The Good Case: Decisions to Litigate at the World Trade Organization

From: Law & Society Review | Date: March 1, 2008| Author: Conti, Joseph A | Copyright information

This article draws upon the law-in-action, repeat players, and motive to understand how legal actors construct the "good case" in dispute settlement systems. The construction of "good cases" is examined at the World Trade Organization (WTO), a relatively new and unexplored site for the study of dispute settlement. Findings show that the good case encompasses flexible sets of motives including economic, political, and symbolic characteristics of trade grievances to mobilize WTO law. The flexib...

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

The WTO Dispute Settlement Procedure under Review - How to Induce better Compliance?
Aussenwirtschaft ; The article addresses recent observations on the participation and compliance records of WTO Member States under the dispute settlement system. Different approaches are discussed and particular regard is given to the optimization of incentives to abide by WTO rules. On the one hand, there has been
WTO Dispute Settlement at Ten: Evolution, Experiences, and Evaluation
Aussenwirtschaft ; On 1 January 1995, the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (DSU) entered into force. During its first ten years, the DSU has since been applied to 324 complaints - more cases than dispute settlement under the GATT 1947 had dealt with in nearly five decades.
Can the WTO dispute settlement body be a judicial tribunal rather than a diplomatic club?
Law and Policy in International Business ; I. INTRODUCTION John Ragosta has prepared a thoughtful and instructive paper.1 He tackles a very important subject, especially from the perspective of the U.S. private sector, namely: what should be the role of private parties and private counsel in what was designed essentially to be a
Problems with WTO dispute settlement
Chicago Journal of International Law ; The open multilateral trading system that has been part of the international economic architecture of the last six decades has brought unparalleled growth and economic well-being to a larger proportion of the world than in any prior era. Those who care about preserving and enhancing this progress
Process, compliance and implementation issues in WTO dispute settlement
American Society of International Law. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting ; The panel was convened at 2:30 p.m., Friday, April 11, by its Chair, John H. Jackson, who introduced the panelists: William J. Davey, Director, Legal Affairs Division, World Trade Organization; Pieter Jan Kuyper, Legal Adviser, Commission of the European Communities; and C. Christopher Parlin,
Is WTO dispute settlement effective?
Global Governance ; The World Trade Organization (WTO) has become one of the most controversial international institutions, as evidenced by the massive protests in Seattle in November 1999. (1) Curiously, both the defendants and the critics of the WTO seem to believe that it is a highly effective institution, but that
WTO dispute settlement procedures could increase reliance on ADR
Dispute Resolution Journal ; International businesses are urging the World Trade Organization to make its dispute settlement system more efficient. Last year, the WTO members committed to negotiate "improvements and clarifications" to the WTO Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU) policies. That process will begin later this
Operation of WTO dispute settlement panels: Assessing proposals for reform
Law and Policy in International Business ; I. INTRODUCTION By their very nature, international institutions present special problems for the policy maker. At the lowest level, the survival and effective functioning of international bodies, such as the World Trade Organizes tion (WTO) dispute settlement panels, depends not only upon the
Participation by private counsel in World Trade Organization dispute settlement proceedings
Law and Policy in International Business ; ABSTRACT This Note is an examination of private counsel participation in the World Trade Organization1 (WTO) dispute settlement process and the relevant considerations involved. This examination is especially pertinent in light of both the increasing amount of litigation before the WTO dispute
U.S. Trade Representative claims victory in WTO dispute with EU over food names.
International Law Update ; The U.S. Trade Representative has announced that the U.S. prevailed in the World Trade Organization dispute with the European Union (EU) over food names. It appears, however, that the Commission of the European Union disagrees with that interpretation of the WTO dispute settlement panel's decision.