Pictures from Google Image Search

Luther v. Borden

The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States | 2005 | | © The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States 2005, originally published by Oxford University Press 2005. (Hide copyright information) Copyright

Luther v. Borden, 7 How. (48 U.S.) 1 (1849), argued 24–28 Jan. 1848, decided 3 Jan. 1849 by vote of 8 to 1; Taney for the Court, Woodbury concurring in part and dissenting in part. The Constitution provides that the federal government shall guarantee to each state a “Republican Form of Government” (Art. IV, sec. 4), but does not specify how much popular participation in state government is required to retain the republican character, nor does it identify which branch of the federal government, if any, is responsible for enforcing the guarantee. Until the 1840s, this imprecision was of no practical significance. In the federal system, each state was as republican as its enfranchised citizens wanted it to be in matters of suffrage qualifications, apportionment, and tax burdens. But in 1842, the Dorr Rebellion implicated the Guarantee Clause as a remedy for disfranchised Rhode Islanders, whose state officials ignored reformist demands to democratize the ossified state constitution.4

Though foremost among American states in the Industrial Revolution, Rhode Island suffered from an unusually backward constitutional order derived from the 1663 royal charter, which continued to serve as the state constitution. Severe disfranchisement of the urban population, composed largely of displaced Yankees and recent immigrants drawn to Rhode Island's cities to work in textile mills, was compounded by malapportionment that preserved dominant political power in rural districts. This produced a political anomaly in the period of Jacksonian democracy.

The so‐called Dorr Rebellion was precipitated when suffrage reformers, despairing of remedies for disfranchisement and malapportionment from the extant state government, invoked the principles of the Declaration of Independence and attempted, in its words, to “alter or abolish” the oppressive government and “to institute [a] new government.”

The reformers called an extralegal constitutional convention, drafted a new state constitution that substantially ameliorated disfranchisement and malapportionment, submitted the document for popular ratification, and held elections under it. A draft constitution submitted by the extant government failed of ratification, but the government refused to cede power, so for a few months in 1842, two opposing governments contended for legitimacy and possession of state offices.

The incumbent governor and legislators, covertly encouraged by President John Tyler's promise of federal military aid should violence occur, declared martial law. State judges convicted the reform governor, Thomas Wilson Dorr, of treason. The U.S. Supreme Court refused Dorr's 1845 appeal (Ex parte Dorr) for release on habeas corpus, because the federal writ did not reach state constitutions.

The Dorr supporter Martin Luther brought suit against a militiaman, Luther Borden, who had entered and searched Luther's home under authority of martial law. For Borden and the state, Daniel Webster denied that the Rhode Island situation justified invoking the Constitution's Guarantee Clause. Luther's counsel claimed that the state's archaic constitutional arrangements prevented fair and peaceful redress of grievances through democratic procedures. Rhode Islanders had therefore exercised Americans' ultimate right inherent in popular sovereignty, that of replacing an oppressive government.

Luther v. Borden posed basic questions about the American constitutional order. Was the Supreme Court the appropriate institution to define the substantive content of republicanism? If frustrated in demands for orderly constitutional change, had Americans no alternatives to revolutionary violence? What was essential to a republican form of government?

The Supreme Court, speaking through Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, skirted these difficult questions. Taney articulated the “political questions” doctrine, which diverts responsibility for resolving certain constitutional issues to the legislative and executive branches of government. “The sovereignty in every State resides in the people,” he concluded—with an empty concession as to how and whether they had exercised it in the Dorr cause—but “is a political question to be settled by the political power” (p. 47).

See also Political Questions.

Bibliography

George M. Dennison , The Dorr War: Republicanism on Trial, 1831–1861 (1976).

Harold M. Hyman

Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.

  • MLA
  • Chicago
  • APA

KERMIT L. HALL. "Luther v. Borden." The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States. Oxford University Press. 2005. Encyclopedia.com. 10 Nov. 2009 <http://www.encyclopedia.com>.

KERMIT L. HALL. "Luther v. Borden." The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States. Oxford University Press. 2005. Encyclopedia.com. (November 10, 2009). http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O184-LuthervBorden.html

KERMIT L. HALL. "Luther v. Borden." The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States. Oxford University Press. 2005. Retrieved November 10, 2009 from Encyclopedia.com: http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O184-LuthervBorden.html

Learn more about citation styles

Related newspaper, magazine, and trade journal articles from HighBeam Research

(Including press releases, facts, information, and biographies)

