Furman v. Georgia
The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States
|
2005
|
|
© The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States 2005, originally published by Oxford University Press 2005. (Hide copyright information)
Copyright
Furman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238 (1972), argued 17 Jan. 1972, decided 29 June 1972 per curiam by vote of 5 to 4; Stewart, White, Douglas, Brennan, and Marshall each concurred separately; Burger, Blackmun, Powell, and Rehnquist dissented jointly and separately. The Supreme Court, for the first time, struck down the death penalty under the
cruel and unusual punishment clause of the
Eighth Amendment. A jury in Georgia had convicted Furman for murder, and juries in Georgia and Texas had convicted two other petitioners for rape. All three juries imposed the death penalty without any specific guides or limits on their discretion. The Supreme Court in
McGautha v. California (1971) had previously held that such guidelines were unnecessary. All three petitioners were African‐American. Three justices for the majority found that jury discretion produced a random pattern among those receiving the death penalty and that this randomness was cruel and unusual. Two justices found capital punishment a per se violation of the Constitution.
More specifically, Justice William O.
Douglas concluded that death was disproportionately applied to the poor and socially disadvantaged; he virtually equated the Eighth Amendment with
equal protection values. Justice Potter
Stewart argued that the failure of the legislature to call for a mandatory death sentence, coupled with the infrequent imposition and execution of death sentences, in practice made the penalty cruel and unusual in the same way that being struck by lightning is cruel and unusual. White insisted that the infrequency of execution prevented the penalty from serving as an effective deterrent and from consistently meeting social needs for retribution. For White the penalty's social irrationality made it cruel and unusual.
Justices William
Brennan and Thurgood
Marshall both concluded that the death penalty was per se cruel and unusual. Brennan found the punishment degrading to human dignity, arbitrarily severe, and unnecessary. Marshall attacked the penalty most directly, finding it excessive, unnecessary, and offensive to contemporary values.
The dissenters argued that the courts should not challenge legislative judgments about the desirability and effectiveness of punishments. They also pointed to opinion polls showing general public support for the penalty.
Furman halted all executions in those thirty‐nine states that sanctioned the death penalty. More than six hundred people waited on death row at the time.
Furman also seemed to create three Eighth Amendment options: mandatory death sentences for crimes carefully defined by statute, development of guidelines to standardize jury discretion, and outright abolition. Of these, outright abolition was least likely, since majority of the justices acknowledged the validity of the retributive motive in punishment an only two condemned the penalty per se. But, like life and death themselves, the course of the law has taken unforeseen turns.
In
Gregg v. Georgia (1976), the Court embraced a form of guided jury discretion, although the guidelines do not systematically reduce randomness. Juries sitting in the penalty phases of capital trials as prescribed by
Gregg consider unique aggravating and mitigating circumstances in each case. This trend has effectively overruled
Furman's holding because juries, even when they operate under statutory guidelines, consider unique circumstances. This process inevitably perpetuates inconsistencies in sentencing, but the Court no longer finds these inconsistencies constitutionally unacceptable.
See also
Capital Punishment.
Lief H. Carte
Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.
|
Plantagenet Capital Receives Management Company Approval From Commission Des Operations De Bourse.
Business Wire; 12/7/1999; 563 words
; ...For European Turnaround Investments Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...in Europe and in the United States. Plantagenet is targeting 200 million euros for its FCPR, called Plantagenet Capital Europe Fund, to invest in...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Files Amended 13-D with SEC on Crown Vantage Holdings; Sees Risk of Default if Fort James-Spinoff Fails to Embrace Plan.
PR Newswire; 2/24/1999; 700+ words
; ...FRANCISCO, Feb. 24 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...Anderson, Senior Managing Partner of Plantagenet, said, "The Company is struggling...which was included in the filing, Plantagenet has recommended that Crown Vantage take...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Names Advisory Board Will Advise on Investment Strategy.
PR Newswire; 11/11/1998; 601 words
; ...FRANCISCO, Nov. 11 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...The advisors will work closely with Plantagenet, a San Francisco-based private equity...Anderson, Senior Managing Partner of Plantagenet, said, "The wealth of experience...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Files Amended 13D on Crown Vantage Holdings.
PR Newswire; 9/7/1999; 652 words
; ...FRANCISCO, Sept. 1 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...OB). The Schedule 13D states that Plantagenet believes that current Crown Vantage...current management are of doubtful value. Plantagenet does not believe that it can be viewed...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Continues Dialog with Crown Vantage Management.
PR Newswire; 3/29/1999; 659 words
; ...FRANCISCO, March 29 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...deleverage the company's balance sheet. Plantagenet has previously disclosed that it held...Anderson, Senior Managing Partner of Plantagenet, said, "The strategic alliance and...
|
|
Plantagenet takes on beer giant over deal.
News Wire article from: Australasian Business Intelligence; 2/26/2006; 566 words
; ...giant, Lion Nathan. Mt Barker-based Plantagenet Wines is suing Lion Nathan in the Perth...Lion Nathan, meanwhile, has taken Plantagenet to the New South Wales Supreme Court...2006 LION NATHAN LIMITED - ASX LNN: PLANTAGENET WINES PTY LTD: FINE WINE PARTNERS PTY...
|
|
Obituary: Plantagenet Somerset Fry
Newspaper article from: The Independent - London; 9/21/1996; ; 670 words
; Plantagenet Somerset Fry published his first book...schoolchildren. Peter George Robin Plantagenet Somerset Fry was a colourful character...kidney disease. Peter George Robin Plantagenet Somerset Fry, writer: born 3 January...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Launches Fundraising for New European Private Equity Fund; Investment Focus on Strategic Buyouts of Under-Performing Companies.
PR Newswire; 3/8/1999; 679 words
; ...FRANCISCO, March 8 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...for its third private equity fund, Plantagenet Europe Fund. The Fund, which has a...European business. C. Derek Anderson, Plantagenet's Senior Managing Partner, says...
|
|
Plantagenet Capital Names Geoffroy Surbled As Managing Director In Its French Office.
PR Newswire; 9/23/1999; 700+ words
; ...FRANCISCO, Sept. 23 /PRNewswire/ -- Plantagenet Capital Management LLC today announced...deal flow opportunities and managing Plantagenet's portfolio companies. Mr. Surbled comes to Plantagenet, which specializes in buyouts, financial...
|
|
Plantagenets at war, in fiction.(COMMENTARY)(BOOK REVIEW)(Column)
Newspaper article from: The Washington Times (Washington, DC); 9/25/2009; 700+ words
; ...hardly a household name in the roster of medieval English royalty, but this fictional account of her role as the wife of the Plantagenet Edward IV suggests she was a ruler to be reckoned with in the bloody wars between the feuding aristocratic families of York...
|
|
Plantagenet
Book article from: The Oxford Dictionary of Phrase and Fable
Plantagenet name of the English royal dynasty which held the throne from the accession of Henry II in 1154 until the death of Richard III in...
|
|
Plantagenet Palliser
Book article from: The Concise Oxford Companion to English Literature
Plantagenet Palliser, see Omnium, Duke of .
|
|
Geoffrey Plantagenet
Book article from: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition
Geoffrey Plantagenet see Geoffrey IV .
|
|
Warwick, Edward Plantagenet, 2nd earl of
Book article from: The Oxford Companion to British History
Warwick, Edward Plantagenet, 2nd earl of (1475–99). Warwick's father was George, duke of Clarence (brother of Edward IV and Richard III...
|
|
Geoffrey ‘Plantagenet’
Book article from: The Oxford Companion to British History
Geoffrey ‘Plantagenet’ (1113–51), count of Anjou (1129–51) and duke of Normandy (1144–51), became...
|