intelligent design
From: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition
|
Date: 2008
intelligent design theory that some complex biological structures and other aspects of nature show evidence of having been designed by an intelligence. Such biological structures are said to have intricate components that are so highly interdependent and so essential to a particular function or process that the structures could not have developed through Darwinian evolution , and therefore must have been created or somehow guided in their development. Although intelligent design is distinguished from creationism by not relying on the biblical account of creation, it is compatible with a belief in God and is often explicitly linked with such a belief. Also, unlike creationists, its proponents do not challenge the idea that the earth is billions of years old and that life on earth has evolved to some degree. The theory does, however, necessarily reject standard science's reliance on explaining the natural world only through undirected natural causes, believing that any theory that relies on such causes alone is incapable of explaining how all biological structures and processes arose. Thus, despite claims by members of the intelligent-design movement that it is a scientific research program, the work of its adherents has been criticized as unscientific and speculative for inferring a pre-existing intelligence to explain the development of biological structures instead of attempting to develop adequate falsifiable mechanistic explanations. In addition, the theory has been attacked on the grounds that many aspects of nature fail to show any evidence of intelligent design, such as "junk" DNA (see nucleic acid ) and the vestigial webbed feet of the frigate bird (which never lands on water).
The idea that nature shows signs of having been designed by an intelligent being dates back at least to ancient Greece. The English theologian William Paley gave the theory its classic formulation in his Natural Theology; or, Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity (1802), in which he argued that the eye and other biological features are perfectly suited for their purposes and that in this suitable design the hand of God can be discerned. The modern intelligent-design movement, however, has its origins in the 1980s with such works as The Mystery of Life's Origins (1984) by Charles Thaxton et al. and Evolution: A Theory in Crisis (1986) by Michael Denton. Micheal Behe's Darwin's Black Box (1996) is perhaps the best-known statement of the movement's critique of Darwin and its argument for a role for God or some other intelligence in the design of biological entities. Advocates of intelligent design have campaigned to have it taught in U.S. public schools alongside the Darwinian theory of evolution. A requirement by the Dover, Pa., area school board that students be told that intelligent design represents an alternative explanation for the origin of life was challenged in federal court in 2005 and ruled unconstitutional.
Bibliography: See R. T. Pennock, ed., Intelligent Design Creationism and Its Critics (2002).
Author not available, INTELLIGENT DESIGN.,
The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2008
The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. Copyright 2008 Columbia University Press
For permission to reuse this article, contact Copyright Clearance Center.
Related articles from HighBeam Research:
|
YOUR VIEWS: EVOLUTION AND INTELLIGENT DESIGN.(FORUM)(Letter to the Editor)
Wisconsin State Journal (Madison, WI); 10/16/2005; 2921 words;
Intelligent design works via evolution I was trained ... come to understand that the obviously intelligent design for producing this diversity is through ... evolution is the awesome way that intelligent design is expressed. So what is the conflict ...
|
|
Intelligent design: scientific theory or religious conviction?
Journal of Church and State; 3/22/2003; Greenawalt, Kent; 9306 words;
... past decade to the theory of intelligent design. Most adherents to the neo ... scientific communities--see intelligent design as just one more stratagem ... biology curriculum. Proponents of intelligent design counter that their theory is ...
|
|
US JUDGE REJECTS INTELLIGENT DESIGN
The Boston Globe; 12/21/2005; Nina J. Easton, Globe Staff; 1168 words;
... Pennsylvania yesterday ruled that intelligent design is "nothing less than the progeny ... legal setback for proponents of intelligent design, which holds that living organisms ... ruling, the first legal test of intelligent design, comes after a six-week trial ...
|
|
Revisiting the Dover Intelligent Design Trial
Talk of the Nation Science Friday (NPR); 2/23/2007; IRA FLATOW; 8226 words;
... and creationism and intelligent design. Did you find that ... the evolution, the intelligent design voices, and then this ... how it all works. The intelligent designers know exactly how it ... voted to remove the intelligent the pro-intelligent design standards that ...
|
|
Intelligent design goes on trial in federal court.
Chicago Tribune (Chicago, IL); 9/26/2005; 1206 words;
... The first legal test of intelligent design, a concept critical of Darwin ... and random mutation against intelligent design, which holds that certain features ... of evolution and introduces intelligent design as an alternative explanation ...
|
|
The Dover decision: a stunning blow against intelligent design creationism--how the Kitzmiller et al. v. Dover Area School District trial unfolded.
Skeptic (Altadena, CA); 6/22/2005; Humburg, Burt Brayton, Ed; 4833 words;
... testimony, the first evolution-Intelligent Design trial of the 21st century drew ... legally sophisticated challenger, Intelligent Design (ID). On the morning of December ... ruling against the teaching of Intelligent Design:</p> <pre> The ...
|
|
Defense focuses on establishing validity of intelligent design.
Chicago Tribune (Chicago, IL); 10/17/2005; Anderson, Lisa; 1130 words;
... federal court here Monday that intelligent design, a view critical of Charles ... although he said he believes the intelligent designer is God. With a great-great-grands ... An outspoken advocate of intelligent design, Behe wrote the 1996 book ...
|
|
Biochemist: Intelligent design is science.
