City Beautiful: The Rise of Urban Planning
City Beautiful: The Rise of Urban Planning
Sources
A Changing Balance. At the start of the Civil War only one out of twelve Americans lived in a city of more than one hundred thousand inhabitants. By the start of the 1880s that figure stood at one in eight; by the turn of the century one in five. More American cities were big cities, and more Americans—many of them immigrants—called these cities home. Two-thirds of New England townships declined in population during the 1880s, even as the population of the region swelled by 20 percent. Similar demographics applied in the Midwest, as immigrants (from small towns, rural areas, and foreign lands) swelled urban populations. As cities expanded, so too did the communication, transportation, and economic channels connecting the metropolis to hinterland. It was the rare individual in the late nineteenth century whose way of life was not touched in some way by urbanization.
The Other Half. The depressions (or “panics”) of the 1870s and 1890s devastated rural populations, as failures of railroads severely hampered the farmers’ ability to get their crops to market. Still, no matter how shaky their financial status, residents of the small town and the countryside enjoyed one advantage over city dwellers: the relief of open space. While investigating urban living conditions, Danish-born journalist Jacob Riis (1849-1914) counted 522 people living in one acre in the Bowery district of New York City. Small rooms—measuring just thirteen feet square—housed as many as a dozen lodgers. Riis’s epochal study of city life, How the Other Half Lives (1890), located a netherworld of poverty within walking distance of the poshest New York neighborhoods. Using photographs and text, Riis depicted an urban hell and entered a plea for urban reform. In many respects, Riis was a precursor of the “muckrakers” who transformed American journalism during the early years of the twentieth century. Riis considered it a journalist’s duty to educate the public and to stimulate reaction and reform. “Long ago it was said that ‘one half of the world does not know how the other half lives,’” Riis noted. “It did not know because it did not care. . . . Information on the subject has been accumulating rapidly since, and the whole world has had its hands full answering for its own ignorance.” The essential optimism of Riis’s vision dovetailed with that of the city planners who set out to remodel the American city in the 1890s.
Making the Cities Beautiful. Late-nineteenth-century reformers worked—with varying degrees of success—to revise tenement laws, construct affordable and sanitary housing, provide cultural and recreational opportunities for the poor, and eliminate graft from municipal government. Many reformers and social workers were associated with the settlement-house movement: residents of Hull House in Chicago or the Henry Street Settlement in New York lived by choice in povertystricken neighborhoods, the better to form meaningful bonds with the populations they intended to aid. While reformers worked through political and philanthropic channels, urban planners approached the question of urban renewal from an aesthetic perspective. Calibrating the salutary effect of urban oases (whether a park, a museum, or a railroad station) on urban dwellers, these landscape architects set out to transform the built environment.
Olmsted’s Vision. Frederick Law Olmsted (1822-1903), arguably the most influential urban planner in the United States, worked to turn American cities green. European cities, Olmsted noted, gracefully integrated parks, grand avenues, and residential neighborhoods. American cities, on the other hand, had been built up, block by block, by profit-hungry developers. Olmsted believed that open space—scarce in American cities—could be an antidote to the pressures of urban existence. Public parks, he proclaimed in 1870, represented “the greatest possible contrast with the restraining and confining conditions of the town, which compel us to walk circumspectly, watchfully, jealously, which compel us to look closely upon others without sympathy.” Along with Calvert Vaux (1824-1895) Olmsted designed the gardens, ponds, meadows, and pathways that coalesced into New York’s Central Park in the 1860s and 1870s. In 1893 he designed a fairyland of lagoons, squares, and boulevards for the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago. During the same decade Olmsted completed the complex of parks and riverways that became Boston’s “Emerald Necklace.” The joggers, dog walkers, and rollerbladers who throng Central Park or Boston’s Esplanade today validate Olmsted’s vision of healthy communal living.
Reclaiming L’Enfant’s Plan. The urban muddle of the late nineteenth century was particularly apparent in the premier “planned” American city: Washington, D.C. The Washington of the 1890s barely resembled the crisp grid of avenues and parks envisioned by planner Pierre-Charles L’Enfant (1754-1825) in the 1790s. The restoration of Washington to a closer approximation of L’Enfant’s vision represents the crowning accomplishment of the “City Beautiful” movement in America. Daniel Burnham—head architect of the World’s Columbian Exposition—served on a Senate Park Commission charged with resuscitating the nation’s capital. From 1901 to 1908 Burnham oversaw the construction of monumental buildings along the major axes of the city, the sprucing up of the Mall, and the clearing of parkland along the Potomac. By the early twentieth century Washington had been transformed into a national showpiece. Burnham’s theory of urban renewal—sketched out in later, largely unimplemented plans for San Francisco, Cleveland, and Chicago—emphasized the classical, the monumentai, the orderly, and the beautiful. Yet his concept of the City Beautiful largely ignored the commercial vitality and (often healthy) disorder of the Modern metropolis. American cities, from the late nineteenth century to the present, have stood witness to the ongoing interplay of chaos and order.
