Luther v. Borden
The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States
|
2005
|
|
© The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States 2005, originally published by Oxford University Press 2005. (Hide copyright information)
Copyright
Luther v. Borden, 7 How. (48 U.S.) 1 (1849), argued 24–28 Jan. 1848, decided 3 Jan. 1849 by vote of 8 to 1; Taney for the Court, Woodbury concurring in part and dissenting in part. The Constitution provides that the federal government shall guarantee to each state a “Republican Form of Government” (Art. IV, sec. 4), but does not specify how much popular participation in state government is required to retain the republican character, nor does it identify which branch of the federal government, if any, is responsible for enforcing the guarantee. Until the 1840s, this imprecision was of no practical significance. In the federal system, each state was as republican as its enfranchised citizens wanted it to be in matters of suffrage qualifications, apportionment, and tax burdens. But in 1842, the Dorr Rebellion implicated the
Guarantee Clause as a remedy for disfranchised Rhode Islanders, whose state officials ignored reformist demands to democratize the ossified state constitution.4
Though foremost among American states in the Industrial Revolution, Rhode Island suffered from an unusually backward constitutional order derived from the 1663 royal charter, which continued to serve as the state constitution. Severe disfranchisement of the urban population, composed largely of displaced Yankees and recent immigrants drawn to Rhode Island's cities to work in textile mills, was compounded by malapportionment that preserved dominant political power in rural districts. This produced a political anomaly in the period of Jacksonian democracy.
The so‐called Dorr Rebellion was precipitated when suffrage reformers, despairing of remedies for disfranchisement and malapportionment from the extant state government, invoked the principles of the
Declaration of Independence and attempted, in its words, to “alter or abolish” the oppressive government and “to institute [a] new government.”
The reformers called an extralegal constitutional convention, drafted a new state constitution that substantially ameliorated disfranchisement and malapportionment, submitted the document for popular ratification, and held elections under it. A draft constitution submitted by the extant government failed of ratification, but the government refused to cede power, so for a few months in 1842, two opposing governments contended for legitimacy and possession of state offices.
The incumbent governor and legislators, covertly encouraged by President John
Tyler's promise of federal military aid should violence occur, declared martial law. State judges convicted the reform governor, Thomas Wilson Dorr, of treason. The U.S. Supreme Court refused Dorr's 1845 appeal (
Ex parte Dorr) for release on
habeas corpus, because the federal writ did not reach state constitutions.
The Dorr supporter Martin Luther brought suit against a militiaman, Luther Borden, who had entered and searched Luther's home under authority of martial law. For Borden and the state, Daniel
Webster denied that the Rhode Island situation justified invoking the Constitution's
Guarantee Clause. Luther's counsel claimed that the state's archaic constitutional arrangements prevented fair and peaceful redress of grievances through democratic procedures. Rhode Islanders had therefore exercised Americans' ultimate right inherent in
popular sovereignty, that of replacing an oppressive government.
Luther v. Borden posed basic questions about the American constitutional order. Was the Supreme Court the appropriate institution to define the substantive content of republicanism? If frustrated in demands for orderly constitutional change, had Americans no alternatives to revolutionary violence? What was essential to a republican form of government?
The Supreme Court, speaking through Chief Justice Roger B.
Taney, skirted these difficult questions. Taney articulated the “political questions” doctrine, which diverts responsibility for resolving certain constitutional issues to the legislative and executive branches of government. “The sovereignty in every State resides in the people,” he concluded—with an empty concession as to how and whether they had exercised it in the Dorr cause—but “is a political question to be settled by the political power” (p. 47).
See also
Political Questions.
Bibliography
George M. Dennison , The Dorr War: Republicanism on Trial, 1831–1861 (1976).
Harold M. Hyman
Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.
|
sympathetic nervous system
Book article from: A Dictionary of Zoology
sympathetic nervous system That part of the autonomic nervous system which generally acts to stimulate the body to cope...increasing the rate of heart beat. Nerves of the sympathetic nervous system tend to form ganglia ( ganglion ) beside the vertebrae...
|
|
sympathetic tone
Book article from: A Dictionary of Biology
sympathetic tone The condition of a muscle when the tone is maintained predominantly by impulses from the sympathetic nervous system .
|
|
Peripheral Nervous System
Encyclopedia entry from: Gale Encyclopedia of Neurological Disorders
...subsystems: the sympathetic nervous system...somatic nervous system that always...autonomic nervous systems can act to...Although the sympathetic systems share...sympathetic systems of the ANS...sympathetic nervous system The ...
|
|
Nervous System Overview
Book article from: World of Forensic Science
...and the autonomic nervous system (ANS), which is associated...cardiac muscle. The autonomic nervous system is further subdivided into sympathetic and parasympathetic systems. The sympathetic nervous system (SNS), when related to the...
|
|
The Nervous System
Book article from: U*X*L Complete Health Resource
...associated parts. The autonomic nervous system can be divided further into...subdivisions: the parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous systems. These two subdivisions work...other. The parasympathetic nervous system regulates involuntary activities...
|