Home > Social Sciences and the Law > Law > Court Cases

Topic:ex parte Merryman

Visit our new topic page about ex parte Merryman

ex parte Merryman

The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition | Date: 2008

ex parte Merryman case decided in 1861 by Chief Justice Roger B. Taney sitting as a federal circuit judge in Baltimore, Md. John Merryman, a citizen of Maryland, was imprisoned by the U.S. army on suspicion of favoring the Confederacy. He obtained a writ of habeas corpus . The commanding general refused to respect this action, alleging that President Lincoln had authorized him to suspend the writ. Taney held that Article 1, Section 9, of the U.S. Constitution gave to Congress alone the power to suspend the writ in case of rebellion or invasion and that consequently the President's action had been without warrant and represented a threat to the liberties of all Americans. Lincoln, however, continued to adhere to the same practice throughout the Civil War. Congress ratified the suspension in 1863.

Bibliography: See H. S. Commager, ed., Documents of American History (8th ed. 1968).



Author not available, MERRYMAN, EX PARTE., The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2008



The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. Copyright 2008 Columbia University Press

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

Is suspension a political question?
Stanford Law Review; 11/1/2006; Tyler, Amanda L.; 43651 words ; ... in Chief Justice Taney's opinion in Ex parte Merryman, in which he opined that the suspension ... decide. (119) Some years later, in Ex parte Merryman, (120) Chief Justice Taney renewed ... note 12, [section] 1336. (17.) See Ex parte Merryman, 17 F. Cas. 144, 152 ... Read more
The discourse of law in time of war: politics and professionalism during the Civil War and Reconstruction.
William and Mary Law Review; 4/1/2005; Spaulding, Norman W.; 47897 words ; ... the suspension of habeas corpus in Ex parte Merryman, (175) and during Reconstruction in Ex parte Milligan and the Test Oath Cases ... starting point in this debate was Ex parte Merryman. (181) When South Carolina fire-eaters ... 471, 498 (1861) (arguing that if ... Read more
Rule of Law or Rule By Law: The Detention of Yaser Hamdi
American Journal of Criminal Law; 4/1/2003; Lugosi, Charles I; 17789 words ; ... Taney expressly rejected in Ex Parte Merryman the proposition that the President ... and an individual named John Merryman, were suspected of dynamiting ... break into the residence of John Merryman as he and his family slept.157 Merryman was arrested without warrant ... military custody ... Read more
(book review) (book review)
Constitutional Commentary; 12/22/1999; Garvin, Margaret A.; 8788 words ; ... Taney wrote his famous opinion in Ex parte Merryman.(10) (p. 34) Taney's opinion is a ... While this has only occurred once, in Ex parte Merryman, the potential for executive rejection ... following the Merryman decision. (11.) Ex Parte Merryman, 17 F. at ... Read more
Incorporating the suspension clause: is there a constitutional right to federal habeas corpus for state prisoners?
Michigan Law Review; 2/1/1994; Steiker, Jordan; 30101 words ; ... 9, cl. 3 ( No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed ... Fort McHenry refused to produce John Merryman, who was accused of assisting in the ... lacked power to authorize suspension. Ex parte Merryman, 17 F. Cas. 144 (C.C.D. Md. 1861 ... Marshall on the basis of his opinion in ... Read more
Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln and civil liberties: the balance of liberty and security.(Scholarship)
White House Studies; 6/22/2005; Williams, Frank J.; 10026 words ; ... and produced the now famous opinion, Ex Parte Merryman. (29) Notwithstanding the fact that ... anti-war demonstrator was treated as Merryman was in 1861. Nevertheless, five years ... conclusion as Taney in a case called Ex Parte Milligan; The Constitution of the ... Sanford, 19 How., p ... . Read more
Are congressionally authorized wars perverse?
Stanford Law Review; 2/1/2007; Nzelibe, Jide; 23155 words ; ... opinion polls are likely to fluctuate with news of battlefront victories and setbacks ... available at http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/03/20030317-7.html). (69 ... of war events, see MATTHEW A. BAUM, SOFT NEWS GOES TO WAR: PUBLIC OPINION AND AMERICAN ... Read more
High court focuses on Lincoln's powers in war.(TRAVEL)(THE CIVIL WAR)
The Washington Times; 10/21/2006; 1491 words ; ... in the case, which became known as Ex parte Merryman, held that the Lincoln administration ... chief justice. Lincoln reacted to Ex parte Merryman by ignoring it. Ironically, Lincoln ... it's comforting to know that both Ex parte Merryman and Ex parte ... Read more
Judges', lawyers' play to illustrate habeas corpus issues during Civil War
The Daily Record (Baltimore); 10/29/2004; Ann Parks; 1061 words ; ... dignified manner than her character - Merryman's jailer - might have done. I want ... person on the back, observes Nachman/Merryman. John W. Hardwicke, executive director ... Historical Society, of a staged reading of Merryman, a one-act play. Written by former ... s the thing The play opens as John ... Read more
Judicial review of the war power.
Presidential Studies Quarterly; 9/1/2005; Fisher, Louis; 15310 words ; ... the outset of the Civil War. John Merryman had been arrested and imprisoned ... pass the gate of the fort where Merryman was detained, even though Taney ... Chief Justice Taney's decision in Ex parte Merryman was sufficient to show that the ... Ibid., 1230. (10.) Ibid. (11.) Ex ... Read more

Related entries from encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauruses

Lincoln, Abraham
Presidents: A Reference History ... the difference, is no democracy. Free labor has the inspiration of hope ... finally to hire men to work for him! Free men had to oppose slavery because ... forever — half slave, and half free?' The problem is too mighty for ... Republicans' Lincoln took every free state except New Jersey, where ... Read more
1850-1877: Law and Justice: Chronology
American Eras ... that blacks — whether free or slave — are not ... Court of Appeals upholds the free status of blacks brought ... writ of habeas corpus in Ex Parte Merryman. President Lincoln refuses ... Orphan Asylum. 3 Apr . In Ex parte Milligan the U.S. Supreme ... announces its ... Read more
Warfare and the Rule of Law
American Eras ... and sharpened American ideas about free speech and the judicial process ever ... Philadelphia and Washington. John Merryman, one of the Maryland secessionists ... Taney, who granted the petition in Ex Parte Merryman. Although Congress was not in session ... had become a tool for suppressing ... Read more
Abraham Lincoln
The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition ... who could win both the abolitionists and the conservative free-staters, and at the Republican national convention of 1856 ... to it, ignoring a circuit court ruling against him in the Merryman Case (see Merryman, ex parte ). In the course of the war, Lincoln further extended his ... Read more
United States Supreme Court
The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition ... by the President and denounced by the Northern press (see Merryman, ex parte ). From the Civil War to 1937 The end of the Civil War to ... Brandeis, began to expand the constitutional protections to free speech. The Roosevelt Years A third great period of constitutional ... Congress was thus given a ... Read more

Related research topics

Online videos

Ex Parte Milligan