Kerr–Siegel hypothesis
Kerr–Siegel hypothesis In an article on ‘The Interindustry Propensity to Strike—an International Comparison’ (in A. Kornhauser et al. , Industrial Conflict, 1954)
, Clark Kerr and Abraham Siegel offered an analysis of inter-industry differences in strike-proneness, and argued that high strike-rates among geographically or socially isolated, cohesive, homogeneous groups of workers (such as longshoremen, miners, and sailors) were a consequence of their alienation from the wider society and the unpleasant nature of their jobs. First, since the location of the worker in society determines his or her propensity to strike, and location is heavily dependent on industrial environment, then industries will be strike-prone where workers form a homogeneous group isolated from the general community. Moreover, by selection and conditioning, the nature of jobs determines the kind of workers employed: unpleasant, casual, unskilled work attracts (and fosters) tough, combative workers, who will be likely to strike. A combination of these two theories explains the differential strike-rates observed across industries.
The thesis generated an extensive secondary literature and considerable controversy. Critics argued, among other things, that the strike statistics that formed the basis of the argument were unreliable; that the analysis omitted certain key industries (such as steel) which contradicted the argument; and that the explanation of strike-proneness relied too much on a limited range of structural factors and ignored the attitudes of the different parties involved. See also INDUSTRIAL CONFLICT.
, Clark Kerr and Abraham Siegel offered an analysis of inter-industry differences in strike-proneness, and argued that high strike-rates among geographically or socially isolated, cohesive, homogeneous groups of workers (such as longshoremen, miners, and sailors) were a consequence of their alienation from the wider society and the unpleasant nature of their jobs. First, since the location of the worker in society determines his or her propensity to strike, and location is heavily dependent on industrial environment, then industries will be strike-prone where workers form a homogeneous group isolated from the general community. Moreover, by selection and conditioning, the nature of jobs determines the kind of workers employed: unpleasant, casual, unskilled work attracts (and fosters) tough, combative workers, who will be likely to strike. A combination of these two theories explains the differential strike-rates observed across industries.
The thesis generated an extensive secondary literature and considerable controversy. Critics argued, among other things, that the strike statistics that formed the basis of the argument were unreliable; that the analysis omitted certain key industries (such as steel) which contradicted the argument; and that the explanation of strike-proneness relied too much on a limited range of structural factors and ignored the attitudes of the different parties involved. See also INDUSTRIAL CONFLICT.
More From encyclopedia.com
Strikes , A strike is an organized stoppage of work. With the rise of factories during the Industrial Revolution , businesses acquired great power over the liv… Industrial Conflict , industrial conflict A term which refers to all expressions of dissatisfaction within the employment relationship, especially those pertaining to the… General Strike , general strike, sympathetic cessation of work by a majority of the workers in all industries of a locality or nation. Such a stoppage is economic if… Strike , strike / strīk/ • v. (past struck / strək/ ) 1. [tr.] hit forcibly and deliberately with one's hand or a weapon or other implement: he raised his han… Hunger Strikes , Hunger strikes as a means of protest have been traced to the pre-Christian era in Rome. They were revived in the early twentieth century in England b… Sit-down Strikes , Sit-Down Strikes
The National Labor Relations Act of 1935 buoyed the hopes of American workers. For the first time, the federal government officially…
You Might Also Like
NEARBY TERMS
Kerr–Siegel hypothesis