Fifth Avenue Theatre, New York. 1. On 24th Street near Broadway. Originally the Fifth Avenue Opera House, specializing in Negro
minstrel shows, it opened as a theatre in 1867, but closed abruptly after a fight in the auditorium in which a man was killed. It reopened in 1869 with John
Brougham in one of his own plays, and on 16 Apr. became
Daly's Fifth Avenue Theatre, with a good company that included Mrs
Gilbert and Fanny
Davenport. Its first outstanding success was Daly's own version of
Frou-Frou by Meilhac and Halévy. Being anxious to encourage American dramatists Daly staged Bronson
Howard's Saratoga (1870), which had a long run. In 1873 the theatre was burnt down and not rebuilt. The site was later used for the Fifth Avenue Hall which became the
Madison Square Theatre. 2. Daly opened his second Fifth Avenue Theatre, at Broadway and 28th Street, in 1874 with an elaborate and costly production of
Love's Labour's Lost, not previously seen in New York, which failed. Success came with the production in 1875 of Daly's own play
The Big Bonanza, in which John
Drew made his New York début. The following season saw the New York production of the popular London success
Our Boys by H. J.
Byron, in which Georgiana
Drew made her first appearance in New York. The first night of Sheridan's
The School for Scandal on 5 Dec., with Charles
Coghlan, was marred by the disastrous Brooklyn Theatre fire (see
FIRES IN THEATRES). By 1878 Daly was finding the financial loss on the theatre too great and left to take over Banvard's Museum, which he opened as
Daly's Theatre. The Fifth Avenue came under new management and was ultimately leased to various travelling companies; after many changes of name it was pulled down in 1908.