DESCRIPTIVE AND PRESCRIPTIVE GRAMMAR

Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language | Date: 1998

DESCRIPTIVE AND PRESCRIPTIVE GRAMMAR. Contrasting terms in LINGUISTICS. A descriptive grammar is an account of a language that seeks to describe how it is used objectively, accurately, systematically, and comprehensively. A prescriptive grammar is an account of a language that sets out rules (prescriptions) for how it should be used and for what should not be used (proscriptions), based on norms derived from a particular model of grammar. For English, such a grammar may prescribe I as in It is I and proscribe me as in It's me. It may proscribe like used as a conjunction, as in He behaved like he was in charge, prescribing instead He behaved as if he were in charge. Prescriptive grammars have been criticized for not taking account of language change and stylistic variation, and for imposing the norms of some groups on all users of a language. They have been discussed by linguists as exemplifying specific attitudes to language and usage. Traditional grammar books have often, however, combined description and prescription. Since the late 1950s, it has become common in linguistics to contrast descriptive grammars with GENERATIVE GRAMMARS. The former involve a description of linguistic structures, usually based on utterances elicited from native-speaking informants. The latter, introduced by CHOMSKY, concentrate on providing an explicit account of an ideal native speaker's knowledge of language (COMPETENCE) rather than a description of samples (performance). Chomsky argued that generative grammars are more valuable, since they capture the creative aspect of human linguistic ability. Linguists generally regard both approaches as complementary. See DESCRIPTIVISM AND PRESCRIPTIVISM, STRUCTURAL LINGUISTICS.


© Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language 1998, originally published by Oxford University Press 1998.

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

A grammar of black masculinity: a body of science.(Abstract)
The Journal of Men's Studies; 3/22/2002; Saint-Aubin, Arthur F.; 787 words ; ... nineteenth-century Western science has produced, through a series of authoritative discourses, what I am calling a grammar of black masculinity. For just as what has been labeled a masculinist conception of science and of scientific ... discourses generated by and imbued with a white-supremacist ideology--has ... Read more
If only the grammar police knew I shared their little obsessions.(News)
Western Mail (Cardiff, Wales); 6/14/2004; 722 words ; ... but'?' In the words of Britney, ooops I did it again. And I don't care. But I do really. The arrival of the grammar police is always distressing. It's no good trying to convince them you are simply writing in pacy journalese or choosing descriptive over-prescriptive language. The law is the law even if ... Read more
Who really cares about grammar and Usage?
Public Relations Quarterly; 10/1/1997; Grazian, Frank; 787 words ; ... possibly care more - about copy that makes errors in grammar and usage? In a broader sense, what difference does ... communicating with the people they have to deal with. ABC News Analyst George Will offered this answer: "It's all ... influence." For those in the public relations field, grammar and usage are ... Read more
On the Correctness of Language: The Case of Impersonal sie Constructions in Polish
Canadian Slavonic Papers; 3/1/2004; Osadnik, Waclaw M; 787 words ; ... seeming dichotomy between descriptive and prescriptive linguistics. Beginning with ... Transformational-Generative Grammar, the paper discusses the notions ... the boundaries separating descriptive linguistics from its prescriptive counterpart are indeed blurred ... the difference between the ... Read more
Student language narratives and discrimination.
Academic Exchange Quarterly; 3/22/2007; Latta, Susan; 787 words ; ... on the tension between traditional, prescriptive approaches to teaching grammar--the belief that a standard exists ... economic and patriotic reasons--and descriptive linguistic accounts that point out ... interactions. The sociolinguistic turn in grammar studies has led to the catchphrase ... Read more