Bill Clinton
1946-
Pesident of the united states (1993-2000)
Lost Opportunities
Historians, political scientists, and psychologists will write at length about Bill Clinton and his presidency. First elected in 1992 with only 43 percent of the popular vote, and reelected in 1996, Clinton dominated the U.S. political landscape for most of the 1990s. He was the first president to be born after the end of World War II (1945) and he symbolized the rise to political maturity of the baby boomers. He began his presidency with the intention of resolving several high-profile, but seemingly intractable, political issues including national health insurance, balancing the budget, civil rights, and education. Like all presidents, Clinton soon learned that progress on any of these issues required spending political capital, and that significant progress on all of them was impossible. As the first president elected after the end of the Cold War, he enjoyed the benefits of an end to the hair-trigger military standoff with the U.S.S.R., but along with that came a host of new and unanticipated foreign-policy problems unleashed by the untidy demise of the Soviet Empire. Finally, his presidency has been forever tainted by his own personal behavior, including dishonesty about his draft status during the Vietnam War (ended 1975), whether he smoked marijuana as a young man, extramarital affairs, and the lies and half-truths that led to his impeachment. Although he was not convicted by the Senate, the sordid affair cast a moral and political pall over nearly all of his second term. His presidency was not without successes—for example, the balanced budget, peace negotiations and agreements in the Middle East, and the improved situation in Northern Ireland—yet, so much more could have been accomplished.
Southern Roots
William Jefferson Blythe IV was born in Hope, Arkansas, on 19 August 1946. Three months before his birth his father, Bill Blythe, was killed in an automobile accident. In 1947 his mother left the boy in the care of his maternal grandparents while she went to New Orleans and nursing school. For most of the next two years he was raised by his grandparents with only occasional visits with his mother. His mother married Roger Clinton when he was four years old. He took the Clinton name when he was in high school. When he was seven the family moved to Hot Springs, Arkansas, though he frequently stayed in Hope with his grandparents. A younger brother, Roger, was born when Bill was ten. Clinton was a fine student and a musician with enough skill and talent with the saxophone to earn music, as well as academic,
scholarships. When he was a senior in high school he was an Arkansas delegate to Boys Nation held in Washington, D.C., where he met President John E Kennedy. By all accounts this was a defining moment for young Clinton and may have been instrumental in his eventual decision to pursue a career in politics. He attended Georgetown University with the help of scholarships and student loans and graduated with a Bachelor of Science in International Affairs in 1968. Georgetown was an ideal place for a young man interested in politics. Its Washington, D.C., location allows students to be close to national politics. While a student there Clinton interned in the Senate office of one of his home-state senators, James William Fulbright (D). After graduation, Clinton was awarded a Rhodes Scholarship to study at Oxford University in England. After two years abroad, Clinton returned to the United States and began legal studies at Yale University. While there, he met Hillary Rodham, also a promising law student. He graduated with his law degree in 1973. He briefly taught law, as did Rodham, at the University of Arkansas. They were married in 1975 and became parents of a daughter, Chelsea, in 1980. His first run for public office was an unsuccessful try at the Arkansas Third District congressional seat in 1974. Two years later he was elected Attorney General and in 1978 he was elected governor when he was only thirty-two years old. He was defeated in his 1980 reelection bid but came back and won the governorship again in 1982, and he held it from that point until his 1992 run for the presidency.
