Detainee operations and the law of war.(Commentary & Reply)(Letter to the Editor)

From: Parameters | Date: September 22, 2005| Author: Rehkopf, Donald G., Jr.; Hoffman, Michael H. | Copyright information

To the Editor:

Michael Hoffman's article, "Rescuing the Law of War: A Way Forward in an Era of Global Terrorism" (Parameters, Summer 2005), contains so many fundamental flaws in legal scholarship, errors of basic constitutional law, and factual fallacies that it verges on Administration propaganda. (1)

Allow me to provide three examples of significant distortions. First, Hoffman argues that "Rasul v. Bush ... establishes that unlawful belligerents have a righ...

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

Freedom: ; Habeas corpus vital
Charleston Gazette ; Most Americans don't understand it, but habeas corpus is a cornerstone of personal liberty underlying democracy. It prevents a despot from locking you in a cell interminably, allowing you no right to challenge your incarceration. Latin for "you have the body," it's a writ commanding jailers to
High court orders fast review of law: Act restricts habeas corpus appeals.(A)
The Washington Times ; The Supreme Court yesterday ordered an extraordinarily expedited hearing on a new anti-terrorism law curbing the court's authority and restricting repeated habeas corpus appeals, including those from death row. Using a procedure reserved for the most important constitutional matters - particularly
Supreme Court to Hear Death-Row Habeas-Corpus Arguments
Morning Edition (NPR) ; 00-00-0000 Today, the Supreme Court will look at the Felker vs. Terkin case to determine the constitutionality of a limitation on death-penalty appeals by provisions of the anti-terrorism law Congress passed in April. BOB EDWARDS, Host: This is Morning Edition. I'm Bob Edwards. Today, the Supreme
Crimes against habeas corpus; Congress's drive-by killing.
The Nation ; With its myriad new death-penalty offenses, three-strikes provisions, mandatory minimums and moneys for prisons and police, Congress left only one thing out of its much-vaunted new crime package: any protection for Americans' most basic constitutional rights. In their poll-driven stampede to look
DETAINEES DESERVE HABEAS CORPUS.(Editorial)
Seattle Post-Intelligencer (Seattle, WA) ; Byline: DAVID S. MARSHALL GUEST COLUMNIST On Wednesday the U.S. Supreme Court will again peer into the hell hole with the beguilingly syncopated name: Guantanamo. Lawyers representing Guantanamo prisoners will argue that the hundreds of alleged terrorists locked up there have the right to habeas