Selective Draft Cases
Selective Draft Cases (1918).In World War I, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Selective Draft Act of 1917 and national conscription in general in the Selective Draft Law Cases (officially, Arver et al. v. United States, 245 U.S. 366).
In a unanimous decision written by Chief Justice Edward White, the Court rejected arguments that the draft was not authorized by the Constitution and violated the Thirteenth Amendment's prohibition against involuntary servitude. Citing Southern court rulings upholding conscription in the Civil War (the Northern judiciary had divided), White—a Confederate veteran and former Louisiana judge and senator—declared that the power to compel military service was inherent in any state for its defense. The Constitution permitted national conscription as “necessary and proper” to implement the specific congressional authority “to raise and maintain armies.” Although the judiciary modified some Selective Service procedures, particularly during the Vietnam War, the Supreme Court has never reexamined the constitutionality of national conscription.
[See also Conscientious Objection; Supreme Court, War, and the Military.]
In a unanimous decision written by Chief Justice Edward White, the Court rejected arguments that the draft was not authorized by the Constitution and violated the Thirteenth Amendment's prohibition against involuntary servitude. Citing Southern court rulings upholding conscription in the Civil War (the Northern judiciary had divided), White—a Confederate veteran and former Louisiana judge and senator—declared that the power to compel military service was inherent in any state for its defense. The Constitution permitted national conscription as “necessary and proper” to implement the specific congressional authority “to raise and maintain armies.” Although the judiciary modified some Selective Service procedures, particularly during the Vietnam War, the Supreme Court has never reexamined the constitutionality of national conscription.
[See also Conscientious Objection; Supreme Court, War, and the Military.]
Bibliography
Paul L. Murphy , The Constitution in Crisis Times, 1918–1969, 1972.
John Whiteclay Chambers II , To Raise an Army: The Draft Comes to Modern America, 1987.
John Whiteclay Chambers II
More From encyclopedia.com
Conscription , The power of the federal government to conscript may derive either from its power to raise armies or, more debatably, from its broadly interpreted po… United States Supreme Court , The U.S. Supreme Court is the nation's highest judicial body. It leads the judiciary, the branch of government responsible for resolving legal disput… John Marshall , Marshall, John
Marshall, John
Died July 6, 1835 (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)
Chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court
John Marshall grew up as a Virgi… Chisholm V. Georgia , Chisholm v. Georgia
An early U.S. Supreme Court case holding that Article III of the federal Constitution gives the Court original jurisdiction over… John Marshall Harlan (1833-1911) , John Marshall Harlan
The second Justice John Marshall Harlan (1899-1971) preached the virtues of judicial restraint and federalism as a persistent di… Thurgood Marshall , Thurgood Marshall 1908–1993
Supreme Court justice
Raised in Prosperous Home
Joined NAACP Staff
Helped End School Segregation
Named to Supreme Court
L…
You Might Also Like
NEARBY TERMS
Selective Draft Cases