Jansenism
JANSENISM
A religious movement, named after Cornelius jan sen, bishop of Ypres (1585–1638) which began in Spanish Flanders and in France as a reaction to molinism. In their struggle to assert and defend their positions, its members exerted a deep influence over church, society, and politics until the end of the 18th century. The generic term suggests an ideological homogeneity that never existed. The movement developed and attempted to impose an extreme Augustinian conception of man's relationship with God; it attacked and was resisted by a more humanistic school fostered by the Society of Jesus, which continued the optimism of the Renaissance. The opposition between the two visions became a war between two parties, Jansenism and "anti-Jansenism," waged not only theologicallly, but also politically. In this dramatic process the features of a Jansenist mentality developed. Its characteristics and influence were constantly modeled and remodeled by its conflictual history.
History
Origins. Cornelius Jansen's augustinus (published 1640), reflected a desire by Louvain University professors to counter Molinist theology with a decisive exposition of the teaching of Saint augustine, the "Doctor of Grace," on matters that had not been resolved by the Church Magisterium. Though some of its positions could appear close to those of another Augustinian from Louvain, Michel de Bai (baius), who had been censured in 1567 by Pius V, it soon was acknowledged as the most representative work of positive theology on the matter of grace, and for that reason its publication signaled the beginning of anti-Jansenist offensive.
In France. Reprinted in Paris (1641) and Rouen (1643), the work was well received in French religious circles for its strict Augustinianism and its appeal to patristic authority alone. A friend of Jansen, Jean duver gier de hauranne, abbot of Saint-Cyran, was instrumental in influencing post-Tridentine renewal with his insistence upon the model of the early Church. Under his spiritual direction, the Abbey of port-royal, reformed by Angélique Arnauld, had become both a workshop and a showcase of this enterprise, attracting influential members of the nobility and the bourgeoisie; later a group of laymen, the solitaires, lived next to the
nuns. In his defense of the rights of bishops to control religious communities (Petrus Aurelius ) Saint-Cyran antagonized regulars; his attacks on moral laxism displeased members of the secular clergy as well, including Cardinal Richelieu. This religious opposition became political with the Parti dévot 's resistence to Richelieu's alliance with Protestant countries.
First condemnations. Augustinus was opposed in Louvain by members of the Society of Jesus, who had their students attack it in theological defenses, but both the book and Jesuit theses were condemned by the Holy Office (1641) for renewing controversies on grace (de auxiliis ), twice forbidden by popes. Dated 1642, but only published in 1643, the bull In Eminenti developed this condemnation, albeit in general terms. As this decision could be interpreted as a Roman rebuttal of Augustinian theology, the University of Louvain sent a deputation to inquire about its precise meaning; it was given reassurance to the contrary by the pope himself.
In France, where since 1638 Saint-Cyran had been imprisoned upon Richelieu's orders, Augustinus was attacked
by Isaac habert, the official theologian of the diocese, in three sermons preached at Notre Dame of Paris (1642–1643). He was acting on the Cardinal Richelieu's command. Antoine arnauld, a disciple of Saint-Cyran, replied in 1644 with a defense of Jansenius, a polemical work, as well as solid evidence of historical scholarship. He also expanded the controversy on more practical planes by attacking the Jesuits on their laxism concerning the reception of the Eucharist (Fréquente communion, 1642) and moral theology (Théologie morale des Jésuites, 1643). At that time the Port-Royal group was perceived to be supporters of the Fronde, the upheaveal against monarchical absolutism. To weaken them, Richelieu's successor, Cardinal Mazarin, supported by the queen regent, Ann of Austria, wanted a stronger papal condemnation. The occasion was seized when students of the Faculty of Theology of Paris defended as orthodox some of the very same theses that Jesuit students had earlier denounced as Calvinist. The Syndic, or moderator of the Faculty, requested a formal condemnation of these seven "propositions" (July 1649), but he was unsuccessful, as was an attempt to obtain a condemnation from the General Assembly of the French Clergy (1650). However, Habert, now bishop of Vabres, was as a member of this assembly able to collect 85 episcopal signatures to a letter asking for papal intervention on the first "Five propositions" of the Sorbonne. As this referral to the Holy See intended to involve the Church's highest authority in the dispute, both French Jansenists and Anti-Jansenists sent agents to defend their positions. The bull cum occasione (May 31, 1653, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1962] 2001–2007) condemned the five propositions, but it was not sufficient to put an end to the controversy for it did not explicitly denote their origin and only disapproved of Jansenius's work in general.
