends, private socializing, and cruising in public parks. Eventually, more public gay institutions emerged. By 1975 Memphis boasted a gay newspaper, a Metropolitan Community Church, public social organizations such as The Queen's Men, and at least five gay bars. With the onset of the AIDS epidemic in the early 1980s, local gay men founded the Aid to End AIDS Committee (ATEAC). Memphis was also home to a thriving drag and female impersonator community.

Although many issues could bring the gay communities in Memphis together, race and gender seemed to keep them apart. As Buring notes in her 1997 study of gay and lesbian Memphis, gay institutions may have appeared to be racially integrated, but blacks maintained a considerable distance because they recognized that the more publicly identifiable gay community mirrored the larger, segregated society. They were a part of the larger black community, but homophobia kept them slightly apart, and as a result, they founded such organizations as the Memphis Committee and Black Gays and Lesbians Allied for Dignity (B-GLAD).

Lesbians in pre-Stonewall Memphis created social networks through local gay and mixed bars and the city's softball leagues, which enabled women to socialize and form relationships with other women, many of whom were also lesbians. Memphis lesbians during this time adopted femme/butch roles. With the rise of gay liberation occurring at the same time as the women's liberation movement, many lesbians in Memphis also joined local feminist organizations, particularly the Memphis chapter of the National Organization for Women (NOW). Through NOW, ongoing softball activities, the Memphis Gay Switchboard, and such community institutions as the Bread and Roses delicatessen and the Meristem feminist bookstore, local lesbians created their own communities, but they were never fully racially integrated and black lesbians never developed organizations or bars to cater exclusively to their needs.

Memphis lesbians and gay men boast a history of being socially "out" in the sense that there have been clearly gay spaces, but political activism does not have a strong history among members of the community. Buring suggests that "the force of social conservatism … keeps Southern lesbians and gay men from getting involved or 'rocking the boat'" (p. 226). However, gay men and lesbians did move from a marginal existence to an institutional presence in the mid-to late-twentieth century, changing the social, cultural, and political landscape of the city of Memphis.

Bibliography

Buring, Daneel. Lesbian and Gay Memphis: Building Communities behind the Magnolia Curtain. New York: Garland Press, 1997.

Duggan, Lisa. "The Trials of Alice Mitchell: Sensationalism, Sexology, and the Lesbian Subject in Turn-of-the-Century America." Signs 18, no. 4 (1993): 791–814.

Duggan, Lisa. Sapphic Slashers: Sex, Violence, and American Modernity. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 2000.

Gilmore, Stephanie. "The Dynamics of Second-Wave Feminism in Memphis, 1971–1982: Rethinking the Liberal/Radical Divide." NWSA Journal 15, no. 1 (2003): 94–117.

Lindquist, Lisa J. "Images of Alice: Gender, Deviancy, and a Love Murder in Memphis." Journal of the History of Sexuality 6, no. 1 (1995): 30–61.

Stephanie Gilmore

see alsohunter, alberta; mitchell, alice.

More From encyclopedia.com