Overfishing
Overfishing
With the tremendous increase in the human population since the industrial revolution, there has been an ever increasing use and, often, exploitation of many of the world's natural resources . The demand for fish and shellfish has exemplified this misuse of natural resources. Paralleling the changes in agriculture, the fisheries industry has progressed from a small-scale, subsistence operation to a highly mechanized, ultra-efficient means of securing huge quantities of fish and shellfish to satisfy the burgeoning market demand. These industrialized commercial fisheries have allowed fishermen to easily work the far offshore waters, and more efficient refrigeration has allowed greater travel time, thus allowing for longer excursions.
Overfishing results in the removal of a substantial portion of a species' population so that there are too few individuals left to reproduce and bring the population back to the level it was the year before. Overfishing has a tremendous negative impact on nontarget species as well. More than half, and occasionally as much as 90%, of a catch may be discarded, and this can adversely affect the environment by altering predator-prey ratios and adding excess organic waste through the dumping of nearly 30 million tons of dead or dying fish and shellfish overboard annually. Overfishing has also negatively impacted diving seabird, sea turtle, and dolphin populations since these animals often get trapped and killed in fishing nets. It is estimated that 44,000 albatrosses are killed each year by Japanese tuna fishermen, and that, over the years, tuna purse seine nets in the Eastern Tropical Pacific have caused the death of millions of dolphins .
The offshore waters are not regulated as are the coastal waters of our continents, therefore several populations of commercially important species have been overfished. Often, fishermen simply try to catch as many fish as possible (as fast as possible), because they believe that any fish left in the water will be caught by someone else. The codfish industry of the Atlantic coast of Canada and the United States had been a productive fishery since the time of the early settlers, hundreds of years ago. But with the introduction, in 1954, of a new kind of highly industrialized fishing vessel, the factory trawler, conditions changed for the cod population. In 1968, exceeding the normal catch for the region by over 500,000 tons, 810,000 tons of cod were taken off Labrador and the Grand Banks off Newfoundland. In the decade to follow, the cod population declined to the point that the number of spawning codfish off Newfoundland in 1977 showed a 94% decrease from the number in 1962. Another species to show population decline due to overfishing is the American shad, often referred to as the poor man's salmon . Harvested by Native Americans and the early colonists, the shad fishery was supplying one of the most commercially valuable fish to the region surrounding the Chesapeake Bay during the 1800's. Overfishing, combined with an increase in pollution and the disruption of spawning runs by the damming of rivers, took a fishery with an annual harvest of nearly 18 million pounds at the turn of the century to less than 2 million pounds in the 1970s.
A tragic example of the effect of overfishing is seen at Georges Bank in the Atlantic Ocean. Georges Bank, discovered by the Italian explorer Giovanni da Verrazano in the early part of the 16th century, was named after St. George by English settlers in 1605. Home to over 100 species of fish, Georges Bank has been a historically significant site of plentiful fishing for centuries. It is an ovoid embankment that is about 75 miles (120 km) off of the coast of New England. It encompasses an area 149 miles (240 km) in length and 75 miles (120 km) in width, and is over 330 feet (100 meters) above the sea floor of the adjacent Gulf of Maine. A bank, or shoal, is a shallow portion of an ocean that is analogous to a plateau. Georges Bank is part of a large range of shoals that extends from Newfoundland to the edge of the North American continental shelf. Georges Bank itself is larger than the state of New Jersey, and is an extremely important breeding ground for cod, haddo! ck, herring, flounder, lobster, and scallops. Its unique conditions are formed by the mingling of two major Atlantic currents: the cold Labrador current and the warm Gulf stream. The mixing of nutrient-rich and well-oxygenated waters in combination with good light penetration due to shallow depth creates an ideal environment for plankton that is a vital food source for young fish.
Known for its abundant fish supply, Georges Bank was heavily fished for centuries. Early fisheries believed the supply to be inexhaustible. The first documented consequence of indiscriminate fishing was in 1850 when, after a concentrated season of overfishing, a dramatic decline in halibut numbers in Georges Bank threatened commerce. The near extinction of halibut in this area occurred when ocean fishing was still accomplished using relatively small sailboats and handlines with baited hooks. After World War II, colossal factory-sized fishing ships were created and new large-scale fishing techniques were employed in Georges Bank. Miles of gill nets and other efficient methods became standard tools for trolling the bank. Fisheries from the United States, the Soviet Union, Spain, Japan, and Germany collected huge bounties from Georges Bank for decades. Each modern ship could catch as much cod in a single hour as an average boat from the 1600s could collect in an enti! re season. The fishing industry boomed from the 1950s through the 1970s, until it became apparent that even the ocean had limits that could be surpassed.