How Matthew Parker added to language.(News)
Newspaper article from: Western Mail (Cardiff, Wales); 8/6/2004; 442 words ; ...come from? Well, you may be interested to know that Matthew Parker was born on this day in 1504, and was one of those...the English language. But why? I hear you ask. Matthew Parker is a person of historical significance in his own...
DOCKET NO. 30850: APPROVAL OF A CERTIFICATE TO TRANSPORT PROPERTY FOR MATTHEW PARKER JR.
News Wire article from: US Fed News Service, Including US State News; 4/18/2008; 266 words ; ...CERTIFICATE TO TRANSPORT PROPERTY FOR MATTHEW PARKER JR., D/B/A MDMP TRUCKING Synopsis...CERTIFICATE TO TRANSPORT PROPERTY FOR MATTHEW PARKER JR., D/B/A MDMP TRUCKING. Companies Involved: MATTHEW PARKER JR.
How concrete channelled the American dream ; Panama Fever By Matthew Parker HUTCHINSON [pound]20 (444pp)
Newspaper article from: The Independent - London; 5/18/2007; ; 674 words ; ...only 11 miles of canal completed. Matthew Parker is at his best in picking over the...million cubic yards of rock and soil. Parker is excellent at the description...The story is an epic one, and Parker has brilliantly done justice to...
A dream that led to hell ended in triumph; DVDS/BOOKS Book SHELF HELL'S GORGE, by Matthew Parker Arrow pounds 8.99.(Features)
Newspaper article from: Huddersfield Daily Examiner (Huddersfield, England); 3/7/2008; 449 words ; ...conditions and amid epidemics, tens of thousands ofworkers perished fighting the jungle, swamps and mountains. Matthew Parker explores the fierce battle to get the project going and the immense engineering and medical challenges associated...
Courage and wit that won the battle; Spitfire Summer - When Britain Stood Alone . By Malcolm Brown (Carlton Books, pounds 14.99). Finest Hour. By Tim Clayton & Phil Craig (Hodder & Stoughton, pounds 12.99).The Battle of Britain July-October 1940 An Oral History of Britain's 'Finest Hour '. By Matthew Parker (Headline, pounds 22).The Battle of Britain . By Roy Conyers Nesbit (Sutton Publishing, pounds 25).(Books)
Newspaper article from: The Birmingham Post (England); 9/9/2000; 700+ words ; ...pilots. In The Battle of Britain July -October 1940 , Matthew Parker does not forget the grimmer realities of fighter pilot...training was cut from a month to just two weeks and Parker relates newcomers to squadrons would then be unlikely...
BrabenderCox.(FIRM CHANGES)(Matthew D. Parker to start his own firm Matthew D. Parker & Associates)(Brief article)
Magazine article from: Campaigns & Elections; 1/1/2007; 625 words ; Republican Matthew D. Parker, former aide to former U.S. Rep. Bob Ney, R-Ohio, has...executive at BrabenderCox to start his own consulting firm, Matthew D. Parker & Associates, which will offer campaign planning, opposition...
Matthew R. Parker. (On the Move).
Magazine article from: Florida Bar News; 12/15/2002; 255 words ; Matthew R. Parker has joined Carlton Fields, with offices at One Harbour Place, 777 S. Harbour Island Blvd., Tampa 33602, telephone (813)223-7000. He practices in the areas of corporate, securities, and taxation law.
MY KIND OF TOWN PANAMA CITY Historian Matthew Parker was born in Central America and is the author of Panama Fever: the Battle to Build the Canal (Hutchinson, pounds 20)
Newspaper article from: The Sunday Telegraph London; 5/6/2007; ; 700+ words ; Why Panama City? Because its history has made it outward-looking and incredibly cosmopolitan, with brilliant food and music. And in 20 minutes you can be in the deepest jungle or on a beautiful beach. What do you miss most when you are away? The warmth of the people and the climate. Panamanians
Books: Monte Cassino by Matthew Parker (Headline, pounds 20).(Features)
Newspaper article from: The Birmingham Post (England); 10/18/2003; 494 words ; Byline: Anthony Looch The destruction by Allied bombers of the great medieval monastery at Monte Cassino near Naples, in February, 1944, was one of the iconic moments of the Second World War. The terrible spectacle was thoroughly recorded by newsreel cameramen and caused dismay throughout the
Book reviews: Graphic reliving of monastery's bloody downfall; Monte Cassino by Matthew Parker. Published in hardback by Headline. pounds 16.99.(Features)
Newspaper article from: The News Letter (Belfast, Northern Ireland); 10/18/2003; 391 words ; THE destruction by Allied bombers of the great medieval monastery at Monte Cassino near Naples, in February, 1944, was one of the iconic moments of the Second World War. This well-researched and compelling book describes, in graphic detail, the full horror of the four interlocked battles at Monte

Related entries from encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauruses

Matthew Parker
Book article from: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition Matthew Parker 1504-75, English prelate, archbishop...and in 1537 to Henry VIII. In 1544, Parker became master of Corpus Christi College...noted for his editions of the works of Matthew of Paris and other chroniclers. Bibliography...
Parker, Matthew
Book article from: A Dictionary of British History Parker, Matthew (1504–75). Archbishop of...at Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, Parker was successively chaplain to Anne Boleyn...architect of the Elizabethan settlement, Parker courageously promoted theological comprehension...
Bacon, Sir Nicholas
Book article from: A Dictionary of British History ...He was at Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, with Matthew Parker , afterwards archbishop of Canterbury. Later, he formed...became keeper of the great seal in December 1558, and Parker archbishop of Canterbury in 1559. Fat and cheerful...
impropriations
Book article from: The Oxford Companion to British History ...servants. When the monasteries were dissolved, many appropriated monastic benefices were impropriated, causing Matthew Parker , for instance, great difficulty as primate in curbing Elizabeth's rapacious courtiers. Lay impropriators, as...
Church of England
Book article from: The Oxford Companion to British History ...though not yet schismatic, to presbyterianism or more extreme protestant views. Elizabeth and her first archbishop, Matthew Parker , used strict liturgical uniformity to mask theological differences between catholic and Calvinistic wings within...

Videos from YouTube

Find thousands of answers for hundreds of subjects at Smart QandA .

All answers verified by trusted sources at Encyclopedia.com

Try Smart QandA now!

For students and teachers!

Encyclopedia.com provides students and teachers facts, information, and biographies from verified, citable sources, including:

Encyclopedia.com provides students and teachers facts, information, and biographies from verified, citable sources, including: