Bertrand, Joseph Louis François

Bertrand, Joseph Louis François

(b. Paris, France, 11 March 1822; d. Paris, 5 April 1900)

mathematics.

Bertrand’s father was Alexandre Bertrand, a writer of popular scientific articles and books. Alexandre had attended the Éole Polytechnique in Paris with Auguste Comte and Jean Marie Constant Duhamel, and the latter married his sister. When his father died, young Bertrand went to live with the Duhamels. A well-known professor of mathematics at the École Polytechnique, Duhamel was the right man to guide his precocious nephew. At the age of eleven the boy was allowed to attend classes at the École Polytechnique. In 1838, at sixteen, Bertrand took the degrees of bachelor of arts and bachelor of science, and at seventeen he received the doctor of science degree with a thesis in thermomechanics. The same year (1839) he officially entered the École Polytechnique, and in 1841 he entered the École des Mines. Bertrand’s first publications date from this period, the first being “Note sur quelques points de la théorie de lélectricité” (1839), which deals with Poisson’s equation, ΔV = –4πρ and the law of Coulomb.

In 1841 Bertrand became a professor of elementarymathematics at the Co11ège Saint-Louis, a position that he filled until 1848. In May 1842 he and his brother, returning to Paris from a visit to their friends the Aclocques at Versailles, were nearly killed in a railroad accident which left a scar on Bertrand’s face. Bertrand married Mlle. Aclocque in 1844, in which year he also became répétiteur d’analyse at the École Polytechnique. Three years later he became examinateur d’admission at this school and suppléant of the physicist Jean-Baptiste Biot at the Collège de France. In 1848, during the revolution, Bertrand served as a captain in the national guard. He published much during these years—in mathematical physics, in mathematical analysis, and in differential geometry. The first of Bertrand’s many textbooks, the Traité d’arithmétique, appeared in Paris in 1849 and was followed by the Traité élémentaire d’aigèbre (1850); both were written for secondary schools. They were followed by textbooks for college instruction. Bertrand always knew how to fascinate his readers and his lecture audiences, and his books had a wide appeal because of content and style. In 1853 he editedand annotated the third edition of J. L. Lagrange’s Mécanique analytique. From the many publications in this period, one, “Mémoire sur le nombre de valeurs…” introduces the so-called problem of Bertrand: to find the subgroups of the symmetric groups of lowest possible index. Another publication, “Mémoire sur la théorie des courbes à double courbure” (1850), discusses curves with the property that a linear relation exists between first and second curvature; these are known as curves of Bertrand.

In 1852 Bertrand became professor of special mathematics at the Lycée Henry IV (then Lycée Napoléon). He also taught at the École Normale Supérieure. In 1856 he replaced Jacques Charles François Sturm as professor of analysis at the École Polytechnique, where he became the colleague of Duhamel. He then left secondary education to pursue his academic career. In 1862 he succeeded Biot at the Collège de France. Bertrand held his position at the École Polytechnique until 1895, that at the Collège de France until his death.

In 1856 Bertrand was elected to the Académie des Sciences, where in 1874 he succeeded the geologist Élie de Beaumont as secréraire perpétuel. In 1884 he replaced the chemist Jean-Baptiste Dumas in the Académie Française. These high academic positions, combined with his erudition, his eloquence, and his natural charm, gave him a position of national prominence in the cultural field.

During the Commune of 1871 Bertrand’s Paris house was burned, and many of his manuscripts were lost, among them those of the third volume of his textbook on calculus and his book on thermodynamics. He was able to rewrite and publish the latter as Thermodynamique. Afterward he lived at Sèvres and then at Viroflay. At his home Bertrand enjoyed being the center of a lively intellectual circle. Many of his pupils became well-known scientists—for instance, Gaston Darboux, who succeeded him as secrétaire perpétuel. In his Leçons sur la théorie générale des surfaces, Darboux elaborated many results of Bertrand and his mathematical circle.

Bertrand’s publications, apart from his textbooks, cover many fields of mathematics. Although his work lacks the fundamental character of that of the great mathematicians of his period, his often elegant studies on the theory of curves and surfaces, of differential equations and their application to analytical mechanics, of probability, and of the theory of errors were widely read. Many of his articles are devoted to subjects in theoretical physics, including capillarity, theory of sound, electricity, hydrodynamics, and even the flight of birds. In his Calcul des probabilités, written, like all his books, in an easy and pleasant style, there is a problem in continuous probabilities known as Bertrand’s paradox. It deals with the probability that a stick of length a > 2l, placed blindly on a circle of radius l, will be cut by the circle in a chord of less than a given length b < 2l. It turns out that this probability is undetermined unless specific assumptions are made about what constitute equally likely cases (i.e., what is meant by “placed blindly”).

From 1865 until his death Bertrand edited the Journal des savants. For this periodical, as for the Revue des deux mondes, he wrote articles of a popular nature, many dealing with the history of science. This interest in history of science appears also in the many éloges he wrote as secrétaire perpétuel of the Academy, among which are biographies of Poncelet, Élie de Beaumont, Lamé, Leverrier, Charles Dupin, Foucault, Poinsot, Chasles, Cauchy, and F. F. Tisserand. He also wrote papers on Viète, Fresnel, Lavoisier, and Comte, and books on d’Alembert and Pascal.

Bertrand spent the later part of his life in the midst of his large family, surrounded by his friends, who were many and distinguished. His son Marcel and his nephews Émile Picard and Paul Appell were his fellow members in the Académie des Sciences. In 1895 his pupils gave him a medal in commemoration of his fifty years of teaching at the École Polytechnique. The influence of Bertrand’s work, however, is hardly comparable to that of several of his contemporaries and pupils. Lest it be judged ephemeral, it must be viewed in the context of nineteenth-century Paris and of Bertrand’s brilliant academic career, his exalted social position, and the love and respect given him by his many pupils.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

I. Original Works. Bertrand’s works include “Note sur quelques points de la théorie de l’électricité:” in Journal de mathématiques pures et appliquées, 4 (1839), 495–500: “Mémoire sur le nombre de valeurs que peut prendre une fonction quand on y permute les lettres qu’elle renferme,” in Journal de l’École polytechique, 30 (1845), 123–140; Traité d’arithmétique (Paris, 1849); “Mémoire sur la théorie des courbes à double courbure.” in Journal de mathématiques pures et applitquées, 15 (1850), 332–350; Traité élémentaire d’algèbre (Paris, 1850); Traité de calcul différentiel et de calcul intégral, 2 vols. (Paris, 1864–1870); Les fondaleurs de l’astronomie moderne (Paris, 1867); Rapport sur les progrès les plus récents de l’anlyse mathématique (Paris, 1867); L’Acaddémie des science et les académiciens de 1666.à 1793 (Paris, 1869); “Considérations relatives á la theéorie du vol des oiseaux,” in Comptes rendus de l’Académie des sciences, 72 (1871), 588–591; Thermodynamique (Paris, 1887); Calcul des prababiliés (Paris, 1889); 2nd ed., 1897); D’Alembert (Paris, 1889); Éloges académiques (Paris, 1889); Leçons sur la théorie mathématique de l’electricité (Paris, 1890); Pascal (Paris, 1891); Éloges aeadémiques, nouvelle série (Paris, 1902), which has a complete bibliography of Bertrand’s works on pp. 387–399.

II. Secondary Literature. Gaston Darboux., “Éloge historique de J. L. F. Bertrand;” in Bertrand’s Éloges académiques, nouvelle série, pp. 8–51, and in Darboux’s Éloges académiques et discours (Paris, 1912), pp. 1–60. Another source of information is Comptes rendus de l’Académie, 130 (1900), 961–978, addresses delivered in the Academy to honor Bertrand and used by G. H. Bryan for his article “Joseph Bertrand,” in Nature, 61 (1899–1900), 614–616. The Library of the Institut de France nos. 2029–2047 comprises correspondence and some papers of Bertrand; 2719 (5) contains “Notes autobiographiques” (information from Henry Nathan)—these are probably the notes used by Darboux in his Éloge. Discussion of Bertrand’s problem may be found in H. Weber, Lehrbuch der Algebra. II (Brunswick, 1899), 154–160. The curves of Bertrand are dealt with in books on differential geometry, e.g., G. Darboux, Leçons sur la théorie générale des surfaces, 1 (Paris, 1887), 13–17, 44–46, and III (Paris, 1894), 313–314.

D. J. Struik