Close

Create a link to this page

Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:

<a href="http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G2-2536601673.html" title="Facts and informations about Obscenity and the Law">Obscenity and the Law</a>

Obscenity and the Law

Obscenity and the Law

Sources

Lucifer, the Light-Bearer . In the later half of the

nineteenth century, conservative moral crusaders such as Anthony Comstock, who had lobbied for the 1873 “Comstock Law” barring obscene material from the U.S. mail, struggled against purveyors of obscenity and a growing cadre of men and women who advocated frank discussion of sex, birth control, woman’s rights in marriage, and other controversial issues. The 1873 law was very strict and defined any mention of sexual relations as obscenity. It was, therefore, simply impossible to address sexual issues without breaking the law. The struggle between moral reformers such as Comstock and more-libertarian individuals can be seen in a case involving a citizen of Valley Falls, Kansas, who published a weekly newspaper called Lucifer, the Light-Bearer. The newspaper had for a motto “Perfect freedom of thought and action for every individual within the limits of his own personality. Self-government is the only true government. Liberty and responsibility the only basis of morality.”

The Case. In 1891 the publisher oí Lucifer, a quiet, sixty-year-old man named Moses Harmon, was indicted for violating the 1873 law by placing an obscene publication in the mail. Harmon maintained that he published his paper in order to educate people. For example, he attacked the prevailing sexual ethics that subjected women to the brutal lusts of their husbands. Though Lucifer contained some general news and political commentary, much of it discussed sexual relations. Harmon’s lawyer tried to have the court consider all of Lucifer, not just the passages the prosecutor selected out as obscene. By seeing these passages in their proper context, Harmon’s lawyer reasoned, the court would I understand that his client’s purpose was to improve and not corrupt morals. Judge John F. Phillips of the federal district court of western Missouri rejected this strategy and dismissed Harmon’s argument that he printed his paper as a public service, not to gratify men’s baser lusts. In fact, Harmon’s argument reminded the judge of Charles Guiteau’s reasons for killing President James Garfield. “Guiteau stoutly maintained to the end his sanity, and that he felt he had a patriotic mission to fulfill in taking off President Garfield, to the salvation of a political party. The Hindu mother cast her babe to the adoring Ganges to appease the gods. But civilized society says both are murders.”

Obscenity in the Mail. Having equated Harmon with presidential assassin Guiteau, Phillips discussed the role of courts in upholding public morality. “Where vituperation or licentiousness begins, liberty of the press ends.” In determining obscenity, the court had to decide how the language in question would be received by a man or woman of average intelligence and sensibility. “The subjects discussed and the language employed are too coarse and indecent for the man of average education and refinement to recapitulate.” The court warned that “the appetite for such literature increases with the feeding. The more it is pandered to, the more insatiable its craving for something yet more vicious in taste. And while it may be conceded . . . that the federal government, under its constitutional limitation, ought not to take upon itself the office of censor morum, nor undertake to legislate . . . the private morals of the people, yet Congress may, as the basis of legislation of this character, have regard to the common consensus of the people that a thing is malum in se — is hurtful to the public morals, — endangering the public welfare, and therefore deny to it as a vehicle of dissemination the use of its post-offices and post-roads, devised and maintained by the government at the public expense for the purpose of promoting the public welfare and common good.”

Intention and Knowledge. The decision in the Harmon case gave sanction to the idea that prevailing community standards should define obscenity while Congress could prevent the public circulation of all offensive material. In some cases, however, this approach actually aided the distribution of such literature. For example, when Elmina Slenker of Snowville, Virginia, was convicted in 1887 for mailing some writings, including the essay “The Girl and the Dog,” her conviction was overturned. While Slenker had placed the pamphlets in the mail, the prosecution had not shown that she knew their content, or knew they would be considered obscene. In an 1894 case a New York court rejected Corns rock’s contention that certain books were obscene after it compared them with standard works of literature. However, these cases were exceptions; men or women who knowingly distributed material that the community regarded as obscene were usually punished in the late nineteenth century.

Sources

Heywood Broun and Margaret Leech, Anthony Comstock: Roundsman of the Lord (New York: Albert & Charles Boni, 1927).

