High Court Rejects Relaxation Of Standard for Guilty Verdict; No Compromise Allowed in `Beyond Reasonable Doubt' Instruction

From: The Washington Post | Date: June 2, 1993| Author: Joan Biskupic | Copyright information

The Supreme Court ruled yesterday that when a jury finds a defendant guilty by using a standard less than "beyond a reasonable doubt," the verdict must be thrown out.

The court has long held that an individual can be convicted only if a jury believes beyond a reasonable doubt that he committed the crime. But until yesterday the justices had not addressed what happens when a judge's instruction to the jury subtly compromises the "reasonable doubt" standard and allows a lower burden of ...