Close

Create a link to this page

Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:

<a href="http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G2-2536601719.html" title="Facts and informations about The Gospel of Wealth">The Gospel of Wealth</a>

The Gospel of Wealth

The Gospel of Wealth

Sources

Working Hard. Industrialization created amazing disparities between rich and poor in the United States, and the rapid pace of change concerned many American Protestants. One early, but prominent, stream of Protestant reaction emphasized acquiescence to the social consequences of industrialization. Many regarded this tendency as an unexpected result of the growing liberal practice of loosening the doctrinal restrictions that had bound preceding generations. Prominent liberal Protestant clergymen followed the lead of Henry Ward Beecher in blessing the new industrial order. Protestantism carried over from the eighteenth century the Calvinistic belief that God created the world with an intrinsic system of rewards and punishments. Under the divine scheme, those who worked and lived ethically prospered, while the lazy or irresponsible poor suffered deservedly from poverty. Beecher insisted that “even in the most compact and closely-populated portions of the East, he that will be frugal and save continuously, living every day within the bounds of his means, can scarcely help accumulating.” This doctrine made sense to middle-class Protestants, who were prospering as a group, but it ignored the reality that the wages of most working-class families fell far short of sufficiency. In the view of the emerging Protestant middle class and elite, the key to both success and holiness was for individuals to help themselves. This strong cultural preference often led to the assumption that wealth was a sign of spiritual attainment. As William Lawrence, an Episcopal bishop, put it, “Godliness is in league with riches.” This was comforting news to the Protestant elite as they sat in the pews of the magnificent new urban churches and listened to sermons by Beecher and other “princes of the pulpit.”

Opportunity. The reverence for worldly success was widely accepted outside the boundaries of the new industrial elite, in part because it resonated so strongly with values inherited from an earlier period of American history. The Baptist minister Russell Conwell emerged as a celebrated proponent of the gospel of opportunity. Conwell delivered his famous sermon, “Acres of Diamonds,” an estimated six thousand times to audiences estimated at thirteen million in the closing decades of the century. The sermon recounted the allegedly factual case of a farmer who lived in destitution until he began to work his land conscientiously. In the course of plowing vigorously, the farmer discovered “acres of diamonds” on the land. Conwell rejected suggestions that pursuit of wealth was spiritually corrupting. “To make money honestly is to preach the gospel,” he claimed. In modern America, he asserted, any upright and hardworking individual could discover success “in his own backyard.”

Responsibility. Conwell and others in the tradition also emphasized honesty, charity, and civic responsibility. Because of his vast wealth and willingness to write and speak publicly about his moral, economic, and political ideas, the steel magnate Andrew Carnegie was one of the best-known religious skeptics of the era. In 1889 he wrote a book called The Gospel of Wealth, which espoused Conwell’s beliefs. (A British editor writing a headline for Carnegie’s 1889 essay titled “Wealth” actually coined the phrase “Gospel of Wealth.”) Carnegie believed in the central moral and economic role of moneymaking: “Don’t shoot the millionaire, for he is the bee that makes the honey.” He stressed, however, that the rich had both the moral right to complete control of their wealth and a moral obligation to use their wealth for the public good. “This then is the duty of the man of wealth,” Carnegie wrote, “to set an example of modest, unostentatious living, shunning display or extravagance; to provide moderately for the legitimate wants of those dependent on him; and after doing so, to consider all surplus revenues which come to him simply as trust funds, which he is called upon to administer, and strictly bound as a matter of duty to administer in the manner which, in his judgment, is best calculated to produce the most beneficial results for the community.” As American industry expanded, however, the individualistic Protestant ethic supporting unrestrained expansion to maximize profits tended to overwhelm such moral restraints. In practice, this approach meant that many Protestants absolved the economic sphere of life from the moral and religious constraints they still sought to apply to personal relationships.

Sources

Agnes Rush Burr, Russell H. Conwell and His Work: One Man’s Interpretation of Life (Philadelphia: Winston, 1926);

Joseph Frazier Wall, The Andrew Carnegie Reader (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1992).

Related newspaper, magazine, and trade journal articles from HighBeam Research

(Including press releases, facts, information, and biographies)

	Schneider, Michael. The Distribution of Wealth.(Book Review) Magazine article from: International Social Science Review; 9/22/2005; ; 700+ words ; Schneider, Michael. The Distribution of Wealth. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing...pp. Cloth, $85.00. The Distribution of Wealth is a valuable addition to the paucity...addressing inequality in the distribution of wealth which is far more unequal than the well... Read more
	Splitting up drops wealth by 77%.(Divorce)(Brief article) Magazine article from: USA Today (Magazine); 4/1/2006; 234 words ; Divorce reduces a person's wealth by 77% compared to that of a single person, while being married increases comparative wealth by 93%. Moreover, people who get divorced see their wealth begin to drop long before the decree becomes... Read more
	Examining: "redistribution of wealth". Magazine article from: National Voter; 2/1/2009; ; 700+ words ; Redistribution of wealth was all the rage following a five-minute...everybody ... I think when you spread the wealth around, it's good for everybody. (1...with the charge of redistribution of wealth when interviewed by commentator Bill O'Re... Read more
	Wealth and its distribution, 1983-1992: secular growth, cyclical stability. Magazine article from: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review; 1/1/1997; ; 700+ words ; ...describes the changes in the distribution of wealth among U.S. households that occurred between...cycle (Weicher, 1995). The distribution of wealth has received extended popular attention...apparent changes in the distribution of wealth do not pass conventional tests of statistical... Read more
	God's stewards: the earth's wealth is really the Lord's; the responsibility to use it for the benefit of all is clearly ours.(Wealth And Responsibility) Magazine article from: National Catholic Reporter; 3/11/2005; ; 700+ words ; It might be useful at the outset to distinguish wealth from income. Wealth, although it can be lost, suggests stability, while...held in reserve), it will make no contribution to wealth. Moreover, one can be a recipient of passive income... Read more
	Disasters, income, and wealth.(FED @ ISSUE) Magazine article from: EconSouth; 3/22/2006; ; 700+ words ; ...and destruction of physical property and wealth. Although we tit to minimize or mitigate...mitigate the risk of the loss of physical wealth, we often insure our possessions. Then...involve the systematic destruction of wealth in a concentrated geographic area. Natural... Read more
	Making the right stuff: wealth or consumption? Magazine article from: Synthesis/Regeneration; 1/1/2007; ; 700+ words ; Economical use of wealth means to conserve it, to make it last...economic thinking. If consumers merely use wealth the consumer economy seems harmless...really works because it tries to use-up wealth. If consumption means use-up then we... Read more
	The rich and the poor: demographics of the U.S. wealth distribution. Magazine article from: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review; 7/1/1997; ; 700+ words ; ...interest in the distribution and concentration of wealth in the United States. Wealth is much more concentrated than income. The wealthiest...holdings. The data are drawn from surveys of household wealth conducted for the Federal Reserve Board in 1983... Read more
	Black/white differences in wealth.(Statistical Data Included) Magazine article from: Economic Perspectives; 3/22/2000; ; 700+ words ; Introduction and summary The gap in wealth holdings between African-Americans and white...and Jianakoplos (1997) find that the average wealth of black households is 20 percent of the average wealth of white households in the 1976 National Longitudinal... Read more
	The Challenge of Wealth.(The Challenge of Wealth: Managing the Joys, Responsibilities, and Opportunities That Come with Wealth )(Brief article)(Book review) Newspaper article from: Library Bookwatch; 7/1/2006; 186 words ; The Challenge Of Wealth Erlend Peterson Seven Locks Press PO Box...certified financial planner in The Challenge Of Wealth: Managing The Joys, Responsibilities, And Opportunities That Come With Wealth to create an informed and informative guide... Read more

For more facts and information, see all related premium articles

Related entries from encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauruses

	Gospel of Wealth, The Book article from: The Oxford Companion to American Literature Gospel of Wealth, The, essay by Andrew Carnegie . Read more
	Social Christianity, Christian Socialism, and the Social Gospel Book article from: American Decades ...CHRISTIAN SOCIALISM, AND THE SOCIAL GOSPEL The Social Crisis American society at...late-nineteenth-century liberal Protestant Gospel of Wealth, which made poverty a sin and prosperity...churches, remained small. The Social Gospel The advocates for a social gospel, less extreme than the ... Read more
	Gospels of Henry the Lion Book article from: The Oxford Dictionary of Art Gospels of Henry the Lion. An illuminated manuscript of the Four Gospels made c. 1175–80 for Henry the Lion ( c. 1129–...abundant use of gold, and was intended to symbolize Henry's wealth and power and to set forth his claim (which remained unfulfilled... Read more
	wealth Book article from: A Dictionary of the Bible wealth In OT times wealth was measured in terms of cattle or sheep and silver and gold...assist the poor (2 Cor. 8: 8–10), the possession of wealth is viewed more negatively, especially in the gospel of Luke (6: 20–1, 24–9). Any display of luxury... Read more
	Carnegie, Andrew Book article from: The Concise Oxford Companion to English Literature Carnegie, Andrew (1835–1919), one of the foremost ironmasters of the United States. In 1900 he published The Gospel of Wealth , maintaining that a ‘man who dies rich dies disgraced’; the most important of his many benefactions... Read more

See all related entries