Conflicts. Against an anti-Jansenist claim that in censuring the five propositions the pope had condemned Jansenius's synthesis and even disapproved of Augustinian theology, A. Arnauld disputed the presence of the propositions in Augustinus : only the first one could be found verbatim and in a context that supported its orthodoxy. Following a classical theological distinction, he asserted his obedience to the droit (the Calvinist doctrine the pope intended to condemn) and his rejection of the fait (the presence in the book of the said propositions). In so doing he manifested a spirit of resistance and division that countered the Church's desire to settle the matter once and for all. The French bishops added to the papal condemnation an oath or formulary that linked explicitly the five propositions and Augustinus. This was Mazarin's way of obtaining Rome's goodwill and fighting those he considered to be the supporters of his enemy the frondeur Cardinal de Retz. Arnauld's appeal to public opinion in defending his interpretation of Cum Occasione caused the Faculty of Theology to censure (January 1656) and expel him with a significant number of fellow theologians. Another familiar of Port-Royal, Blaise pas cal, was more successful in his Provincial Letters (1656–1657), which vindicated Arnauld's position and attacked laxist morality.
The escalation of pronouncements that followed showed that in the mind of the new pope matters of ecclesiastical obedience were as primordial as questions of orthodoxy. In ad sanctam beati petri sedem (October 1656, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2010–2012, sometimes indicated as Ad Sacram ), Alexander VII intended to clarify the matter by specifying the presence of the propositions in the book and his predecessors's intention to condemn them "in the sense of Jansenius." He later followed the French bishops' oath requirement by prescribing his own formulary, in regiminis apostolici (February 1665, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2020).
Regiminis Apostolici added a level of complications to the already intricate question of Jansenism. In the pope's words, the Church had the ability to rule on a "fact," both the material presence of the propositions and their meaning as intended by the author. This claim bore on another intense debate taking place in France at the time, on the relationship between the spiritual and secular powers. In this instance, recourse to the Roman pontiff not only backed Ultramontanism in its assertion of the supremacy of the pope, it also demanded an acceptance of his infallibility that extended to "dogmatic facts," such as the presence of the propositions in Augustinus. The assertion at the Sorbonne of such theories (1663) started a wave of Gallicanism that had little to do with the writings of Jansenius. It emboldened a resistance to the formulary that was endorsed by several pro-Jansenist bishops and prompted a settlement of the vexing formulary issue, by the agreement of a clause of conscience that allowed "respectful silence," that is private dissent on the fact. This "Peace of the Church" was authorized by Clement IX (Jan. 14, 1669).
By that time the movement had acquired its distinctive features, above all its individualism. In their insistence on defending what they considered to be the objective truth, most of the French Augustinians separated themselves from their more moderate associates in the Catholic Renewal; they also incurred Roman suspicion for their disobedience and government resentment for their political maneuvering, which at times threatened the unity of the kingdom. In their fight against laxist morality, they received the support of secular clergy but the success of their appeal to public opinion (Pascal's Provincial Letters ) was a double-edged sword since it confirmed the existence of a "Jansenist party." In the same manner, this crusade, though moderately endorsed by Rome, was perceived there as dangerous because of its fierce opposition to religious orders and its occasional association with the secular power of the Parlements.
Truce. The "Peace of the Church" was a temporary but momentous respite. It allowed the Port-Royal circle to extend its influence through publishing, especially in biblical, patristic, liturgical, and historical studies; in a move to assert their orthodoxy, they also took an important part in the controversy with Protestants (Perpétuité de la foi, 1672). The campaign against laxism was carried on, receiving noticeable Roman support in 1679 (Condemnation of 65 propositions, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2101–2167) and in 1690 (Condemnation of "philosophical sin," H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2291); it expanded to Jesuit missionary methods, a prelude to the Chinese Rites controversy. The adversaries of the Jansenists were not idle in their efforts to counter and disparage them. Louis XIV was alerted to their spirit of independence by their lack of support in his conflict with Innocent XI (1675). By 1679, only the nuns were allowed to remain at Port-Royal. Arnauld chose to go into exile; in 1685 his disciple P. quesnel joined him in Brussels—a perilous choice, for in that city since 1678 a "secret congregation against Jansenism" had been busy preparing a new offensive. They secured Roman censure of an important number of rigorist propositions (1690, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2301–2332). They also initiated attacks against Quesnel's Réflexions morales sur le Nouveau Testament.
The Crisis of Unigenitus. Despite papal support for the "politics of silence," reiterated by Innocent XII in a brief to the Belgian bishops (1694), the conflict was bound to ignite. It was stirred up by the publication (1702) of a Cas of conscience, submitted to the Faculty of Theology of Paris. Forty doctors had approved a text that not only supported "respectful silence" on the "fact" but also exposed Jansenist positions on religious practice: Confession, Communion, Bible in the vernacular, restrained Marian devotion. The arrest of Quesnel in May of 1703 gave ample evidence of the activity, even in Rome, of a Jansenist network, a blatant breach of the "Peace of the Church." At Louis XIV's insistence, Clement XI promulgated an apostolic constitution, Vineam Domini (1705, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2390), which contented itself with renewing former condemnations without taking into account the transformation of the movement. In its publication in France, the bull was accompanied by an affirmation of episcopal authority to resolve dogmatic issues in conjunction with the pope, an action that signaled an alliance between Jansenist doctrine and Gallican ecclesiology. Another apostolic constitution, the bull unigenitus (1713, D.S. 2400–2502), also requested by the French king, aimed at a comprehensive condemnation of Jansenism. It censured with general qualifications 101 excerpts from Quesnel's Réflexions morales. A minority of French bishops, headed by Cardinal de noailles, objected to this approach and asked for a revision of the document before its official publication in the kingdom. Their resistance infuriated the old king, who practically forsook his Gallican principles in order to squelch it, but he died a few days before the national council that was to convict them (1715). Political necessity forced his nephew, the Regent Philip of Orléans, to secure support of these very opponents. Emboldened by this situation, some extremists decided to appeal to a future general council against Unigenitus (1717), whereas the more moderate worked unsuccessfully on a official interpretation that would make it acceptable. In reaction, a new papal bull, Pastoralis Officii (1718), forbade any "explanation" of Unigenitus and declared the appellants excluded from his communion.
Despite the limited areas of resistance and the low numbers of opponents, Unigenitus generated a crisis that was to have ripple effects over the evolution of the post-Tridentine Church. The ill-fated papal constitution became exemplary of a type of Catholicism that was rejected for both its authoritarianism and its doctrinal deficiencies. This rejection also took political tones, due to the involment of the secular power in the conflict.
The Politics of Jansenism. When the impossibility of a resolution became evident, the French ministry under Cardinal Fleury took drastic steps: exile, imprisonment of the major opponents, even the impeachment of Bishop Soanen by the Provincial Synod of Embrun (1727). In 1730 Unigenitus was registered as the law of the land. In 1749, the archbishop of Paris, Christophe de Beaumont, decided to deny the sacraments (and therefore Christian burial) to those who did not assent to the bull. These measures contributed to a weakening and dispersion of the Jansenists. An important group decided to yield, in order to maintain their original goal of Christian excellence. Between Jansenists and anti-Jansenists, they constituted an influential "Third Party." Many continued in their opposition: they appealed to public opinion and sought support from the lawyers of the Parlements. Inevitably, some became more extreme: the miracles of Saint-Médard cemetery and the Convulsionaries (1730–1760) manifested the spiritual confusion of many, whereas the biblical "figuratism" of Duguet and d'Ettemare expressed the complete disillusion of a few.
Theological and political resistance was not entirely unsuccessful. In 1748, Benedict XIV reaffirmed the "liberty of schools" between Molinism, thomism, and augustinianism. In 1754, after a serious conflict with the Parlements, Louis XV forbade any public controversy on Unigenitus, later obtaining papal support of that position (Ex omnibus christiani orbis regionibus 1756). The expulsion of the Jesuits from France (1761–64), and the suppression of the Society of Jesuits in 1773, were perceived as a victory of the Jansenists. It certainly manifested the influence of the movement, diffused through innumerable pamphlets, books, and the clandestine newsletter, the Nouvelles ecclésiastiques (1728–1803), to the major posts of "Catholic Enlightenment."
European Jansenism. Schism was not avoided in the Netherlands, where local tensions with Rome resulted in the election, and consecration by a French Jansenist, of the first bishop of the Old Catholic Church (1723). About the same time, in Mediterranean and Middle European countries, many of the Jansenist themes appeared in various expressions of the "Catholic Enlightenment" that developed under the protection of the States. Though opposed to the Philosophes, they favored a critical renewal of Christianity based on the early church model. As they found most of their inspiration in the writings of the Port-Royal circle, they revived the entire movement by developing an international network dedicated to this internal reform. The decrees of the Synod of pistoia (1786) are representative of this perspective, condemned by Pius VI in auctorem fidei (1794, H. Denzinger, Enchiridion symbolorum [Freiburg 1963] 2600–2700).
Jansenism and Revolution. Transfering to the State the principles they advocated in the church, members of the Jansenist party were influential in the opposition to absolutism that prepared the way for the French Revolution. They were also involved in the first stages of the revolution, but they disagreed on the issue of the civil constitution of the clergy. Very few actually adhered to the Constitutional church, but as its leaders, especially Bishop Henri Grégoire, came to see themselves as the heirs of Port-Royal; they manifested in the early 19th century what can be seen as the last coherent form of Jansenism.
Jansenist Mentality
As a movement, Jansenism defies a compact definition because of a conflict-filled history that spans two centuries of major change in European society. A "Jansenist mentality" that unites the different forms of Jansenism might more easily be described. It is a combination of three elements: theological, social, and political.
Theological. The theological specificity of Jansenism has its origin with a rigid Augustinian interpretation of the relation between nature and grace. The five propositions condemned by Innocent X mark the limits of its orthodoxy. As a part of the French Catholic renewal, it soon took a practical expression: to the "humanistic conception" of Molinism was opposed a high ideal of personal holiness. Based on Scripture, sacraments, and a strict morality, a more personal and truthful piety was to improve society at large. The pastoral efforts of bishops and clergy associated with the movement show abundantly the importance of biblical rediscovery, and of liturgical participation supporting an authentic spirituality.
This "archaic Jansenism" flourished in the "frontiers of Catholicism," possibly emulating Protestantism. Its development was thwarted by its sacramental and moral rigorism, but also by an association of "patristic fundamentalism" with a static ecclesiology, incapable of accepting the post-Tridentine structure of the Church. The difficulties it encountered created an irresolvable opposition with the Magisterium of the Church, accentuating a form of individualism inherent to any reform movement. Hence a notable drift towards Gallican Episcopalism, and later Richerist Presbyterianism.
Social. The participation of the nobility and lower classes in the movement was limited, but it appears that especially in times of crisis the Jansenist cause received the support of an "old-style middle class," the "bourgeoisie de Robe." This may have a practical explanation: they had the education and time to be engaged in theological reflection. This explanation has been combined with a sociological interpretation: some members of this bourgeoisie expressed in their involvement with Jansenism the difficulties they experienced as a class in exerting political influence. Some found motivations for a spiritual withdrawal, a complete "refusal of the world" (Jansénisme extramondain ); others for a total resistance, religious and political (Jansénisme intramondain ). This thesis has the merit of pointing to the social composition of the movement and its varying attitudes toward society. It does not offer a satisfactory interpretation of a centrist position more concerned with the religious reform of society, principally through education, social action, and political involvement. If Jansenist exaltation of the right of conscience represented values attractive to the bourgeois ideal in earlier times, Jansenist morality with its rejection of temporal achievement and its opposition to usury explains the disaffection of 18th-century bourgeoisie.
Political. The political ideal of Jansenius and of his disciples was that of a Catholic monarch supporting the interests of the Church. Their resolved attachment to this theory and criticism of the emerging modern State accounts for their alienation from public authorities, and the persecution they often had to endure. These difficulties stirred up a spirit of resistance that combined a "mentality of opposition" with a dynamic defense of their ideas. They looked for support in the higher circles of the State and the Church, established a network of influence, relentlessly attacked their adversaries, and constantly sought public support through pamphleteering. This activism enriched and nuanced their "political theology," which followed the religious evolution of the movement, but because of their theological perception of the monarchy, they never envisioned in the State the democratic polity they advocated in the Church. Jansenism's democratic influence on society is indirect and unintentional, the result of a resistance movement mentality and a participatory ecclesiology.
Jansenism cannot simply be reduced to a reactionary struggle over ideals of Church, State, and society. It was an authentic spiritual movement that exceedingly rationalized its experience and obstinately defended its conclusions. In doing so it limited the function and authority of the Church, a flaw that its enemies were keen to stress and use against it. Subsequent resistance amply supported the accusation, prompting condemnation of a notion of spiritual renewal and ecclesiastical reform that might have been condoned in a different context. Despite the diversity of the movement, one element kept it together: an elitist and intellectual conception of the relationship between God and man and a deep commitment to vindicate it. Paradoxically, it can therefore be said that by their conduct the Jansenists hindered the very process of renewal that they so tenaciously espoused.
Bibliography: e. appolis, Entre Jansénistes et Zelanti: Le Tiers Parti catholique au XVIII e siècle (Paris 1960). c. a. bolton, Church Reform in 18th-Century Italy (The Synod of Pistoia, 1786) (The Hague 1969). l. ceyssens, "Les cinq propositions de Jansenius à Rome," Jansenistica minora XI; l. ceyssens and j. a. g. tans, Autour de l'Unigenitus (Louvain 1987). p. chaunu, "Jansénisme et frontières de catholicité (XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles) Revue historique 227 (1962) 115–138. r. m. golden ed., Church and Society under the Bourbon Kings (Lawrence 1982). l. kolakowski, God Owes Us Nothing (Chicago 1995). e. kovacs, ed., Katholische Auflkläurung und Josephinismus (Vienna 1977). b. r. kreiser, Miracles, Convulsions and Ecclesiastical Politics in Early Eighteenth-Century Paris (Princeton, N.J. 1978): h. de lubac, Augustinianism and Modern Theology (London 1969). c. l. maire, "Port-Royal: The Jansenist Schism," in p. nora, ed., Realms of Memory: The Construction of the French Past, v. 1 (New York 1996) 301–351. b. neveu, L'erreur et son juge. b. plongeron, "Recherches sur l'Aufklärung catholique en Europe occidentale (1770–1830)," Revue d'histoire moderne et contemporaine 16 (1969) 555–605. j. l. quantin, Le Catholicisme classique et les Pères de l'Église (Paris 1999). m. rosa, ed., Cattolicesimo e lumi nel settecento italiano (Rome 1981). a. sedgwick, Jansenism in Seventeenth-Century France (Charlottesville 1977). j. saugnieux, Le Jansénisme espagnol du XVIII e siècle: Ses composantes et ses sources (Oviedo 1975). p. stella, Studi sul Giansenismo (Bari 1972). r. taveneaux, Jansénisme et politique (Paris 1965). d. van kley, The Jansenists and the Expulsion of the Jesuits from France, 1757–1765 (New Haven, Conn. 1975); The Religious Origins of the French Revolution (New Haven–London 1996). f. e. weaver, "The Neo-Gallican Liturgies Revisited," Studia liturgica 16 (1986–87) 54–72.
[j. m. gres-gayer]
