Research topic:states rights

Click to see an enlarged picture
states' rights. Wikimedia Commons (Public Domain)
Find more facts and information on our topic page about states rights

States' Rights

The Oxford Companion to United States History

States' Rights. Rooted in the classical republican view that freedom and virtue are incompatible with empire and in antifederalist fears of centralized power, the doctrine of states' rights is enshrined in several parts of the Constitution, including the guarantee of each state's equal standing in the Senate (the only provision permanently unchangeable by amendment). The most often cited guarantee of states' rights is the Tenth Amendment. To states'‐rights supporters, the amendment limits the federal government's powers to those specifically enumerated in the Constitution, and reserves all other powers of government (such as the power to create and tax corporations) to the states.

The first major confrontation between defenders of states' rights and the proponents of centralized power came in response to the Federalist party's Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, in the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, declared the acts unconstitutional and asserted that states, as parties to the constitutional “compact,” had the power to protect the liberties of their citizens and “alien friends” from federal acts that violated the compact. Nationalists on the U.S. Supreme Court under Chief Justice John Marshall restricted states' rights (and protected corporations) in such decisions as Fletcher v. Peck and McCulloch v. Maryland, but the issue remained unsettled.

In the second major confrontation, during the War of 1812, commercially minded New England Federalists convened the 1814 Hartford Convention, which denounced what they considered the dangerous imperialism of the Republicans in Washington and asserted the rights of states to refuse to authorize the conscription and taxation needed to support “Mr. Madison's War.”

In the third major confrontation, the nullification crisis of 1828–1832, involving the federal tariff, the doctrine became associated with John C. Calhoun, who had earlier opposed states' rights. Calhoun's major opponent on nullification, President Andrew Jackson, was also inconsistent: Like many Democratic party leaders, Jackson supported states' rights on most matters. Although states' rights doctrine was increasingly tied to the defense of slavery, some abolitionists invoked it in their efforts to thwart the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 (e.g., in Ableman v. Booth, 1859).

While South Carolina had stood alone on nullification, proslavery politicians espoused other versions of states' rights doctrine, eventually taking the ultimate step of secession. Their advocacy of the doctrine returned to haunt them as the Confederate States of America struggled for wartime unity and discipline in the fourth major confrontation, the Civil War. In State Rights in the Confederacy (1925), Frank Lawrence Owsley noted the central irony that in order to defend states' rights effectively, the Confederacy's leaders would have had to crush them.

After the Civil War, opponents of African‐American rights embraced states' rights. Although the Supreme Court again restricted state power to regulate corporations in the 1880s and 1890s, it supported broad state power to enforce racial segregation. The principal twentieth‐century uses of the doctrine were to ward off federal anti‐lynching laws and to defend racial segregation. Opponents of federal economic regulation sometimes invoked the doctrine as well.

After World War II, liberals generally condemned states' rights through a kind of guilt‐by‐association with slavery and segregation. With Brown v. Board of Education and related decisions, the Supreme Court under Earl Warren brought civil rights law into line with broader nationalistic trends. After the 1960s, the doctrine moved to the margins of American political culture, although conservatives, including Ronald Reagan, invoked it occasionally in rhetorical thrusts at “big government” and the massive federal budget. Subsequently, under William Rehnquist's chief justiceship (1986– ) a narrow majority on the Court resuscitated states' rights for some purposes, but it was not clear how durable these decisions would be. Curiously, despite its historical roots in the defense of civil liberties, immigrant rights, and anti‐imperialism, late twentieth century nonconservative opponents of centralized power (governmental and corporate) found little merit in the doctrine.
See also Bill of Rights; Conservatism; Early Republic, Era of the; Federalism; Liberalism; Federalism; Republicanism; Revolution and Constitution, Era of; States' Rights Party.

Bibliography

Alpheus Thomas Mason , The States' Rights Debate: Antifederalism and the Constitution, 1964.
Chester James Antineau , States' Rights under Federal Constitutions, 1984.

David L. Chappell


Find more facts and information related to the .
© The Oxford Companion to United States History 2001, originally published by Oxford University Press 2001.