Related newspaper, magazine, and trade journal articles from HighBeam Research

(Including press releases, facts, information, and biographies)

	Age of First Experience of Sexual Relations and Corresponding Attitudes.(surveys)(Brief Article) Magazine article from: The Journal of Sex Research; 2/1/2006; 280 words ; Age of First Experience of Sexual Relations and Corresponding Attitudes, Dolores...data concerning the prevalence of sexual relations throughout the life cycle, but in...Among boys, first experiences of sexual relations occurred at ages 11-12 in 14% of cases... Read more
	Public Welfare Attorneys hold successful training conference.(affiliates' corner)(Brief article) Magazine article from: Policy & Practice; 12/1/2005; 281 words ; The American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys (AAPWA), an APHSA affiliate...counsel at the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare, received the Thomas J. Blazusiak Memorial...has made outstanding contributions in public welfare law or policy. Plans are underway for... Read more
	AAPWA meets in Minneapolis.(affiliates' corner)(American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys)(Brief article)(Conference notes) Magazine article from: Policy & Practice; 10/1/2008; 282 words ; The American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys held its 41st Annual...The American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys has been the premier...for attorneys representing public welfare agencies in 50 states. AAPWA... Read more
	Judge Denies Janice Holyfield's Motion To Dismiss Divorce Action Filed By Husband Evander Holyfield. Magazine article from: Jet; 6/14/1999; 292 words ; ...testified that she and the champ have had sexual relations four times since he filed for divorce...remember if he did or did not have sexual relations with his wife during that time. No...Judge Ben Miller said he did not think sexual relations necessarily equal marital ... Read more
	Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare.(newsmakers)(Thomas Blazusiak appointed as president of American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys)(Brief Article) Magazine article from: Policy & Practice; 12/1/2004; 31 words ; Thomas Blazusiak, senior attorney at the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare, has been elected president of American Association of Public Welfare Attorneys at the group's conference in September. Read more
	The American Association of public welfare Attoneys.(affiliates' corner)(Brief article) Magazine article from: Policy & Practice; 12/1/2008; 220 words ; The American Association of Public Welfare Attoneys held its 41st Annual Conference...Garvey, Shubert, Barer. The American of Public Welfare Attorneys is the Premier organization...attorneys representing state and local public welfare/human service agenices. AAPWA's annual... Read more
	Re-establishing intimacy.(Brief Article) Magazine article from: Soldiers Magazine; 8/1/2003; 241 words ; ...Barriers to intimate communication and sexual relations may include: * Unrealistic fantasies...your relationship; * Feelings that sexual relations to be rushed to make up for lost time...Partners shouldn't anticipate normal sexual relations for a few days, and should remember... Read more
	When does a woman give valid consent to sexual relations?(Consent to Sexual Relations)(Book Review) Magazine article from: The Journal of Sex Research; 8/1/2005; ; 700+ words ; Consent to Sexual Relations, by Alan Wertheimer. Cambridge...Wertheimer, the author of Consent to Sexual Relations, was once such a student (albeit...woman gives valid consent to sexual relations. In the introductory chapter... Read more
	Attorney-client sex: too close for comfort?(disciplinary actions, malpractice liability may arise from consensual sex between attorneys and clients) Magazine article from: Trial; 8/1/1999; ; 700+ words ; ...client can never truly consent, and any sexual relations with a client during representation...centered on whether attorney-client sexual relations should be a per se violation of the...absolute rules regulating attorney-client sexual relations.(11) Each state's rule is different... Read more
	Unisys chosen by Pennsylvania Dept of Public Welfare for network upgrade.(Brief Article) Newspaper article from: Telecomworldwire; 10/12/2001; 140 words ; TELECOMWORLDWIRE-12 October 2001-Unisys chosen by Pennsylvania Dept of Public Welfare for network upgrade (C)1994-2001 M2 COMMUNICATIONS LTD http...technology and services upgrade to the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare's (DPW) Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement System (PACSES... Read more

For more facts and information, see all related premium articles

Related entries from encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauruses

Obscenity and the Law Book article from: American Eras Obscenity and the Law Lucifer, the Light-Bear...x201C; Comstock Law ” barring...against purveyors of obscenity and a growing cadre...issues. The 1873 law was very strict and...sexual relations as obscenity. It was, therefore...without breaking the law. The struggle ... Read more

See all related entries