PEER REVIEW FROM THE STUDENTS' PERSPECTIVE: INVALUABLE OR INVALID?

From: Composition Studies | Date: October 1, 2007| Author: | Copyright information

Peer review is well established as an important theoretical component of the writing process. Early practitioners of process writing such as Peter Elbow, Kenneth Bruffee, Donald Murray, and Anne Ruggles Gere studied, discussed, published, and lived collaborative learning at a time when the "chalk and talk" lecture routine was standard throughout higher education. Thanks to their vision, the process of having students critique each other's papers has become commonplace in the composition classroom and in English composition textbooks. According to one survey, experienced instructors believe ...

Read all of this article with a FREE trial to HighBeam Research

Related newspaper, magazine, and trade journal articles from HighBeam Research

(Including press releases, facts, information, and biographies)

Rethinking Peer Review: Detecting and Addressing Medical Malpractice Claims Risk
; ...At the chair's request, the hospital peer review committee evaluates Dr. G's malpractice...this Article, we analyze the ability of peer review to recognize and reduce physicians...malpractice claims. Critics argue that peer review neither consistently identifies substandard...
State medical peer review: High cost but no benefit--is it time for a change?
; ...policy-makers have widely accepted peer review of physicians as essential to...high quality medical practice. Peer review is a process by which members...their practice. l To encourage peer review, almost all states have granted...
Peer Review: Dealing with the Reality of Perceptions
; ...there was a lot of discussion about peer review, the process by which CPA firms review...work in order to ensure high standards. Peer review is basically educational-helping to...progressive disciplinary approach to peer review. People have vastly different perceptions...
Embracing the Evolution of Peer Review
; ...other state societies don't address peer review, the New York State Education Department...counterparts in other states will. CPA firm peer review as a quality-control mechanism has always...regulator, resulting in self-regulated peer review with one-size-fits-all rules that serve...
Peer Review: Is It For You?
; For CPAs in public practice, peer review has been a part of our practice lives for...or a state society that has a mandatory peer review requirement, you still may be subject to peer review. Over 50 percent of the state boards of...
FLAWS ARE FOUND IN VALIDATING MEDICAL STUDIES MANY SEE NEED TO OVERHAUL STANDARDS FOR PEER REVIEW
; ...heart disease. Each study was vetted by peer review, the basic process for checking medical...specialists began looking at whether peer review had failed to identify serious flaws...system. In advance of a world congress on peer review next month in Chicago, these specialists...
Could peer review be wrong? (Focus on Publishing).
; Seriously questioning the validity of the peer-review process is like debating the merits of a holy grail. We've been conducting peer review for so long (more than 200 years, by...good. Or as Martha Stewart might say: Peer review. It's a good thing. But two scholarly...
Performance appraisals: how valuable is peer review?
; ...worried, since it was the first time that peer review was to be part of the appraisal process...whose units had already implemented peer review. For the most part, the reports were...management's job? How is this going to help us? Peer review is a form of performance appraisal that...
Peer Review: An Emerging Niche Market
; The AICPA's Peer Review Program began more than 30 years ago as a...Plan Audit Quality Center) either require peer review for membership or require that member firms make their peer review reports readily available to the public...
Peer review in an era of transparency.(Top Stories)
; Should peer review results be made public? A future AICPA...opportunity to vote on changes to the peer review program. At its spring 2004 meeting...supporting increased transparency in the peer review process. It also authorized a member...