PHILOLOGY
Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language
|
1998
|
|
© Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language 1998, originally published by Oxford University Press 1998. (Hide copyright information)
Copyright
PHILOLOGY [From Greek
philología love of language]. The traditional study of
LANGUAGE, which reached its peak as
comparative philology in the later 19c. Overshadowed in the 20c by its offspring
LINGUISTICS, it continues in a more muted fashion, sharing much with the subdiscipline
historical linguistics, and focusing particularly on the evolution of languages, especially in terms of their groupings (‘families’) and their elements. Languages appear to change in the direction of greater diversity: one language tends to be superseded by several; a written ‘dead’ language preserves evidence of the earlier forms from which ‘living’ languages developed. Thus, Latin
planctus gave way to French
plainte and Italian
pianto;
LATIN planus to
FRENCH plain and
ITALIAN piano. The descendants of the Latin words have diverged to the point that, though Italian is related to French, they are now foreign to each other, as is their common ‘parent’ to both. The changes, moreover, are regular: Italian reduces the Latin
-us ending to
-o, French reduces it to
-e or deletes it entirely; Latin
a becomes French
ai and remains unchanged in Italian; and Latin
pl becomes Italian
pi and remains unchanged in French.
Not so regular is the change of
MEANING: Italian
piano has at least one meaning (‘soft’ as opposed to ‘loud’) not in the related Latin or French. In the combination
piano e forte (
soft and loud),
piano in due course became the name for a keyboard instrument, the
pianoforte, more capable of dynamic variation thancame before it. By abbreviation, this new instrument is now usually called a
piano in English and various other languages. The special meaning of the Italian phrase results from its cultural context and the distinctive feature of the instrument it names. The English word still names the same instrument, but the clipping discards ‘and loud’ from the original Italian phrase and hence becomes an arbitrary label and no longer a description. Over the centuries, philologists have learned to trace and tease out such facts and processes as these, and over the last century philology has concerned itself with all such changes and with the linguistic relationships they result in.
Written documents provide the information needed for this study, but, by mapping such relationships, philologists can also reconstruct further relationships among stages of earlier languages that left no written records. Thus, philologists give the name
Germanic to the language that is the source of English as Latin is the source of French; but Germanic, unlike Latin, vanished without leaving written testimony. Presentday understanding of the family of
INDO-EUROPEAN LANGUAGES therefore results from studies that systematically combine textual analysis and hypothetical reconstruction.
History
The ancient Greeks wrote about their own language, having little interest in comparing Greek with what they considered lesser (barbarian) languages. Roman writers, impressed by such thinking, undertook some comparisons of their Latin with Greek, for though not mutually intelligible, the two have many similarities of
VOCABULARY (Latin and Doric Greek both have
māter for mother) and of GRAMMAR (both have three grammatical
GENDERS and similar declensional systems). From such hints, some Roman writers concluded that Latin had descended from Greek, a view abandoned only with the development of comparative philology around 1800, which demonstrated that Greek and Latin descended collaterally from a putative common ancestor, Indo-European (IE).
In the Middle Ages, Latin ceased to be an everyday spoken language, and the
VERNACULARS descended from it, such as French and Italian, grew in prestige. Writers like Dante gave some consideration to the relationship among vernaculars and their kinship with Latin, that is, to comparative and historical concerns. Such consideration, aided from the Renaissance onwards by the publication of many early manuscript texts as printed books, yielded further knowledge of individual language families such as the
CELTIC and
GERMANIC. But speculation concentrated on vocabulary and took no account of systematic relationships, and hence failed to discern larger ‘genetic’ connections. On the rare occasions where a common parent language was postulated, the language was (for cultural and even doctrinal reasons) usually
HEBREW. As late as 1807, the writer Alexander Pirie could maintain that ‘The originality of the Hebrew language being incontrovertible, nothing can be more natural than that all other languages should in some respects be derivatives.’ Such arguments distracted from the successful study of IE, with which Hebrew has no genetic connection.
European
IMPERIALISM put 18c scholars in touch with such Asian languages as
SANSKRIT, and in 1786 Sir William
JONES announced his belief that the grammar of Sanskrit revealed its close affinity with Greek and Latin, suggesting the derivation of all three from ‘some common source … which no longer exists’. Jones's belief, which served to unite previously fragmented studies of individual language families, underwent elaboration in the 19c, especially by F. von Schlegel, Franz Bopp, Rasmus Rask, and Jacob Grimm early in the century and later by A. F. Pott, K. Verner, Ferdinand de Saussure, K. Brugmann, and B. Delbrück.
These scholars concentrated on refining knowledge of the relationship of later languages (such as French and Italian) with their earlier written forms (such as Latin), the relationship of these earlier written forms (such as Latin and Sanskrit) with each other, and the relationship of them all with the unrecorded ‘common source’, whether the lost Germanic original of the Scandinavian, GOTHIC,
GERMAN, and English languages, or the lost Indo-European original of Germanic, Latin, Greek, and Sanskrit. These relationships are usually set out in a form devised by A. Schleicher, resembling a genetic ‘family tree’ owing much to biological classification and Darwinism. The materials for establishing such a schematic form are the usual objects of language study:
VOCABULARY, GRAMMAR (especially
MORPHOLOGY), and sounds with their orthographic equivalents, as in the French and Italian words derived from Latin (above). However, vocabulary is at once the most tempting and the most treacherous evidence for the study, because, unlike sounds or grammatical forms, WORDS readily migrate from one language to another. Currently, linguists generally prefer the synchronic study of spoken language to the diachronic comparison of words in texts, and have tended to regard philology as pre-scientific. Others have sought to bring elements of old and new together in panchronic studies that give equal importance to past and present. However regarded, philology (in association with traditional grammar and
ETYMOLOGY) has built a formidable edifice which few scholars ignore when writing about or teaching the history of languages. See
LANGUAGE FAMILY,
MURRAY,
SEMANTIC CHANGE,
SEMANTICS,
SWEET.
Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.
|
Videotex may revolutionize your home life
Newspaper article from: Chicago Sun-Times; 2/23/1986; ; 700+ words
; Q. Is videotex anything to get excited about? A. Videotex will probably be the next big electronic sensation in the American home. Videotex is a generic term for a two-way electronic system that makes information in computers easily available...
|
|
Videotex booster, local distributors exchange lawsuits. (Data-Tel Video Text Inc.)
Magazine article from: San Diego Business Journal; 3/19/1990; ; 700+ words
; Videotex booster, local distributors exchange...write it off and keep on trucking." Videotex of Southern California Inc. signed contracts...around a telecommunications trend called "videotex," similar to a computer bulletin board...
|
|
Developing videotex as a consumer medium.
Magazine article from: Information Today; 3/1/1990; ; 700+ words
; Developing Videotex as a Consumer Medium A good videotex service grabs its users, drawing them farther and farther...or another. Being attractive to users is what consumer videotex is all about. Videotex for business users can be simply...
|
|
Why consider videotex? (column)
Magazine article from: Folio: the Magazine for Magazine Management; 4/1/1984; ; 700+ words
; Why consider videotex? The controversy continues over whether videotex (which allows two-way interaction between sender...of Consumer Reports, which recently introduced a Videotex service. BB: Why should a publisher of a consumer...
|
|
Lessons from the "videotex school of hard knocks." (column)
Magazine article from: Online; 1/1/1991; ; 700+ words
; ...ONLINE, November 1990), I introduced the subject of videotex and presented a few impressions of the Videotex '90 conference held in May, 1990. This column continues our look at videotex and examines some reasons why the hopes of its developers...
|
|
And you thought videotex was dead!
Magazine article from: Online; 11/1/1990; ; 700+ words
; And You Thought Videotex Was Dead! It would be difficult to...these companies are known generally as videotex, and it is probably safe to say that...them as they could be. My interest in videotex was piqued when I attended the fifth...
|
|
French seek to repeat videotex success in U.S. (includes related article on Minitel aiding cable TV)
Magazine article from: Communications News; 6/1/1990; ; 700+ words
; FRENCH SEEK TO REPEAT VIDEOTEX SUCCESS IN U.S. A little over a...has bee the success of the French videotex system, originally called Teletel...than 200,000 subscribers to their videotex services. Mindful of the united Europe...
|
|
World trade group elects Texas president. (International Videotex Industry Association, Amin Rahme)
PR Newswire; 11/20/1987; 700+ words
; ...first time a truly international videotex forum took place in Paris, it was announced today by the International Videotex Industry Association (IVIA). Until...local attendees. Out of the 110 videotex specialists at the forum in Paris...
|
|
Brighter Picture Is Appearing for Business Videotex.
Magazine article from: Communications News; 8/1/1985; ; 700+ words
; While public videotex services continue to languish in the US, the picture for business videotex brightening. This past year has seen a major...Corporation and Honeywell into the business videotex arena, as well as significant joint-venture...
|
|
VIA to take part in research project. (Videotex Industry Association)
Magazine article from: Information Today; 4/1/1989; 700+ words
; ...Public Technology, Inc. (PTI) and the Videotex Industry Association (VIA) have joined...demonstration project to explore how videotex, a growing interactive medium, can...potential role for cities and countries as videotex service providers and users. The project...
|
|
videotex
Book article from: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition
videotex communications service that is linked...pictorial information at home. Traditional videotex systems are limited to menu-oriented...viewing screen. There are two forms of videotex systems. One-way teletext systems permit...
|
|
CompuServe Incorporated
Book article from: International Directory of Company Histories
...personal computer users worldwide with videotex, a system for accessing electronic information...services. Through its pioneering efforts in videotex technology, CompuServe introduced an...as research and development. Through videotex, CompuServe enabled users to perform...
|
|
CompuServe Interactive Services, Inc.
Book article from: International Directory of Company Histories
...services. Through its pioneering efforts in videotex technology, CompuServe introduced an...as research and development. Through videotex, CompuServe enabled users to perform...Americans became more willing to explore videotex transactions. CompuServe reported that...
|
|
Prodigy Communications Corporation
Book article from: International Directory of Company Histories
...joint venture, named Trintex, to offer videotex services. In this pre-Internet era, Videotex was a system enabling subscribers to obtain...news, home shopping, and catalogs. Other videotex ventures, most notably Knight-Ridder...
|
|
Mecklermedia Corporation
Book article from: International Directory of Company Histories
...cover the emerging technology. Software Review and Videodisc-Videotex, a quarterly launched in 1981, were two of his earliest moves...had already positioned himself in this area with Videodisc-Videotex, and he sponsored his first trade shows on the subject of...
|