Charles E. Beveridge, Frederick Law Olmsted: Designing the American Landscape (New York: Rizzoli, 1995);
Thomas S. Hines, Burnham of Chicago, Architect and Planner (New York: Oxford University Press, 1974);
Vincent Scully, American Architecture and Urbanism, revised edition (New York: Holt, 1988);
William H. Wilson, The City Beautiful Movement (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1989).
Cite this article
Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.
|
Paying more for less: wave of the future?(New York Metropolitian Transportation Authority raises fares, cuts services)
Magazine article from: Railway Age; 11/1/1995; ; 609 words
; New York is not alone among American cities whose transit systems are...action. But the sheer size of New York's system--coupled with NJ...ridership in the nation--makes New York a macrocosm of what could...riders elsewhere. And for New York riders, the ...
Read more
|
|
(book reviews)
Magazine article from: Commonweal; 2/23/1996; ; 700+ words
; ...helped to distinguish American cities from European ones...one that includes New York, Toronto, the upstate...asked him why North American cities aren't like those...the development of American cities against the background...
Read more
|
|
Julia Vitullo-Martin.(Summer Reading)(Waterfront: A Journey around Manhattan)(The Outlaw Sea: A World of Freedom, Chaos and Crime)(The Ordinary Seaman)(The Dialectical Development of Doctrine: A Methodological Approach)(Book Review)
Magazine article from: Commonweal; 6/18/2004; ; 700+ words
; ...as a walk around many major American cities reminds us. Even as waterfront...water. The archipelago of New York, probably one of the greatest...432 pp.). Lopate writes of New York's transition from a working...impression. The truth is that New York's rivers remain ...
Read more
|
|
LETTER FROM NEW YORK.
Magazine article from: The Architectural Review; 11/1/1999; ; 700+ words
; As the great economic boom in the United States continues to roar on, American cities, particularly New York, are being transformed, and not usually for the better. What had been one of the few American cities with a delicate downtown is being radically altered in scale, mix and quality ...
Read more
|
|
Exhibit explores legacy of neighborhood activist.(INSIDE CONSTRUCTION & DESIGN)
Magazine article from: Real Estate Weekly; 9/5/2007; 260 words
; The Municipal Art Society of New York, through sponsorship from the Rockefeller...text, The Death and Life of Great American Cities. The exhibit highlights the context...wrote The Death and Life of Great American Cities, while also illustrating the role of Jane Jacobs's ideas in today's ...
Read more
|
|
Rachmanioff in Winnipeg: the Band of the Princess Patricia's regiment meets a Russian master.
Magazine article from: Manitoba History; 9/22/2000; ; 700+ words
; ...great demand in many North American cities for exposure to the best...came to be visiting North American cities in the 1920s as a concert...It was premiered by the New York Symphony under the baton...the Philadelphia and the New York Philharmonic. The ...
Read more
|
|
2000 volunteers try to count New York's homeless.(Shelter)(Brief Article)
Magazine article from: Community Action; 3/21/2005; 199 words
; NEW YORK -- Over 2000 volunteers went onto New York City streets on an early March night to count the homeless...time similar efforts were being made in a number of large American cities. The purpose of the count was to strengthen their request for additional funding from the federal ...
Read more
|
|
Municipal fiscal strain: indicators and causes.
Magazine article from: Government Finance Review; 6/1/1994; ; 700+ words
; ...is a central concern for American cities. The history of fiscal...but from the 1930s to the New York fiscal crisis in the mid-197...analysis. Yet with the New York fiscal crisis, it became clear that if New York City could default, so...
Read more
|
|
Jacobs exhibit.(AROUND TOWN: EVENTS SEMINARS MEETINGS TALKS)
Magazine article from: Real Estate Weekly; 12/12/2007; 94 words
; ...Jan. 5: The Municipal Art Society of New York has launched a multi-faceted project...classic text, The Death and Life of Great American Cities. Jane Jacobs and the Future of New York, applies Jacobs' principles to contemporary New York while seeking to initiate a ...
Read more
|
|
Minimal art with maximum impact. (painter Tony Smith)
Magazine article from: Interview; 9/1/1998; ; 311 words
; ...for the black geometric voids that stud civic plazas in New York City, Detroit, Washington, D.C., and other American cities, Smith refused to be pigeonholed and worked variously as...first-ever retrospective at the Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) in New York City (through September 22), ...
Read more
|
|
City Planning
Encyclopedia entry from: Gale Encyclopedia of U.S. Economic History
CITY PLANNING City planning is a process by...organization of a city is determined by...which are quite beautiful and take good advantage...typified this kind of city planning. In the United States...became known as the City Beautiful Movement. In ...
Read more
|
|
1878-1899: The Arts: Topics in the News
Book article from: American Eras
...Romanticism in Art The Birth of the Skyscraper The Brooklyn Bridge The Chicago Style of Architecture City Beautiful: The Rise of Urban Planning Dime Novels and Historical Romances Founding the Metropolitan Opera From Minstrel Stage to Broadway...
Read more
|