Home > Categories > History > Modern Europe > Russian, Soviet, and CIS History > Slavophiles and Westernizers

Slavophiles and Westernizers

From: The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition | Date: 2008

Slavophiles and Westernizers designation for two groups of intellectuals in mid-19th-century Russia that represented opposing schools of thought concerning the nature of Russian civilization. The differences between them, however, were not always clear cut. The Slavophiles held that Russian civilization was unique and superior to Western culture because it was based on such institutions as the Orthodox Eastern Church, the village community, or mir , and the ancient popular assembly, the zemsky sobor. The Slavophiles supported autocracy and opposed political participation; however, they also favored emancipation of serfs and freedom of speech and press. The Slavophiles became increasingly nationalistic; many ardently supported Pan-Slavism after Russia's defeat in the Crimean War (1854-56). Prominent among them were Ivan Kireyevsky, Aleksey Khomiakov, and Konstantin and Ivan Aksakov. The Westernizers believed that Russia's development depended on the adoption of Western technology and liberal government. In their approach they were rationalistic and often agnostic rather than emotional and mystical. Some remained moderate liberals, while others became socialists and political radicals. The leading Westernizers included Piotr Y. Chaadayev , Aleksandr I. Herzen , and Vissarion G. Belinsky .

Bibliography: See A. Walicki, The Slavophile Controversy (1975).

Author not available, SLAVOPHILES AND WESTERNIZERS., The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2008

The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. Copyright 2008 Columbia University Press

For permission to reuse this article, contact Copyright Clearance Center.

Related articles from HighBeam Research:

	The ideology of Russia's rulers in 1995: Westernizers and Eurasians. Monthly Review; 10/1/1995; Bilenkin, Vladimir; 4367 words; ... power. - In their political economy and social theory, the Westernizers have gone back to Adam Smith and his conception of the ... nineteenth-century ideas borrowed from the conservative wing of the Slavophiles, Dostoevsky, and the official ideology of the Russian ... a variety of national models. The contest ...
	As Mother Russia Stirs, Forces Compete to Chart Her Future The Washington Post; 9/23/1990; Michael Dobbs; 2329 words; ... debate between "westernizers" and "Slavophiles." The westernizers believe that ... countries. The Slavophiles insist that ... moment, the westernizers dominate the ... movement, today's Slavophiles are a heterogeneous ... course, the westernizers would almost ... program, the ...
	(book reviews) World Literature Today; 1/1/1995; Rollberg, Peter; 935 words; ... Russian culture of recent decades, while avoiding the stereotypes of loyal communists and dissidents, neo-Slavophiles and neo-Westernizers, and the like. Finally, I thought, there is somebody who has ventured to analyze that peculiar layer between ...
	Vladimir S. Soloviev and the politics of human rights. Journal of Church and State; 1/1/1999; Wozniuk, Vladimir; 8182 words; ... Russian debates between Slavophiles and westernizers.(6) This essay suggests ... alienate him from secular westernizers as well as Slavophiles. Representing a kind ... Socrates intolerable, many westernizers and Slavophiles found Soloviev's message ...
	A problem in self-identity: Russian intellectual thought in the context of the French Revolution. Journal of European Studies; 3/1/1996; Shlapentokh, Dmitry; 7014 words; ... entity. The so-called Westernizers saw Russia as following ... of the West while the Slavophiles viewed it as being the ... modification of the Slavophiles' belief that Russia ... Pavel Miliukov's Last News (Poslednie novosti ... Miliukov, editor of Last News, made explicit statements ... script. On ...
	SHARED MENTAL MODELS, CATCH-UP DEVELOPMENT AND ECONOMIC POLICY-MAKING: THE CASE OF GERMANY AFTER WORLD WAR II AND ITS SIGNIFICANCE FOR CONTEMPORARY RUSSIA Eastern Economic Journal; 7/1/2006; Zweynert, Joachim; 10539 words; ... strikingly referred to as "westernizers." A second group ... the clash between westernizers and romanticists ... conflict between westernizers and romanticists ... very much like the westernizers would finally gain ... dissent between "westernizers" and "easternizers ... remains divided into ...
	POWER PLAYS; Russia's Mixed-Up Moves Reveal Its Dangerous Divide . . . The Washington Post; 6/20/1999; Marshall I. Goldman; 1398 words; ... nationalists and Slavophiles, who are furious ... Russians--above all the Slavophiles-- view everything ... Even the modern-day Westernizers--who seek closer ... does not mean that Westernizers such as he aren ... While even the Westernizers were happy to see ... think much), the Westernizers ...
	Russia looks West -- and East Yeltsin's struggle reflects a centuries-old battle The Boston Globe; 3/21/1993; Fred Kaplan, Globe Staff; 1440 words; ... given way to the old conflict between Westernizers and nationalists," Oleg Rumyantsev ... to lay the struggle to rest. The Westernizers believe that Russia's salvation lies ... American -- ideas and institutions. The Slavophiles (as the nationalists are called in ... if not yet in force, because the ...
	Reassessment of the relationship: Polish history and the Polish question in the imperial duma. East European Quarterly; 3/22/1999; Shlapentokh, Dmitry; 8646 words; ... endless embarrassment. The Slavophiles were quite virulent in their ... monarchism of nineteenth century Slavophiles. For Slavophiles, the Russian monarchy was ... different from that of the Slavophiles. Slavophiles asserted that since Russian ... views to the ideas of other Westernizers, ...
	Utopian Nostalgia Russia's "New Idea". World Policy Journal; 9/22/1999; Feifer, Gregory; 4255 words; ... the free new media. Television news - even on the most independent ... Russian national idea. Cultural Westernizers grimace. Marat Gelman, a stalwart ... farfetched, for their own purposes. Westernizers vs. Slavophiles Since Peter the Great began openly ... cultural debates has been between ...
	The future of the Soviet Union. The Futurist; 11/1/1991; Hecht, James L. Modisett, Lawrence E.; 4291 words; ... adherents, traditionally known as Slavophiles, hold Russian culture to be superior ... this view, traditionally known as Westernizers, hold that Russia is historically ... Nonetheless, the strength of present-day Slavophiles was evidenced by Gorbachev's appointment ... found new vehicles of expression ... .
	The Rise of Russia and the Fall of the Soviet Empire Armenian Reporter, The; 9/9/1995; Ara Baliozian; 480 words; ... maintains here that the present turmoil in Russia is only the latest chapter in a centuries-old contest between Slavophiles and Westernizers. He divides the present Russian leadership into two camps and provides us with a series of biographical sketches ...
	Third Rome resurgent Ukrainian Weekly, The; 4/24/2005; Kuropas, Myron B.; 958 words; ... busy fine-tuning all three. The one-time intense, pre-Soviet intellectual debate between "Westernizers," who favored democratic processes, and "Slavophiles" who shunned Western ideals, is long past. Autocracy, part of the Russian condition since ...
	(book review) East European Quarterly; 6/22/2001; Zlatar, Zdenko; 10507 words; ... hostility of some of the Slavophiles and virtually all of the Westernizers; he spent thirty years ... subsequent scholars, but the Slavophiles as well: we know from Barsukov ... Unlike Kireevskii and other Slavophiles Pogodin eulogized Peter ...
	Eastward Bound, THE MOSCOW TIMES The Moscow Times (Russia); 5/14/2004; Walter Laqueur; 1078 words; ... continuation of the 19th-century identity debate between the Westernizers and the Slavophiles (Alexander Herzen's "ours" and "not ours"), except that the Westernizers have become fewer in number and that even disciples ... often heard in present-day discussions. Today's Neo-Slavophiles, Billington ...