Related newspaper, magazine, and trade journal articles from HighBeam Research

(Including press releases, facts, information, and biographies)

Lott's gone, but GOP still grapples with states' rights
; ...Lott's gone, but GOP still grapples with states' rights E.J. DIONNE Date: 12-22-2002, Sunday...defense of segregation. The principle was states' rights. It's not surprising that Republicans...contemporary Republicans are as committed to states' rights doctrines as he is. This creates ... Read more
Statehood as the new personhood: the discovery of fundamental "states' rights".
; ...State Sovereignty: State Powers Versus States' Rights 1. Rights, Powers, and Institutions...Jurisprudential Anomaly of Fundamental States' Rights B. Sovereigns, Persons, and Constitutional...reality, or more likely because of it, states' rights has experienced a renaissance in our... Read more
When States' Rights Get in the Way
; ...painfully obvious again: The doctrine of states' rights, so often invoked as a principle, is...one decision after another supporting states' rights would shudder at the idea of the federal...included the three most reliable states' rights votes on the court, Justices Clarence... Read more
Analysis: States' rights as a political tool for both parties
; ...NPR) 11-30-2004 Analysis: States' rights as a political tool for both...In years past, the phrase `states' rights' was enough to send liberals...barricades. In the 19th century, states' rights was the banner of cessation... Read more
States' Rights' and the Union: Imperium in Imperio, 1776-1876
; States' Rights and the Union: Imperium in Imperio...repeatedly likes to remind us these days, states' rights is not some moldy-oldie concept to...of the formative first century of states' rights. Imperium in imperio is no longer... Read more
States' rights are pitifully overblown: ; W.Va., like S.C., is both too small and way too big
; ...of the Confederacy. The principle of "states' rights," of course, is sacred in Tupelo. Our...cluttered and altogether unhandsome. States' rights? Why should we clamor for states' rights as long as Bob Byrd delivers the boodle... Read more
The foreign affairs powers of the U.S. Executive in light of changing conceptions of states' rights
; ...Amendment controversy in the early 1950s. States' rights partisans in Congress, especially those...by a single vote in the Senate, but states' rights issues in the foreign arena are now...seemingly discovered the virtues of states' rights in connection with Natsios v. National... Read more
States' rights rolls back democracy. (Originated from Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service)
; ...is neither. Throughout our history, states' rights have been invoked to roll back democracy. The first great evocation of states' rights in this tradition occurred in 1832...Calhoun of South Carolina, champion of states' rights, against President Andrew Jackson... Read more
Liberal pols using states rights dodge.(Editorial)
; ...Thomas M. Keane Jr. Forty years ago, states' rights were regarded as a transparent effort...constitutional amendment banning gay marriage. States' rights, it turns out, are important when they...discovered the deeply vital principle of states' rights. Marriage was never a federal ... Read more
States' Rights and the Union: Imperium in Imperio, 1776-1876.
; ...repeatedly likes to remind us these days, states' rights is not some moldy-oldie concept to...survey of the formative first century of states' rights. Imperium in imperio is no longer a...is somewhat less than monographic. States' Rights and the Union provides a concise, lively... Read more

Related entries from encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauruses

states' rights
states' rights the rights and powers held by individual states rather than by the federal government. Read more
states' rights
states' rights • pl. n. the rights and powers held by individual U.S. states rather than by the federal government. Read more
states' rights
states' rights In the USA, the doctrine that the states have authority in matters not delegated to the federal government. The controversy between federal and state jurisdiction reached...This led to the Nullification Crisis (1832) and contributed to secession and the Civil War . It was also an issue during ... Read more
State Sovereignty and States' Rights
State Sovereignty and States' Rights doctrines emphasize ambiguities...revitalized by the Rehnquist Court. States' rights doctrine's main constitutional...see Commerce Power ). Two bold states' rights and sovereignty assertions, interposition... Read more
states' rights
states' rights A US political doctrine that upholds the rights of individual states against the power of the federal government...reserved to the states. The doctrine of states' rights lay behind the NULLIFICATION Crisis... Read more

Related research topics

Online videos

What is Real State's Rights

For Students and teachers!

HighBeam Encyclopedia provides students and teachers facts, information, and biographies from verified, citable sources, including:

HighBeam Encyclopedia provides students and teachers facts, information, and biographies from verified, citable sources, including: