WHAT IF...WE HAD WON AT CULLODEN? SATURDAY ESSAY: The finest transport system in the world? A top class economy? THREE World Cup finals? Would all these treasures have come Scotland's way if the Jacobites had prevailed on a bleak Highland battlefield?

From: Daily Mail | Date: August 26, 2006| Author: ALLAN MASSIE | Copyright information

COUNTER FACTUAL history became popular, even with academic historians, a few years ago. It is a nice intellectual parlour game, or bar game, i f you prefer. It answers the question 'What if...?' and allows you to construct an alternative version of the past.

The game is being played again following a report this week that some historians believe the Jacobite defeat at Culloden was good for Scotland.

One of the most popular of Scottish historical 'What ifs?' concerns the 1745 Ja...

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

What's New.(Ultra Electronics Audiopack teamed with Scott Health & Safety)(Brief Article)
Crain's Cleveland Business ; COMPANY: Ultra Electronics Audiopack, Garfield Heights PRODUCT: Hazmat Radiocom II Ultra Electronics Audiopack teamed with Scott Health & Safety, part of Tyco International Ltd., to develop a facepiece-integrated communications system'' exclusively for the New York City Fire Department Hazardous
Coriolanus.(Theater review)
Daily Variety ; (Eisenhower Theater, Washington, D.C.; 1,110 seats; $78 top) A Kennedy Center presentation of a Royal Shakespeare Company production of a play in two acts by William Shakespeare. Directed by Gregory Doran. Sets and costumes, Richard Hudson; original lighting, Tim Mitchell; lighting recreation,
Forms of Collective Violence: Riots, Pogroms and Genocide in Modern India.(Critical essay)
Pacific Affairs ; FORMS OF COLLECTIVE VIOLENCE: Riots, Pogroms and Genocide in Modern India. By Paul R. Brass. Gurgaon (India): Three Essays Collective, 2006. xix, 184 pp. Rs500.00, cloth. ISBN 81-88789-39-9. Paul R. Brass's book is a successful attempt at understanding how instances of collective violence in parts
Friedman and Russia.(Milton Friedman)
The Cato Journal ; One day I asked Milton Friedman a question. That question was in my mind every time we met: Could he have achieved the same status he did in America if he had lived in Russia--not only in terms of his research, but in shaping his outlook on life and in his understanding of freedom? Having kept
Human rights, limited government, and capitalism.
The Cato Journal ; By and large, there are two distinct intellectual traditions in social theorizing. One is normative. It addresses how people should live or how the social order should be arranged. Much of the human fights discourse belongs to this tradition. The other tradition attempts to analyze the world as it