Gallicanism

Home > Philosophy and Religion > Christianity > Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches: Branches, Schisms, and Heresies

Gallicanism , in French Roman Catholicism, tradition of resistance to papal authority. It was in opposition to ultramontanism , the view that accorded the papacy complete authority over the universal church. Two aspects of Gallicanism are sometimes distinguished: royal Gallicanism, which defended the special rights of the French monarch in the French church; and ecclesiastical Gallicanism, which tried to preserve for the French clergy a certain administrative independence from Rome. Gallicanism in both senses received its theoretical formulation during the crisis of the Great Schism through the conciliar theory, which asserted the supremacy of general councils over the pope. The Council of Basel (see Basel, Council of ) further extended the conciliar ideas and in 1438 the French king, Charles VII, legalized these antipapal measures in the Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges (see under pragmatic sanction ). For additional chapters in the long struggle between monarch and pope for control of the French church see investiture ; church and state ; Philip IV ; Boniface VIII ; concordat . The quarrel between Louis XIV and Innocent XI occasioned the famous "Four Gallican Articles," drawn up for Louis by the French bishops (see also Innocent XII ). These declare that kings are not subject to the pope, that general councils supersede the pope's authority, that the pope must respect the customs of the local church, and that papal decrees do not bind unless accepted by the entire church. Gallicanism was much encouraged by Jansenism and remained fashionable at court. It was furthered by the followers of the Swiss theologian Thomas Erastus . No French king, however, sought to separate the French church from Rome, as did Henry VIII with the church in England; nor did any French king, despite the development of Gallican theory, ever manage to gain a hold over the church comparable to that exercised by the Spanish kings. The French clergy generally supported Gallicanism and during the French Revolution had little difficulty assenting to the Civil Constitution of the Clergy. The First Vatican Council in 1870 established the authority of the pope as a matter of dogma, and Gallicanism continued to live on only in the heretical Old Catholics .

Bibliography: See W. H. Jervis, The Gallican Church and the Revolution (1882).

Gallicanism. The collective name for the body of doctrine which asserted the more or less complete freedom of the RC Church, especially in France, from the ecclesiastical authority of the Papacy. In the 14th and 15th cents. the main question at issue was the claim of the French Church to a privileged position in relation to the Papacy. In the Concordat of Bologna (1516) the Pope conceded the right of the French king to nominate to bishoprics and other high ecclesiastical offices. In 1663 the Sorbonne published a declaration, in substance reaffirmed by an Assembly of the French clergy in 1682 in the formula known as the Four Gallican Articles (q.v.). Gallican principles were preached in the 18th cent. by the Jansenists, and were codified and proclaimed at the Synod of Pistoia (1786). In the 19th cent. there was a renascence of Ultramontanism in France, and the definition of Papal infallibility at the First Vatican Council (1869–70) made Gallicanism incompatible with Roman Catholicism.

Gallicanism. The assertion of more or less complete freedom in the Roman Catholic Church from the authority of the papacy. This was affirmed particularly for the Church in France (the old Gaul, hence the name). The opposite is Ultramontanism. The definition of papal infallibity at the first Vatican Council made any further expression of Gallicanism impossible.