In 1976, the United States passed the Magnuson Act which established American authority to ban international factory fishing in the Georges Bank area. The intention was to protect and preserve fish stocks for the United States and Canada. Rather than initiate conservation strategies for managing the fish populations of Georges Bank, western fisheries free from foreign competition in the area, advanced. The New England Council, created by the Magnuson Act to protect Georges Bank, was effectively controlled by fishing industry interests that did little to address growing concerns about dwindling supplies.
In 1994 the National Marine Fisheries Service estimated a 40% decline in cod stocks in the Georges Bank area that occurred over an alarmingly short four-year period. Survey after survey found that the once abundant bank had been stripped of every prime commercial fish species that once filled its waters. As a result, that same year, fishing was banned in a 9,600 square kilometer area of Georges Bank. As of 1999, scientists reported that some commercial species were beginning to show signs of a slow increase in numbers, but that cod continued a rapid decline. While the ban on heavy fishing continues, some strictly regulated fishing is permitted in certain areas of Georges Bank. Although the depletion of fish populations in Georges Bank are assumed by some to be temporary, scientists remain cautious about providing assurances of a return to former abundance since recovery from such massive overfishing is not well understood.
Because regions relatively close to land, such as Georges Bank, tend to be more regulated, fishermen have begun to move farther out into unregulated water. Lack of regulations, however, is not the only reason fishermen are going farther offshore. Many populations have been over-fished in coastal waters, but fish and shellfish populations have declined in these waters due to near-shore pollution as well. Decreased water quality has had an impact on the population numbers and also on the quality of the fish itself, therefore creating a demand for fish and shellfish from distant, presumably cleaner, waters. Being driven farther offshore to make their catches, commercial fishermen may often overfish a population to bring in more revenues to offset their huge debt incurred on their equipment, crew, and ever increasing fuel costs.
A particularly alarming new method of fishing that threatens ocean fauna is cyanide fishing. Cyanide fishing is an increasingly popular method of fishing that uses cyanide to temporarily stun fish in exotic areas, like coral reefs. Once stunned, the fish are easily collected, then sold either as aquarium pets or as live fish in restaurants. Live fish sell for much higher prices than frozen fish, and live fish selections in restaurants is a growing trend. One problem with cyanide fishing is that only about half of the fish captured survive for sale, making it a wasteful effort. A second problem is the nonselective poisoning of other wildlife found in the ecosystems. Coral itself is killed by the cyanide used to flush-out exotic species from hiding places for luxury fish markets in Asia. Cyanide fishing constitutes a new threat for overfishing. It is estimated that roughly 65 tons of cyanide are used each year in Philippine coral reefs alone. Cyanide used on one! area spreads and jeopardizes ocean life on a scale that is poorly understood.
Popular trends in cuisine, in addition to live exotic fish selections in restaurants, can effect fishing. During the 1980s, when a New Orleans chef popularized "blackened redfish" and the dish was in demand across the country, the Gulf of Mexico population of "redfish", actually the Red drum, was nearly decimated by overfishing. Because of its unpopularity as a food and game fish, the Red drum was not regulated as are the more important commercial fish and shellfish species of this region. Therefore, when orders for the fish started coming in from across the nation, commercial fishermen began catching them in record numbers. There were cases in which great numbers of dead redfish were washing up on the shores of the Gulf states because fishermen had caught too many to process on their vessels and dumped the excess overboard. In just a couple of years the Red drum population crashed in the Gulf of Mexico, prompting the fish and game officials in all of the Gulf states to halt commercial fishing for redfish. (A recovery program, however, is meeting with success.) This problem could have been avoided had the original dish been named "blackened fish" or had the nation's seafood markets and restaurants known that the flavor in "blackened redfish" is in the seasonings and not in the fish itself, thus relying on local fisheries and the redfish of the Gulf of Mexico.
One means of offsetting overfishing by commercial fishing fleets, and reducing fuel use as well, is aquaculture , the cultivation and harvesting of fish and shellfish under controlled conditions. With pressures on fish populations from overfishing, increased pollution problems, and a dying industry strapped with higher costs of fuel and equipment, "fish farming" may offer a true alternative to greatly reduced quantities and inferior quality seafood in the future.
See also Commercial fishing
[Eugene Beckham ]
RESOURCES
PERIODICALS
Bricklemyer, E., S. Iudicello, and H. Hartmann. "Discarded Catch in U.S. Commercial Marine Fisheries." Audubon Wildlife Report. San Diego: Academic Press, 1990–91.
Kunzig, Robert. 1995. Twilight of the Cod. Discover, April 1995,44–49, 52–57, 60.
Lawren, B. "Net Loss." National Wildlife 30 (1992): 46–53.
