Mistretta v. United States
The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States
|
2005
|
|
© The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States 2005, originally published by Oxford University Press 2005. (Hide copyright information)
Copyright
Mistretta v. United States, 488 U.S. 361 (1989), argued 5 Oct. 1988, decided 18 Jan. 1989 by vote of 8 to 1; Blackmun for the Court, Scalia in dissent. Federal judges have traditionally exercised considerable discretion in fixing the terms of sentences for convicted offenders. Convinced of a need for more uniformity in sentencing practices, Congress passed the Sentencing Reform Act of 1984, creating the United States Sentencing Commission and giving it authority to establish ranges of sentences for all categories of federal offenses. The commission was established as an independent body within the judicial branch to consist of seven members appointed by the president and removable by him. At least three were required to be federal judges, selected by the president from a list of six judges recommended by the Judicial Conference of the United States.
This statutory challenge to judicial autonomy, plus the unusual provisions for appointment and removal of commission members, raised
separation of powers issues. However, in
Mistretta the Supreme Court upheld the sentencing law in all respects. Though admitting that the commission was “an unusual hybrid in structure and authority,” Justice Harry A.
Blackmun ruled that locating the commission within the judicial branch did not violate the separation of powers doctrine (p. 412). The commission was not a court nor controlled by the judiciary. Requiring three federal judges to serve on the commission along with nonjudges did not affect the integrity or independence of the judicial branch. Giving the president power to remove commission members had no effect on the tenure or compensation of
Article III judges. The development of sentencing rules was an “essentially neutral endeavor” in which judicial participation was “peculiarly appropriate” (p. 407).
Justice Antonin
Scalia, dissenting, challenged the constitutionality of the commission. He concluded that it was a violation of
Article III of the Constitution to have federal judges serve in policy‐making positions in the executive branch.
See also
Appointment and Removal Power.
C. Herman Pritchett
Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.
|
DEEDS TOUTS HIS RURAL VALUES, COMMON-SENSE POLICIES
Newspaper article from: Roanoke Times & World News; 10/23/2005; ; 700+ words
; Creigh Deeds has always brought a sense of rural Virginia...County schools through the early 1970s. But Deeds saves most of the credit for his grandfather...electric power in Bath County. Even now, Deeds talks about the event as an awe-inspiring...
|
|
Deeds's Success Seen As Crucial For Kaine; Political Future Is Intertwined With Race
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post; 8/23/2009; ; 700+ words
; ...M. Kaine calls state Sen. R. Creigh Deeds, the Democratic nominee for governor...daily, and Kaine's wife has even called Deeds's wife to help her navigate the role...been through two statewide campaigns," Deeds said. "He's walked the same path I...
|
|
|
Deeds ignored advice, White House says; Top Democrats seek to shield Obama in case of election loss
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post; 10/23/2009; ; 700+ words
; ...frustration with how Democrat R. Creigh Deeds has handled his campaign for governor...Virginia Gov. Timothy M. Kaine (D) offered Deeds advice on winning a statewide election...the Democratic National Committee, told Deeds that he should lay out more of his own...
|
 "The Washington Times (Washington, DC)")
|
Deeds' address highlights the past; Casts him with Warner, Kaine.(PAGE ONE)
Newspaper article from: The Washington Times (Washington, DC); 8/22/2009; 700+ words
; ...Abruzzese, THE WASHINGTON TIMES R. Creigh Deeds worked to invigorate his gubernatorial...came amid public surveys that show Mr. Deeds trailing his Republican opponent, Robert...But the speech - streamed live on Mr. Deeds' campaign Web site - contained little...
|
|
|
Deeds reaches for 'Obama energy'; PRESIDENT SPEAKS AT RALLY Senator trails McDonnell in polls in swing state
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post; 10/28/2009; ; 700+ words
; ...of thousands not to count out R. Creigh Deeds, despite polls that show his Republican...are willing to work in this election." Deeds has pinned his comeback hopes on rallying...released Tuesday showed McDonnell leading Deeds among likely voters by 55 to 44 percent...
|
|
|
Deeds targets abortion issue; Democrat says GOP rival for governor has 'narrow' agenda.(D.C. AREA)
Newspaper article from: The Washington Times (Washington, DC); 8/11/2009; 700+ words
; ...Democratic gubernatorial candidate, R. Creigh Deeds, attacked his opponent's stance on abortion...issues than rebuilding the economy. Mr. Deeds, a state senator, made the charges during...members of the General Assembly, Mr. Deeds said he thinks that Virginia women are...
|
|
|
DEEDS LEARNING THE INS AND OUTS OF STATE SENATE WARM SPRINGS DEMOCRAT STARTING FROM SCRATCH AGAIN
Newspaper article from: Roanoke Times & World News; 2/24/2002; ; 700+ words
; ...November's election, former Del. Creigh Deeds found himself in an undesirable, yet promising...House of Delegates Democratic Caucus, Deeds was widely considered a top contender to...positions in the fiercely partisan House, Deeds chose a seat tucked in the far left corner...
|
|
|
Deeds drops popular name in campaign, but it's not Obama.(PAGE ONE)
Newspaper article from: The Washington Times (Washington, DC); 10/8/2009; 700+ words
; ...than 40 years to win Virginia, R. Creigh Deeds rarely mentions the president while he...in Raleigh, N.C. If you are Creigh Deeds and you want to communicate in shorthand...doesn't offer any rhetorical boost to Deeds in speaking to the general electorate...
|
|
|
Deeds Touts Himself as Heir to Kaine And Warner; Democrat Cultivates Image as Moderate
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post; 9/13/2009; ; 700+ words
; ...Democratic gubernatorial candidate R. Creigh Deeds began a short speech to cheering supporters...when asked what his campaign is about, Deeds has turned not to policy but to philosophy...the natural heir to Warner and Kaine, Deeds hopes he can inherit their reputation among...
|
|
|
DEEDS JOINS BIG-CITY LAW FIRM
Newspaper article from: Roanoke Times & World News; 12/1/2006; ; 700+ words
; ...joined a large Richmond firm. Deeds, D-Bath County, started...will provide more stability for Deeds and his family, which could...was precipitated largely by Deed's first run for a statewide...his law practice to campaign. Deeds split the vote nearly evenly...
|
|
Deed
Encyclopedia entry from: West's Encyclopedia of American Law
...order. A properly recorded deed provides constructive notice...considered to have notice of the deed whether or not they actually...sale in the records to other deeds, the purchaser might be required...map referred to in a recorded deed that describes the property...
|
|
|
Warranty Deed
Encyclopedia entry from: West's Encyclopedia of American Law
...clear of any claims. A deed is a written instrument...Although many types of deeds exist, title is usually transferred by a warranty deed. A warranty deed provides...two types of warranty deeds: general and special. A general warranty deed not only conveys to the...
|
|
|
Quitclaim Deed
Encyclopedia entry from: West's Encyclopedia of American Law
QUITCLAIM DEED An instrument of conveyance of real property that passes...representations as to the validity of such title. A quitclaim deed is a release by the grantor, or conveyor of the deed, of any interest the grantor may have in the property...
|
|
|
Deed of Trust
Encyclopedia entry from: West's Encyclopedia of American Law
DEED OF TRUST A document that embodies the agreement between a lender...a trustee, to secure the payment of a debt by the borrower. A deed of trust, also called a trust deed or a Potomac Mortgage, is used in some states in place of a mortgage...
|
|
deed
Book article from: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition
...The formalities with which a deed is invested are designed to...states of the United States deeds must be formally delivered and...It is possible to deposit a deed with a third party or a court...Most states also require that deeds be acknowledged by a duly authorized...
|