Chicago Tribune (Chicago, IL); 10/18/2005; 1083 words;
... nothing other than an intelligent cause has been able to ... a strong appearance of design, the concept of design is rationally justified ... that bear the mark of a designer. Behe, who wrote the chapter ... but well explained by design, he testified. Responding ... for the plaintiffs that ...
|
|
ID and SETI: can intelligent design be considered scientific in the same way that SETI is?(Intelligent design and search for extraterrestrial intelligence)
Skeptic (Altadena, CA); 6/22/2005; Camp, Robert; 3220 words;
... RHETORICAL devices used by Intelligent Design (ID) theorists in support of ... that make a determination of Intelligent Design extraneous from a scientific ... or chance) and some form of intelligent design. The problems with Dembski ...
|
|
Garrett backs lessons on intelligent design
The Record (Bergen County, NJ); 9/30/2005; KATHLEEN CARROLL, STAFF WRITER; 1197 words;
... Garrett backs lessons on intelligent design By KATHLEEN CARROLL ... 09-30-2005, Friday Section: NEWS Edtion: All Editions ... to include lessons on intelligent design alongside evolution ... Garrett, R-Wantage. "[But] intelligent design is one that is apparently ... to consider ...
|
|
U.S. judge rejects teaching of intelligent design Idea is classified as religion, not science
International Herald Tribune; 12/22/2005; Laurie Goodstein; 795 words;
... Tennessee.Intelligent design posits that biological ... that it must have been designed by an intelligent source. Its adherents ... from identifying the designer, and that it could even ... the trial proved that intelligent design was ''creationism relabeled ... members who supported ...
|
|
Analysis: New science program in Montana introduces public school students to the concept of intelligent design
Weekend Edition - Sunday (NPR); 5/2/2004; LIANE HANSEN; 1279 words;
... explained as a result of an intelligent cause rather than an ... can empirically detect design, I mean, I don't see ... Advancement of Science, dismiss intelligent design and its tenets as unscientific ... We are not asking for intelligent design to be taught in the science ... incorporates ...
|
|
The 'intelligent design' decision: America's Newspapers Speak Out: newspapers across America commented on U.S District Court Judge John E. Jones' ruling in the Dover, Pa., 'intelligent design' controversy. Here are excerpts from some of those editorials.(Pennsylvania)(Excerpt)
Church & State; 2/1/2006; Boston, Rob; 1302 words;
... Religious At Its Core Advocates of intelligent design don't talk about God, and they ... makes abundantly clear that intelligent design--which posits that the complexity ... thoroughgoing repudiation of intelligent design will end the incessant warfare ...
|
|
EVOLUTION DEBATE GROWS ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES; INTEREST SPARKED BY INTELLIGENT DESIGN CASES IN KANSAS AND PENNSYLVANIA.(News)
The Post-Standard (Syracuse, NY); 11/20/2005; 1363 words;
... e's also an advocate for intelligent design - the notion that biological ... She helped found the Intelligent Design and Evolution Awareness ... evolution. The debate over intelligent design, Darwin and God usually makes news at the public school ... interest in tackling ...
|
|
Victory in Dover! Federal Court unmasks the Genesis of 'intelligent design'--and the lies that helped bring it into Pennsylvania public schools.
Church & State; 2/1/2006; Boston, Rob; 3078 words;
... decision. (See The Intelligent Design Decision, page 8 ... Minnery told Focus' news service. Most unfortunately ... establishment of religion. Intelligent design is not a religious ... definitive decision about intelligent design. This is an activist ... more interested in ...
|
See all results from premium newspaper and magazine articles, images, maps and more at HighBeam Research.
Related articles from newspapers, magazines and other sources:
Creator God: the debate on intelligent design.(Cover Story)
The Christian Century; 12/27/2005; Steinmetz, David C.; 2717 words;
|
Design Yes, Intelligent No A Critique of Intelligent Design Theory and Neocreationism.
Skeptical Inquirer; 9/1/2001; PIGLIUCCI, MASSIMO; 4207 words;
|
Neither intelligent nor designed: evolution succeeds where "Intelligent Design" fails in describing the natural world.
Skeptical Inquirer; 11/1/2003; Martin, Bruce Martin, Frances; 3121 words;
|
Intelligent design.(LETTERS TO THE EDITOR)(Letter to the editor)
Skeptical Inquirer; 5/1/2006; Gumbrell, Anthony Bentley, John G. Gosling, Craig; 751 words;
|
The 'vise strategy' undone: Kitzmiller et al. v. Dover Area School District: here's an inside look at the first legal case testing intelligent design, Kitzmiller et al. v. Dover Area School District, by one of the expert witnesses for the pro-evolution side. The "Darwinists" won the landmark case, establishing the first legal precedent restricting the teaching of intelligent design in public-school science classes.(Case overview)
Skeptical Inquirer; 1/1/2007; Forrest, Barbara; 5778 words;
|
Vatican newspaper rejects science behind intelligent design.(CHURCH NOTES)
Catholic New Times; 2/12/2006; 274 words;
|
AGU: President confuses science and belief, puts schoolchildren at risk.(American Geophysical Union, evolution, intelligent design)
Skeptical Inquirer; 11/1/2005; 338 words;
|
Why scientists shouldn't be surprised by the popularity of intelligent design: perspectives from psychology: the main obstacle standing in the way of the public's acceptance of evolutionary theory is not a dearth of common sense. Instead, it is the public's erroneous belief that common sense is a reliable guide to evaluating the natural world.
Skeptical Inquirer; 5/1/2006; Lilienfeld, Scott O.; 2047 words;
|
Intelligent design?(Century marks)(Brief Article)
The Christian Century; 11/15/2005; 110 words;
|
Intelligent design theory belongs in the science classroom.(VIEWPOINT)
National Catholic Reporter; 10/21/2005; Betty, Stafford; 978 words;
|
|
|