Running for President
Clinton was a long shot to get the Democratic nomination in 1992 to run against President Bush. He did not have a high public profile nationally, and Arkansas is not usually thought of as a strong base for a presidential run. Clinton benefitted as several nationally prominent Democrats decided not to seek the nomination in part because they were intimidated by Bush's incredibly high approval ratings in public opinion polls. Unlike other potential Democratic candidates, Clinton was willing to take the chance. He believed that Bush was unlikely to be able to sustain the unprecedented poll numbers and that he was vulnerable on other issues—most notably, the economy. In the 1980s Clinton had positioned himself to be a new Democrat who could put together an electoral coalition to win the presidency. He believed that though the old Democratic coalition of labor, liberals, and blacks had been successful from the 1930 through the 1960s, now it had become increasingly prone to fracturing on important issues. Clinton believed that new issues, raised and discussed by the Democratic Leadership Council that included Clinton, and the associated think tank, the Progressive Policy Institute, were the framework for forming a new coalition. The broad outlines of this line of thinking included a continuing reliance on activist government and social issues such as civil rights, but with a simultaneous embrace of free enterprise on the domestic front and a commitment to a global free market trading system. There would be less welfare, to be replaced with a greater reliance on "workfare" and job-training programs. Unlike the old Democratic coalition, the new coalition would place an emphasis on reducing crime, and additional money would be committed to building prisons and putting more police on the streets. In addition, Clinton supported the use of the death penalty. All of these positions were a stark deviation from traditional Democratic paternalism, and his ability to position himself in the middle of the political spectrum was instrumental in securing the nomination and winning the general election campaign against Bush and H. Ross Perot. Perot's strong run as a third-party candidate in 1992 probably helped Clinton as well. Throughout the campaign, Bush and Perot engaged in a partly private, partly public feud that increased whatever negative impressions the public may have already had about them. Clinton focused on the economy, blaming President Bush for every negative economic reality. His campaign office posted a sign reminding the candidate and campaign workers that "It's the economy, stupid!" In November, Clinton barely won a plurality of the popular vote although he won a substantial victory in the Electoral College.
First Term
President Clinton got off to a difficult start. He had made promises to end discrimination against gays and lesbians in the U.S. military, and the homosexual community presumed that he would remove all restrictions on their military service. Clinton ran into a buzz saw of opposition to removing those restrictions, however, so he settled on a compromise position, ordering that the military not ask about sexual orientation. Gays and lesbians would be permitted to serve in uniform only if they did not tell others of their orientation. This satisfied neither the homosexual community nor those intent on maintaining traditional bans on their military service and earned Clinton the enmity of both sides. By the end of the decade, it had become clear that the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" policy was a failure. President Clinton also appointed First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton to head a task force charged with designing a new health-care insurance system for the United States. Providing adequate and affordable health care was one of the core promises Clinton had made in the 1992 campaign. It was a promise he could not keep as the insurance industry turned up the pressure on Congress and engaged in a public-relations blitz that crippled the effort before the proposals ever emerged from the commission. Clinton spent an enormous amount of political capital in this doomed effort. The suicide of Vincent W. Foster Jr., his deputy counsel at the White House and former law partner of Hillary Rodham Clinton, just six months after the new administration took office was to have long-term consequences. Not only was this tragic death of a friend a personal blow, but Foster's suicide became the focus of conspiracy theorists hoping to smear the president. Foster was Clinton's counsel handling charges that the Clintons had been involved in suspect land deals in Arkansas. This next round of investigations led to a web of further inquiries that turned up some shady dealings by a variety of people in and out of the administration, damaged the reputations of
others not involved, and ultimately led to the president's impeachment in 1998 and trial in 1999. The biggest blow of all was the resounding Republican success in the 1994 midterm elections. Many political observers believed the congressional elections that year would be a referendum on Clinton and his policies, and the Democratic defeat was widely viewed as Clinton's defeat. There were successes as well, of course. Certainly the agreement in 1993 between Israel and Palestine to begin to carve out a Palestinian presence in occupied territories was a major victory, as was his success in getting Congress to approve the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) that same year. The economy was getting stronger, some categories of crime were in decline, welfare reform had been tackled in tandem with the Republican Congress, the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act imposing a waiting period on handgun purchases was passed, his national-service program (AmeriCorps) was created, and it was increasingly clear that the budget could be balanced after three decades of deficits.
The 1996 Election
In the months after the disastrous 1994 elections, it seemed unlikely that Clinton could sufficiently recover the political momentum necessary to secure a second term. Yet, he was once again the "Comeback Kid." He learned from his 1980 gubernatorial reelection defeat and his comeback victory two years later; from the Gennifer Flowers extramarital affairs charges that almost destroyed his candidacy before he got the nomination in 1992; and from the Republican success in capturing control of Congress in 1994. His opponents in 1996 were Robert Joseph "Bob" Dole (R-Kansas) and H. Ross Perot (Reform Party). Clinton successfully mobilized his constituencies around the New Democratic agenda; he was able to take credit for a strong economy, welfare reform, and reduced crime. He won the election by a wider margin than in 1992, but it was still only a plurality of the votes cast. He received 49 percent of the popular vote, while Dole garnered 41 percent and Perot trailed with 8 percent.
Second Term
The soaring economy provided the opportunity for Clinton and the congressional Republicans to reach an agreement on the historic balanced budget in 1997. This was so successful that by 1999 the major domestic political issue was how to use the ever-increasing budget surplus. In 1998 former Maine Senator George John Mitchell successfully led negotiations to end the violence between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland and, while further negotiations continued at the end of the decade, this agreement and its successors constituted a major foreign-policy success for the administration. Yet, from the beginning of the second term ethical questions took center stage. First, there were allegations of illegal fundraising by the president's campaign, and by Vice President Al Gore personally. Then the investigations led by Special Prosecutor Kenneth W. Starr branched out from the original Whitewater investigation to look into Vincent W. Foster Jr.'s suicide, Paula Corbin Jones's allegations of sexual misconduct on the part of Clinton when he was Arkansas governor, and new charges of improper conduct with a young intern, Monica S. Lewinsky. As 1998 wore on these matters increasingly consumed the press coverage of the president to the near exclusion of most matters of public policy. In August, Starr presented a report to Congress alleging that Clinton had perjured himself in the Jones and Lewinsky matters. On 19 December 1998 the House of Representatives voted, largely along party lines, to approve two of the possible four articles of impeachment, making Clinton only the second president in American history to be impeached (Andrew Johnson, in 1868, was the other). The dramatic Senate trial was held in January and February of 1999. Two-thirds of the senators had to vote "guilty" in order to remove the president from office. Like his sole impeached predecessor, Clinton survived that critical vote. On the first article, alleging grand jury perjury, the Senate failed to remove him from office by a vote of fifty-five to forty-five margin, with ten Republicans joining the Democrats; on the second article, alleging obstruction of justice, the Senate split fifty-fifty, as five Republicans broke ranks with their colleagues. Throughout the entire process opinion polls repeatedly indicated that while the public had some serious reservations about Clinton's character, they viewed the impeachment as a partisan political ploy and emphatically did not want Clinton removed from office.
Foreign Affairs
Of course, events around the world did not stop just for the impeachment battle. In the spring of 1999 issues of national self-determination in the Balkans again surfaced, this time in the Yugoslav province of Kosovo whose large Albanian population lived uneasily with a powerful Serb minority. In February and March increasing violence against the Albanians by Serbs supported by the Yugoslav army put the Balkans once again at the front of the foreign-affairs agenda. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), comprising the United States and its European allies, decided in March to initiate a bombing campaign to drive the Serbs out of Kosovo. In the process, most of the Albanian Kosovar population became refugees and NATO relentlessly bombed Serbian assets, particularly the military, governmental, and economic infrastructure in the Serbian portions of Yugoslavia. In June an agreement was reached with the Serb political leadership that ended the bombing in exchange for Serb withdrawal from Kosovo, return of the Albanian refugees, and a multinational peacekeeping force in Kosovo led by NATO. While some peace was restored to the region, at the end of the decade it remained uncertain as to what the future would hold for Kosovo and its people.
Impact on American Politics
Clinton will be remembered as the president who was impeached and who, through the entire unsavory episode, was forced to publicly admit to embarrassing indiscretions, lies, and partial truths. Yet, in many ways his two terms in office were
successful. The economy boomed, the budget was balanced, welfare reform was initiated, crime was reduced, several historic agreements were reached in foreign affairs, including movement toward peace both in the Middle East and Northern Ireland, major free-trade pacts were negotiated and implemented, and a national service program was instituted. Furthermore, he was instrumental in creating a new Democratic Party coalition that could effectively compete with Republicans on the national stage. Journalist Elizabeth Drew, quoting a friend of Clinton, said, "Bill has always been someone who has lived on the edge, politically and personally."
Sources:
Elizabeth Drew, On the Edge: The Clinton Presidency (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1994).
David Maraniss, First in His Class: A Biography of Bill Clinton (New York: Simon, & Schuster, 1995).
Stanley A. Renshon, High Hopes: The Clinton Presidency and the Politics of Ambition (New York: New York University Press, 1996).
Martin Walker, The President We Deserve: Bill Clinton, His Rise. Falls, and Comebacks (New York: Crown, 1996).