The old (electoral) college cheer: why we have it; why we need it.

From: National Review | Date: November 8, 2004| Author: Uhlmann, Michael M. | Copyright information

AS the late Rodney Dangerfield might say, the Electoral College just don't get no respect. Polls show that most Americans, given the opportunity, would cashier it tomorrow in favor of so-called direct election. That they'd live to regret their decision only reminds us of H. L. Mencken's definition of democracy: a form of government in which the people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard. What the people would get by choosing direct election is the disintegratio...

Read all of this article with a FREE trial to HighBeam Research

Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles from HighBeam Research

SA: O Donoghue won t act as spoiler for direct election
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-07-1999 SA: O Donoghue won t act as spoiler for direct election ADELAIDE, Nov 7 AAP - Aboriginal leader and republican ...
A not-so-distant mirror: the 17th Amendment and congressional change. (provision for direct election of U.S. senators)
American Political Science Review ; The selection of U.S. senators by state legislators occurred for the last time in November 1912. Just a few months later, on May 31, 1913, the 17th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution went into effect. It brought down the curtain on indirect elections by altering Article 1, Section 3, such that
Beilin to ask ministers to back abolition of direct- election law
Jerusalem Post ; DAVID HARRIS Jerusalem Post 08-03-1999 Justice Minister Yossi Beilin intends to ask the ministerial committee on legislation to support a private member's bill which calls for the abolition of the direct election of the prime minister, despite the opposition of Prime Minister Ehud Barak. "I'm
FED: Howard backs Carr in rejecting direct election vote
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-03-1999 FED: Howard backs Carr in rejecting direct election vote Prime Minister JOHN HOWARD has backed New South ...
SA: Direct election republicans courted by both sides in SA
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-04-1999 SA: Direct election republicans courted by both sides in SA ADELAIDE, Nov 4 AAP - Direct election republicans ...
Don't circumvent the constitution: perhaps direct election of the president is a good idea. But trying to work around the Constitution isn't.(CON)(Essay)
State Legislatures ; In Federalist No. 10, James Madison identified our Constitution with popular government. Power belongs to the people, but popular government does not mean unimpeded majority rule. Instead, the Founders sought to constitute the will of the people through institutions that restrained and refined the
VIC: Direct election battle just beginning
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-06-1999 VIC: Direct election battle just beginning While the Australian Republican movement comes to terms with ...
VIC: Direct election republicans gearing up for battle
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-07-1999 VIC: Direct election republicans gearing up for battle While the Australian Republican movement comes to ...
SA: O Donoghue appeals to direct election voters to vote Yes
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 11-04-1999 SA: O Donoghue appeals to direct election voters to vote Yes ADELAIDE, Nov 4 AAP - Aboriginal leader Lowitja ...
FED: Beazley proposes direct election referendum
AAP General News (Australia) ; AAP General News (Australia) 09-26-1999 FED: Beazley proposes direct election referendum Opposition Leader KIM BEAZLEY has proposed a referendum ...